The Best Pie Shop in Every State, #12 Will Surprise You

Discover the most delightful pie destinations across the United States. From traditional favorites to innovative flavors, each state offers a unique slice of heaven. Join us as we explore the best pie shops, uncovering the local charm and delicious secrets that make each one special.

1. Pie Lab (Greensboro)

In Greensboro, Alabama, Pie Lab is more than just a bakery—it’s a social enterprise. With its heartwarming mission, this charming spot serves up Southern-style pies bursting with flavor. Imagine savoring a slice of pecan pie, where the rich, nutty filling meets a perfectly flaky crust. Chocolate chess pie fans will also find their sweet tooth satisfied. The community-centric vibes make each visit feel like coming home. Founded to bring people together, Pie Lab succeeds deliciously.

2. A Pie Stop (Anchorage)

Anchorage’s A Pie Stop brings the rugged beauty of Alaska into every pie. Known for their rustic, homemade treats, this shop celebrates local ingredients. Picture a pie filled with wild Alaskan berries, their vibrant colors and fresh taste creating a delightful experience. Each bite offers a taste of the wilderness, with hearty flavors that comfort and satisfy. A Pie Stop embodies the spirit of Alaska, connecting people through their shared love for pie.

3. Pie Snob (Phoenix)

Phoenix’s Pie Snob takes pride in crafting pies that are as beautiful as they are delicious. With a commitment to quality, they offer flaky crusts and bold fillings. Seasonal favorites like lemon meringue and coconut cream are just the beginning. Each pie is a testament to their dedication, bringing a touch of elegance to classic flavors. For those seeking a refined pie experience, Pie Snob delivers with style and taste.

4. PattiCakes Bakery (Conway)

In the heart of Conway, Arkansas, PattiCakes Bakery offers a warm embrace with every pie. Known for their chocolate chip pecan pie, this bakery captures the essence of small-town charm. The friendly staff and inviting atmosphere make each visit special. Imagine a pie where chocolate and pecans blend harmoniously, creating a rich, satisfying dessert. PattiCakes is a local treasure, where tradition and love are baked into every slice.

5. I Like Pie Bake Shop (Claremont)

Claremont’s I Like Pie Bake Shop brings creativity to the pie scene with personal-sized delights. Sweet and savory options abound, each crafted with care. From classic apple to innovative flavors, these pies are a feast for the eyes and taste buds. The shop’s charm lies in its attention to detail, making each pie a miniature masterpiece. Perfect for those seeking variety, I Like Pie offers a delightful twist on tradition.

6. Gold Star Pies (Fort Collins)

In Fort Collins, Colorado, Gold Star Pies offers a pie experience with a twist. Operating from a charming truck, they serve up flaky-crusted pies made from fresh, farm-to-fork ingredients. Each slice tells a story of quality and passion. Imagine enjoying a pie outdoors, where the simple pleasure of good food brings people together. Gold Star Pies is a mobile delight, bringing pie happiness to every corner of town.

7. Michele’s Pies (Norwalk)

Michele’s Pies in Norwalk, Connecticut, is a champion in the world of pies. With multiple national awards, their creations are renowned for excellence. The bourbon pecan and maple pumpkin pies are must-tries, offering a symphony of flavors. Each pie is a testament to Michele’s skill and dedication. In a shop where tradition meets innovation, pie lovers find a haven. Michele’s Pies is where award-winning taste becomes a reality.

8. Willey Farms (Townsend)

In Townsend, Delaware, Willey Farms is a local gem where fresh, handmade pies take center stage. The market’s bakery offers a variety of flavors, each crafted with love and attention. From fruit-filled classics to unique creations, there’s a pie for every palate. Imagine the aroma of baking pies filling the air, inviting you to indulge. Willey Farms is more than a market—it’s a community hub where delicious moments are made.

9. Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village (Sarasota)

Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village in Sarasota, Florida, is legendary for its sky-high peanut butter cream pie. This iconic dessert draws visitors from near and far, eager to taste its creamy richness. Beyond pies, the restaurant embraces traditional Amish recipes, offering a true taste of heritage. Step into a world where time-honored flavors and warm hospitality create an unforgettable experience. Yoder’s is a slice of tradition you won’t want to miss.

10. The Pie Hole (Roswell)

In Roswell, Georgia, The Pie Hole stands as a beacon of Southern pie perfection. Not to be confused with its namesake chain, this local bakery offers dense, satisfying pies that capture the essence of the South. Each slice is a journey into rich flavors, with options like pecan pie that delight the senses. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make every visit feel like family. The Pie Hole is a Southern delight worth savoring.

