Ranking The Best (And Worst) Fast Food Fried Fish Sandwiches In The United States

Fast food fried fish sandwiches are a popular choice for seafood lovers across the United States. From the tangy tartar sauce to the crispy, golden-brown breading, these sandwiches offer a diverse range of flavors and textures. In this article, we rank the best and worst fast food fried fish sandwiches, considering factors like taste, texture, and overall satisfaction.

1. Long John Silver’s Classic Fish Sandwich

Long John Silver’s Classic Fish Sandwich is a straightforward delight. The thick, battered pollock filet topped with tangy tartar sauce and crisp crinkle-cut pickles makes for a satisfying bite. The fish is cooked to perfection, with a golden crust that offers just the right amount of crunch.

For many, it stands as a favorite due to its simplicity and consistency. There’s no need for fancy additions; the uncomplicated flavors speak for themselves. If you’re seeking comfort in a classic fish sandwich, Long John Silver’s delivers reliably. Perfect for those who appreciate timeless flavors.

2. Burger King Fiery Big Fish

Burger King’s Fiery Big Fish is not your typical fish sandwich. It teases the palate with a spicy glaze that complements the crisp, panko-breaded filet. This daring twist doesn’t overshadow the fish’s natural flavor but enhances it, creating a balanced taste that excites the senses.

The sandwich is an upgrade from the regular version, offering a punch of heat without being overwhelming. For those who enjoy a little kick in their meal, the Fiery Big Fish is a must-try. It marries spice with seafood in a deliciously innovative way.

3. Burger King Big Fish (Classic)

The classic Burger King Big Fish sandwich maintains its popularity with a moist and well-balanced offering. Available year-round, it stands as a reliable mid-range pick for fast food enthusiasts.

The fish filet is tender, and the combination of tartar sauce and lettuce adds a refreshing touch. Consistency is key here, as Burger King ensures that each bite delivers the expected flavors without fail.

For those who seek a dependable option, this sandwich provides satisfaction without surprises. It’s the go-to choice for a straightforward fish sandwich experience.

4. Popeyes Classic Flounder Sandwich

Popeyes Classic Flounder Sandwich offers a taste of something homemade in the fast food realm. The crispy, thick-breaded filet is complemented by a well-seasoned coating, providing a flavorful punch.

Toppings are artfully balanced, ensuring that each bite offers a harmonious blend of taste and texture. It’s a sandwich that stands out for its quality, reminiscent of a home-cooked meal rather than a typical fast food offering.

For those seeking a comforting yet exciting bite, Popeyes delivers a classic that never goes out of style.

5. Popeyes Spicy Flounder Sandwich

The Spicy Flounder Sandwich at Popeyes brings a Cajun kick to the table. All the flavor of the classic with an added spicy twist, this sandwich spices things up without overshadowing the fish’s natural taste.

The crispy breading, infused with well-balanced spices, delivers a delightful heat that complements rather than dominates. Fresh toppings complete the experience, offering a refreshing contrast to the spiciness.

For fans of bold flavors, this sandwich is a must-try. It’s a perfect blend of spice and substance that ignites the taste buds.

6. Wendy’s Crispy Panko Fish Sandwich

Wendy’s Crispy Panko Fish Sandwich brings a bright note to the menu with its extra crunchy texture. The panko breading ensures a satisfying crispiness, while the dill-tartar sauce adds an unexpected brightness.

This sandwich is particularly popular during springtime, making it a favorite for Easter feasts. The freshness of the lettuce and the tangy sauce create a contrast that leaves a memorable impression.

For those seeking something seasonally delightful yet consistently delicious, Wendy’s offers a springtime treat that captures the essence of renewal.

7. Arby’s Crispy Fish Sandwich

Arby’s Crispy Fish Sandwich serves up a decent flavor profile with its crispy filet and tangy tartar sauce. The sesame bun adds a unique touch, although the topping distribution can sometimes be uneven.

This sandwich strikes a balance between taste and texture, offering a satisfactory bite. While not groundbreaking, it remains a reliable choice for those seeking a simple yet flavorful fish sandwich experience.

Arby’s consistency in delivering comfort through familiar flavors makes this a staple for many fast food lovers.

8. Arby’s King’s Hawaiian Fish Deluxe

The King’s Hawaiian Fish Deluxe from Arby’s offers a novel twist with its sweet Hawaiian roll. This addition adds character to what is otherwise similar to the Crispy version, enhancing the overall experience.

The sweetness of the roll pairs interestingly with the tangy tartar sauce and crispy fish filet. While not extraordinary, it’s a solid option for those looking for something a bit different.

Arby’s masterfully combines familiar flavors with a touch of innovation, making this sandwich a noteworthy choice for adventurous eaters.

9. Dairy Queen Wild Alaskan Fish Sandwich

Dairy Queen’s Wild Alaskan Fish Sandwich is an interesting mix of textures. It offers a crispy bite but is let down by overly saucy presentation. The thin breading leaves the fish somewhat overwhelmed by the abundance of tartar.

For those who enjoy a saucier sandwich, this may be a plus. However, it can be a bit too much for those who prefer the fish to be the star of the show.

It’s a bold, albeit messy, offering that caters to specific tastes, making it a divisive option in the fast food fish realm.

10. McDonald’s Filet‑O‑Fish

McDonald’s Filet‑O‑Fish is a nostalgic classic. Its iconic status is undeniable, even if the flavor profile is sometimes considered bland. The combination of a steamed bun, fish filet, tartar sauce, and a slice of cheese creates a unique yet comforting taste.

For those who grew up enjoying this sandwich, it offers a sense of comfort and familiarity. However, some may find the sauce too watery and the portion skimpy.

It’s best appreciated for its simplicity and iconic status rather than quality, a staple since 1962.

11. Culver’s North Atlantic Cod Sandwich

Culver’s North Atlantic Cod Sandwich offers a hearty bite with its thick breading. However, this thickness tends to mask the fish rather than complement it, leaving more breading than substance.

The tartar sauce is heavy on relish, adding a tangy note that some might find too overpowering. It’s a sandwich that aims to provide fullness but may fall short in flavor balance.

For those who love a substantial breading experience, this is a fitting choice, though it might not satisfy those craving pure fish flavor.

12. Popeyes Spicy Flounder (if extremely spicy)

For spice enthusiasts, Popeyes Spicy Flounder, when at its most fiery, pushes boundaries. The spices can be overwhelming, often outpowering the natural flavor of the fish.

This variation is intense, best for those who crave a fiery kick that lingers. However, it’s not for the faint of heart, as the heat can be overpowering.

If you seek an adventurous, spice-filled experience, this sandwich offers a challenge. But approach with caution, as it’s a bold choice in the realm of spicy fast food offerings.

13. Sonic Fish Sandwich

The Sonic Fish Sandwich tends to disappoint with its bland, chewy texture. Critics often point to its lack of authentic fish flavor and odd taste, making it a less favorable option.

The sandwich fails to stand out and does not deliver the satisfying bite expected from a fast food fish offering.

For those with a discerning palate, this may not be the best choice, lacking the excitement or quality found in other options. It’s a reminder that not every fish sandwich hits the mark.