We Tried Every Costco Burger & Here’s the Best (And The Worst)

Costco, a haven for bulk buyers and quality seekers alike, offers a diverse range of burger options that cater to various tastes and dietary preferences. From plant-based alternatives to classic beef patties, each product promises a unique culinary experience. In this blog post, we’ll explore twelve distinct burgers available at Costco, evaluating their flavor profiles, textures, and overall appeal. Whether you’re a beef enthusiast or a vegetarian on the lookout for the best options, this guide will help you navigate the Costco burger aisle with confidence. Join us as we dive into our comprehensive taste test and reveal the best and the worst Costco has to offer.

1. Don Lee Farms Organic Plant-Based Patties

Grainy, bland, and falling apart easily, Don Lee Farms Organic Plant-Based Patties lack the appeal of a hearty burger. Though these patties are certified organic, the flavor fails to impress, offering little more than a bland bite. The texture struggles to hold together, making it a challenge even for the most dedicated plant-based eaters. This patty might work in a pinch, but it’s unlikely to become a regular purchase. The absence of any robust flavors or satisfying texture leaves us questioning its place in the competitive world of plant-based burgers.

2. Amy’s Organic Sonoma Veggie Burgers

Amy’s Organic Sonoma Veggie Burgers promise a health-conscious choice but deliver a dry and bean-heavy experience. These patties feature a soft texture that doesn’t hold up well in a bun, limiting their versatility. While they might appeal to those seeking organic ingredients, the underwhelming flavor and crumbly texture detract from their appeal. If you’re desperate for a vegetarian option, they might suffice, but they’re not likely to win over any meat lovers. Despite their wholesome ingredients, these burgers lack the juicy satisfaction expected from a burger.

3. Dr. Praeger’s California Veggie Burgers

Dr. Praeger’s California Veggie Burgers are packed with greens and visible veggies, making them visually appealing but lacking burger satisfaction. These patties feel more like a frozen side dish than a hearty burger, leaving burger lovers craving more substance. While they might suit a light lunch, they’re not the choice for a BBQ star. Their texture and taste are more reminiscent of a vegetable medley than a cohesive patty. Those looking for a flavorful and satisfying veggie burger may find themselves disappointed by the lack of richness.

4. Kirkland Signature Turkey Burgers

Kirkland Signature Turkey Burgers present a lean and clean option, though they often come out dry. With great protein content, these patties are perfect for those counting macros, but they may not provide the juicy bite one expects from a burger. While they excel as a healthy choice, the lack of moisture can detract from the overall experience. Ideal for those focused on nutrition over indulgence, these burgers serve their purpose but may leave a little to be desired in taste and texture for the average burger enthusiast.

5. Boca All-American Veggie Burgers

Boca All-American Veggie Burgers carry a nostalgic vibe with their classic soy-based patties, but the experience can feel a bit dry. These burgers evoke memories of the original veggie burgers, capturing a piece of history in each bite. Though they lack juiciness and robust flavor, they have their place for those seeking an old-school veggie burger fix. Occasional enjoyment might be found in their familiar taste, but these aren’t likely to become a staple for those craving something new and exciting in the veggie burger realm.

6. MorningStar Farms Spicy Black Bean Burgers

MorningStar Farms Spicy Black Bean Burgers pack a flavor punch, but their texture remains mushy. These patties deliver a kick that spices up any meal, offering a distinct taste different from the usual veggie burger. While their spicy profile is appealing, they’re better suited for a wrap than a traditional bun, where their mushy texture can be masked. The bold flavors make them a fun choice for those looking to diversify their meals, but they might not satisfy those seeking the texture of a classic burger.

7. Kirkland Signature Angus Beef Patties

Kirkland Signature Angus Beef Patties offer consistency and ease of cooking, though they might be slightly underseasoned. These patties serve as a good base for those who love to load up on toppings, providing a reliable starting point for a weeknight dinner. While they may lack the bold flavors some seek, their straightforward nature makes them a versatile option. Perfect for busy nights, these patties get the job done without much fuss, appealing to those who appreciate a no-frills approach to burgers.

8. Impossible Burger Patties

Impossible Burger Patties defy expectations with their shockingly meaty taste. Juicy and flavorful, these plant-based patties offer a convincing alternative to beef, appealing even to meat-eaters. Their impressive texture and rich taste make them a top choice for those seeking a satisfying plant-based option. Whether for a casual dinner or a special occasion, these patties deliver on both flavor and texture. Their ability to mimic beef so closely sets them apart in the plant-based world, making them a worthwhile addition to any burger lineup.

9. Beyond Meat Plant-Based Patties

Beyond Meat Plant-Based Patties provide a slightly firmer texture than their Impossible counterparts, with a savory char that closely resembles beef. Their robust taste and satisfying consistency make them a favorite for grill nights. While they might not be indistinguishable from meat, their impressive flavor profile and texture bring them close. Perfect for those looking to enjoy a plant-based meal without sacrificing taste, these patties offer a compelling alternative. Their appeal lies in the balance between authenticity and innovation, delighting both seasoned vegetarians and curious carnivores.

10. Kirkland Signature Sirloin Beef Patties (1/3 lb)

Kirkland Signature Sirloin Beef Patties (1/3 lb) bring richness and beefy satisfaction to the table. These perfectly fatty patties maintain their shape while delivering the authentic burger experience many crave. Ideal for summer grilling, they hold their own and satisfy burger aficionados with each bite. Their robust flavor and satisfying texture make them a must-have for any serious burger lover. Whether enjoyed at a family barbecue or a solo dinner, these patties bring the taste of a classic burger to life, making them a repeat purchase.

11. Pre-Cooked Grass-Fed Beef Patties (Good Food Made Simple)

Pre-Cooked Grass-Fed Beef Patties from Good Food Made Simple surprise with their flavor and juiciness. For a pre-cooked option, these patties offer clean ingredients and a satisfying taste, making them ideal for fast weeknight dinners. Their convenience doesn’t compromise their quality, as they deliver on both taste and ease of preparation. Their grass-fed origin adds a touch of quality that discerning customers appreciate. Whether you’re in a hurry or just looking for a reliable option, these patties fit seamlessly into a busy lifestyle without sacrificing flavor.

12. Steakhouse Reserve Angus Beef Patties

Steakhouse Reserve Angus Beef Patties stand out with their juicy, thick composition and rich beefy flavor. These patties require no condiments, showcasing their quality in every bite. Perfect for those who value simplicity and taste, they offer a gourmet experience at home. Ideal for any burger lover, these patties elevate the meal with their impressive flavor and satisfying texture. Whether enjoyed on a quiet evening or a lively gathering, these are the burgers to beat at Costco, embodying the pinnacle of what a beef patty should be.