11. The Right Slice (Lihue, Kauai)

The Right Slice in Lihue, Kauai, brings tropical flavors to the pie scene with creations like mango lilikoi. Each pie bursts with vibrant taste, capturing the essence of Hawaii. The shop’s focus on fresh, local ingredients ensures quality in every bite. Imagine indulging in a slice that transports you to a paradise of flavors. The Right Slice is a Hawaiian treasure, where every pie is a taste of the islands.

12. Birdie’s Pie Shop (Coeur d’Alene)

In Coeur d’Alene, Idaho, Birdie’s Pie Shop is a hidden gem that surprises and delights. Known for scratch-made pies, this shop offers a variety of flavors from huckleberry to peanut butter. Each pie is crafted with care, ensuring a taste sensation in every slice. The shop’s unassuming charm hides a world of delightful creations. Birdie’s is where unexpected flavors and comforting classics come together in perfect harmony.

13. Hoosier Mama Pie Company (Chicago)

In Chicago, Illinois, Hoosier Mama Pie Company is beloved for its deep-dish fruit pies. Each creation is a testament to their commitment to quality and flavor. From apple to berry, these pies offer a taste of tradition with a modern twist. The rotating seasonal menu ensures there’s always something new to try. In a city known for culinary delights, Hoosier Mama stands out as a pie lover’s paradise.

14. Lisa’s Pie Shop (Atlanta, IN)

Lisa’s Pie Shop in Atlanta, Indiana, is known for its innovative pie-in-a-jar concept. This unique approach offers a convenient way to enjoy pie on the go. Classics like sugar cream and cherry are available in this portable format, ensuring a taste of home wherever you are. The shop’s down-home atmosphere and friendly service make it a cherished local spot. Lisa’s Pie Shop is where tradition meets creativity in every jar.

15. The Filling Station (Davenport)

In Davenport, Iowa, The Filling Station takes you back in time with its retro diner-style bakery. Known for mile-high pies, this spot offers a nostalgic taste of classic Americana. Picture a generous slice of cream pie, its towering layers tempting you with every bite. The atmosphere is as inviting as the pies, making it a beloved local haunt. The Filling Station is where old-school charm and deliciousness converge.

16. Upper Crust Pie Bakery (Overland Park)

Upper Crust Pie Bakery in Overland Park, Kansas, brings rustic charm to every pie. With a focus on flaky crusts and fresh ingredients, their creations delight the senses. Sweet and savory options are made daily, offering a taste of home-baked goodness. Picture a pie with a golden-brown top, its aroma filling the air. The bakery’s inviting atmosphere makes it a favorite for locals seeking comfort in every slice.

17. Missy’s Pies (Lexington)

In Lexington, Kentucky, Missy’s Pies offers iconic state favorites like derby pie, peanut butter pie, and coconut cream. Each pie celebrates Kentucky’s rich culinary heritage, with flavors that evoke a sense of nostalgia. Picture a derby pie, where chocolate and nuts create a decadent delight. The shop’s bustling atmosphere and friendly service invite you to indulge. Missy’s Pies is where tradition and taste come together in harmony.

18. Lea’s Lunchroom (Lecompte)

Lea’s Lunchroom in Lecompte, Louisiana, is a roadside legend known for its homemade pies. Their coconut and pecan pies draw pie lovers from across the state. Picture a coconut pie with a toasted top, its creamy filling inviting you to take a bite. The lunchroom’s rustic charm and welcoming vibe make it a beloved stop for travelers. Lea’s is where pie traditions live on, delighting all who enter.

19. Two Fat Cats Bakery (Portland)

In Portland, Maine, Two Fat Cats Bakery is known for its wild blueberry pies. The juicy berries, combined with a buttery crust, create a true New England treat. Each pie is crafted with care, ensuring a delightful taste experience. The bakery’s rustic, homey interior adds to its charm, inviting you to enjoy a slice with a cup of coffee. Two Fat Cats is a taste of Maine’s pie heritage, cherished by locals and visitors alike.

20. Dangerously Delicious Pies (Baltimore)

Baltimore’s Dangerously Delicious Pies offers an edgy twist on traditional pies. With clever names and bold flavors, this shop stands out. From savory quiches to decadent chocolate pecan pies, there’s something for every palate. Each creation is a testament to their innovative spirit, inviting you to explore new taste adventures. Dangerous in name, delicious in nature, this pie shop is a must-visit for adventurous foodies.

21. Petsi Pies (Somerville)

In Somerville, Massachusetts, Petsi Pies is celebrated for its handmade crusts and homey fillings. Specialties like blueberry, key lime, and pear ginger pies delight the senses. Each pie is a labor of love, crafted with attention to detail. Picture a key lime pie, its vibrant green filling offering a burst of citrusy goodness. The shop’s cozy atmosphere makes every visit feel like coming home. Petsi Pies is where comfort and flavor meet.

22. Grand Traverse Pie Company (Traverse City)

In Traverse City, Michigan, Grand Traverse Pie Company is famous for its cherry pies. Made with local tart cherries, these pies are a celebration of Michigan’s bounty. The bright red cherries, nestled in a buttery crust, create a symphony of flavors. Each slice tells a story of tradition and quality, inviting you to savor every bite. In a state known for its cherries, this pie shop is a cherished destination.

23. Rustic Inn Café (Two Harbors)

In Two Harbors, Minnesota, Rustic Inn Café offers classic cream pies that keep road-trippers and locals coming back. Their caramel apple pie, with its golden-brown crust, is a standout. Each pie is crafted with care, ensuring a taste of tradition in every slice. The café’s welcoming atmosphere and picturesque location make it a favorite stop. Rustic Inn Café is where classic flavors and warm hospitality create a memorable experience.

24. Sugaree’s Bakery (New Albany)

In New Albany, Mississippi, Sugaree’s Bakery embodies the rich soul of Southern baking. Their pies, like the fudge pie, offer a decadent taste of the South. Each creation is a sweet masterpiece, crafted with love and tradition. Picture a fudge pie with a rich, glossy finish, its chocolatey goodness inviting you to indulge. The bakery’s charm and dedication to quality make it a beloved local treasure.

25. Peggy Jean’s Pies (Columbia)

In Columbia, Missouri, Peggy Jean’s Pies offers creative takes on classic flavors. Their French silk and bourbon chocolate pecan pies are standout choices. Each pie is crafted with love, ensuring a taste sensation in every bite. Picture a French silk pie, its smooth chocolate filling offering a decadent delight. The family-run atmosphere and friendly service make it a cherished local spot. Peggy Jean’s is where creativity and tradition blend beautifully.

26. Loula’s Café (Whitefish)

Loula’s Café in Whitefish, Montana, is famed for its fresh huckleberry pies. Made with locally foraged berries, these pies offer a taste of Montana’s wild beauty. Picture a pie with a rustic lattice crust, its vibrant berries peeking through. Each slice is a celebration of nature’s bounty, crafted with care and tradition. The café’s cozy setting and warm hospitality make it a favorite for locals and visitors alike.

27. Village PieMaker (Omaha)

In Omaha, Nebraska, Village PieMaker offers handmade frozen pies that bake up bakery-quality. Known for their peach and cherry pies, this shop delivers convenience without compromising taste. Picture a peach pie with a golden, flaky crust, its aroma filling your home. Each pie is crafted with care, ensuring a taste sensation even from your own oven. Village PieMaker is where quality meets convenience, bringing pie joy to all.

28. Great Buns Bakery (Las Vegas)

In Las Vegas, Nevada, Great Buns Bakery is known for its homemade pies. While famous for their breads, their pecan and lemon pies are local secrets. Picture a pecan pie with a rich, nutty filling, its flavors melding beautifully with a flaky crust. The bakery’s bustling atmosphere and dedication to quality make it a beloved spot for pie lovers. Great Buns is where bakery excellence extends beyond bread.

29. Henniker Bakery & Café (Henniker)

In Henniker, New Hampshire, Henniker Bakery & Café is a small-town gem where warm pies are baked daily. Their apple crumb pie, with its golden, crumbly top, is especially loved. Each pie is crafted with attention, offering a taste of home-baked goodness. The bakery’s cozy atmosphere and friendly service invite you to indulge in a slice. Henniker Bakery is where community and flavor come together in harmony.

30. The Pie Store (Montclair)

In Montclair, New Jersey, The Pie Store offers a British-inspired pie experience. Savory and sweet options abound, each crafted with authenticity and flavor. The sticky toffee pudding pie, with its caramel drizzle, is unforgettable. Each pie is a taste of Britain, bringing a touch of tradition to American shores. The shop’s quaint atmosphere and dedication to quality make it a favorite for pie enthusiasts. The Pie Store is where British charm meets delicious bites.

31. Pie-O-Neer (Pie Town)

In Pie Town, New Mexico, Pie-O-Neer offers a quirky and delicious pie experience. Known for regional specialties like green chile apple pie, this shop stands out. Each pie is a testament to the area’s culinary uniqueness, offering a taste adventure in every bite. The shop’s remote location and charming vibe make it a must-visit for pie lovers. Pie-O-Neer is where regional flavors and pie passion converge beautifully.

32. Four & Twenty Blackbirds (Brooklyn)

In Brooklyn, New York, Four & Twenty Blackbirds is famous for its inventive pie flavors. With options like salted caramel apple and black bottom oat, this shop pushes the boundaries of taste. Each pie is a creative masterpiece, crafted with precision and flair. The shop’s trendy atmosphere and dedication to quality make it a beloved destination for pie enthusiasts. Four & Twenty Blackbirds is where innovation and tradition deliciously meet.

33. Carolina Pie Company (Mooresville)

In Mooresville, North Carolina, Carolina Pie Company offers perfectly balanced Southern favorites. Their coconut custard and chocolate fudge pies are must-haves. Each pie is crafted with care, ensuring a delightful taste experience. Picture a coconut custard pie with a creamy, toasted top, its flavors evoking a sense of nostalgia. The bakery’s cozy setting and friendly service make it a cherished local spot. Carolina Pie Company is where Southern charm and deliciousness harmoniously blend.

34. Nichole’s Fine Pastry (Fargo)

In Fargo, North Dakota, Nichole’s Fine Pastry offers a refined pie experience. Known for beautiful fruit pies and French-style desserts, this bakery delights the senses. Picture a raspberry pie with a lattice crust, its vibrant filling peeking through. Each pie is a testament to quality and artistry, crafted with precision. The bakery’s elegant atmosphere and dedication to excellence make it a favorite for pie connoisseurs. Nichole’s Fine Pastry is where beauty and flavor deliciously meet.

35. Just Pies (Westerville)

In Westerville, Ohio, Just Pies is a staple offering dozens of pie varieties. Baked fresh daily, these pies are a celebration of flavor and tradition. Picture a blueberry pie with a golden, flaky crust, its aroma inviting you to indulge. Each pie is crafted with love and care, ensuring a delightful experience. The shop’s bustling atmosphere and dedication to quality make it a beloved destination for pie lovers. Just Pies is where variety and deliciousness meet beautifully.

36. Pie Junkie (Oklahoma City)

In Oklahoma City, Pie Junkie offers creative pie flavors that delight the senses. The Drunken Turtle and peanut butter chocolate pies are standout choices. Each pie is crafted with innovation, ensuring a taste adventure in every bite. Picture a Drunken Turtle pie with caramel and chocolate, its richness inviting you to indulge. The shop’s trendy atmosphere and dedication to quality make it a favorite for pie enthusiasts. Pie Junkie is where creativity and deliciousness beautifully converge.

37. Lauretta Jean’s (Portland)

In Portland, Oregon, Lauretta Jean’s is renowned for its buttery crusts and seasonal fruit pies. The standout lemon sour cream pie offers a burst of citrusy goodness. Each pie is a testament to quality and flavor, crafted with care. Picture a lemon sour cream pie with a vibrant, glossy finish, its tangy sweetness inviting you to indulge. The shop’s cozy atmosphere and dedication to excellence make it a beloved local spot. Lauretta Jean’s is where seasonal flavors and pie perfection meet.

38. Dutch Haven Shoofly Pie Bakery (Ronks)

In Ronks, Pennsylvania, Dutch Haven Shoofly Pie Bakery has been serving traditional shoofly pies since 1946. These iconic pies are a taste of Amish country, with their crumbly brown sugar topping and sweet filling. Each slice is a journey into Pennsylvania’s rich culinary heritage, crafted with authenticity and care. The bakery’s dedication to tradition and flavor makes it a cherished destination for pie lovers. Dutch Haven is where history and deliciousness come together harmoniously.

39. Providence Pie Co. (Providence)

In Providence, Rhode Island, Providence Pie Co. may be small, but it’s mighty in flavor. Known for flavorful hand pies and rustic full-sized slices, this shop delights the senses. Each pie is crafted with care, ensuring a taste sensation in every bite. Picture a rustic full-sized pie with a golden crust, its aroma inviting you to indulge. The shop’s dedication to quality and flavor makes it a favorite for pie enthusiasts. Providence Pie Co. is where small size meets big taste beautifully.

40. Kudzu Bakery (Georgetown)

In Georgetown, South Carolina, Kudzu Bakery offers Southern classics like pecan and sweet potato pies. Each pie is a taste of tradition, crafted with love and care. Picture a pecan pie with a rich, nutty filling, its flavors inviting you to indulge. The bakery’s Southern charm and dedication to quality make it a beloved local spot. Kudzu Bakery is where tradition and deliciousness meet harmoniously, offering a true taste of the South.

41. Bobkat’s Purple Pie Place (Custer)

In Custer, South Dakota, Bobkat’s Purple Pie Place is a touristy yet beloved pie shop known for its homemade triple berry pies. Each pie is a celebration of vibrant flavors, with berries nestled in a golden crust. The shop’s quirky atmosphere and dedication to quality make it a favorite stop for visitors and locals alike. Bobkat’s is where fun and deliciousness converge, offering a memorable pie experience for all who enter.

42. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop (Knoxville)

In Knoxville, Tennessee, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop offers mini pies that pack a punch of flavor. With rotating seasonal options, there’s always something new to try. Picture a banana cream pie with a smooth, creamy topping, its sweetness inviting you to indulge. The shop’s cozy atmosphere and friendly service make it a cherished local spot. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is where small pies bring big smiles, offering a delightful taste experience.

43. Emporium Pies (Dallas)

In Dallas, Texas, Emporium Pies offers stylish, high-quality creations that delight the senses. The Drunken Nut and deep-dish Lord of the Pies are standout choices. Each pie is a testament to craftsmanship and flavor, crafted with care and precision. Picture a Drunken Nut pie with a deep dish and glossy finish, its richness inviting you to indulge. The shop’s stylish atmosphere and dedication to excellence make it a favorite for pie enthusiasts. Emporium Pies is where style and substance deliciously meet.

44. Veyo Pies (Veyo)

Located near St. George, Utah, Veyo Pies is a crowd-favorite known for its banana cream and mountain berry pies. Each pie is a celebration of flavor, crafted with care and tradition. Picture a pie with vibrant berries and a creamy filling, its sweetness inviting you to indulge. The shop’s dedication to quality and taste makes it a beloved destination for pie lovers. Veyo Pies is where flavor and tradition meet beautifully, offering a slice of pie paradise.

45. Poorhouse Pies (Underhill)

In Underhill, Vermont, Poorhouse Pies is a tiny roadside stand with big flavor. Known for its raspberry rhubarb and maple walnut pies, this spot delights the senses. Each pie is crafted with love and attention, ensuring a taste sensation in every bite. Picture a raspberry rhubarb pie with a rustic appearance, its vibrant filling inviting you to indulge. The stand’s charm and dedication to quality make it a beloved local treasure. Poorhouse Pies is where small size meets big taste beautifully.

46. Proper Pie Co. (Richmond)

In Richmond, Virginia, Proper Pie Co. offers funky New Zealand-style hand pies and slices that delight the senses. Each pie is crafted with care, ensuring a taste sensation in every bite. Picture a sweet pie with a golden, flaky crust, its aroma inviting you to indulge. The shop’s funky atmosphere and dedication to quality make it a favorite for pie enthusiasts. Proper Pie Co. is where funky style and delicious flavor beautifully meet.

47. A La Mode Pies (Seattle)

In Seattle, Washington, A La Mode Pies is modern and fresh, offering marionberry and Mexican chocolate pies. Each pie is a testament to quality and innovation, crafted with care. Picture a marionberry pie with a vibrant berry filling and glossy finish, its sweetness inviting you to indulge. The shop’s modern atmosphere and dedication to excellence make it a beloved spot for pie lovers. A La Mode Pies is where innovation and tradition deliciously meet.

48. Apple Annie’s (Morgantown)

In Morgantown, West Virginia, Apple Annie’s offers homestyle pies made daily. Their apple crumb and peanut butter cream pies are especially beloved. Each pie is crafted with care, ensuring a taste of tradition in every bite. Picture an apple crumb pie with a golden, crumbly top, its flavors inviting you to indulge. The shop’s homestyle atmosphere and dedication to quality make it a cherished local spot. Apple Annie’s is where homestyle and deliciousness harmoniously meet.

49. Norske Nook (Osseo)

In Osseo, Wisconsin, Norske Nook is a Scandinavian bakery known for its award-winning pies. Lingonberry, blueberry cream, and sour cream raisin pies are standout choices. Each pie is crafted with care, ensuring a taste sensation in every bite. Picture a lingonberry pie with vibrant berries and a glossy finish, its flavors inviting you to indulge. The bakery’s Scandinavian charm and dedication to excellence make it a favorite for pie lovers. Norske Nook is where tradition and innovation deliciously meet.

50. Cowboy Café (Dubois)

In Dubois, Wyoming, Cowboy Café is a rustic roadside café known for its mile-high meringue and seasonal fruit pies. Each pie is crafted with care, ensuring a taste sensation in every slice. Picture a pie with a golden, fluffy meringue top, its flavors inviting you to indulge. The café’s rustic charm and dedication to quality make it a beloved stop for pie lovers. Cowboy Café is where rustic style and delicious flavor beautifully meet.