Ranking Jersey Mike’s Top 9 Sandwiches From Best To Worst

Jersey Mike’s has long been celebrated for its robust and flavorful sandwiches, each crafted with precision and passion. As a haven for sandwich aficionados, the menu boasts a wide array of choices, each more tantalizing than the last. In this post, we will rank the top 9 sandwiches from best to worst, offering a savory guide to the delights of Jersey Mike’s.

1. The Club Sub (#8)

Why has the Club Sub earned its spot at the top? It’s the perfect blend of simplicity and luxury. The turkey and ham provide a robust, meaty base, while the crispy bacon adds an irresistible crunch. Provolone ties everything together, making each bite a creamy delight. The addition of mayo offers a rich, smooth texture, enhancing the overall experience. Served ‘Mike’s Way,’ it bursts with freshness thanks to crips lettuce, ripe tomatoes, and onions. This sandwich is a harmonious symphony of flavors, a perfect balance of savory, smoky, and creamy, making it a standout choice.

2. Mike’s Famous Philly (#17)

Mike’s Famous Philly is a love letter to cheesesteak enthusiasts everywhere. Imagine tender slices of steak, perfectly grilled, mingling with sautéed peppers and onions. The American cheese melts luxuriously over the top, binding everything in a gooey embrace. This isn’t just a sandwich; it’s an experience of warmth and comfort. Every bite tells a story of culinary expertise, a melody of hearty and tangy notes. It’s a go-to for anyone craving a robust and satisfying meal. Dive into this hearty masterpiece, where each component shines in its role, creating a beloved classic.

3. The Original Italian (#13)

The Original Italian stands as a monument to traditional deli flavors. This sandwich is a powerhouse, combining five distinct meats: provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and pepperoni. Each layer offers a new texture and taste, from the creamy provolone to the spicy pepperoni. It’s bold, it’s briny, and it’s undeniably satisfying. With every bite, experience a burst of salty, savory, and slightly sweet flavors. This is not just a meal; it’s a journey through the rich, robust landscape of Italian deli history, offering a fulfilling and adventurous taste adventure.

4. Big Kahuna Chicken Cheesesteak (#55)

For those who like their sandwich with a kick, the Big Kahuna Chicken Cheesesteak is the perfect choice. It’s a medley of flavors, with tender grilled chicken at its heart. Onions and peppers dance around it, adding sweetness and crunch. Mushrooms introduce an earthy undertone, while jalapeños bring a fiery heat. All of this is enveloped in melted cheese, creating a spicy, savory, and satisfying meal. It’s a bold choice, not for the faint-hearted, yet it rewards those adventurous enough to try with a taste explosion that leaves a lasting impression.

5. Turkey and Provolone (#7)

Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication, and the Turkey and Provolone sandwich exemplifies this truth. Delicate slices of turkey provide a light yet flavorful base. Provolone adds a creamy richness, while fresh lettuce and juicy tomatoes bring a refreshing crunch. This sandwich is a lighter option, perfect for those seeking a satisfying yet not overwhelming meal. It’s a timeless classic, offering a sense of comfort and familiarity with every bite. Enjoy the subtle yet delightful harmony of flavors in this simple yet elegant creation that stands the test of time.

6. Club Supreme (#9)

Club Supreme takes the concept of a club sandwich and elevates it with an indulgent twist. Roast beef and turkey provide a robust foundation, while Swiss cheese adds a nutty, creamy layer. Bacon introduces a smoky crunch, and mayo rounds everything off with a smooth, luxurious texture. It’s a heavier option, offering a hearty meal for those seeking something substantial. The sandwich is a step up in richness and size, with each component playing a vital role. Enjoy a fulfilling experience that’s both decadent and delightful, perfect for a satisfying lunch or dinner.

7. Grilled Portabella & Swiss (#64)

For those seeking a vegetarian delight, the Grilled Portabella & Swiss is a revelation. Earthy portabella mushrooms are the heroes here, grilled to perfection. Swiss cheese melts smoothly over the top, creating a creamy, nutty layer. Lettuce and tomatoes add freshness and crunch, making this a balanced and satisfying option. It’s a flavorful journey, proving that meat-free doesn’t mean flavor-free. This sandwich offers a unique, mouthwatering experience, providing the richness of a traditional sandwich with a vegetarian twist. Relish in a delightful option that caters to all tastes.

8. Chipotle Cheesesteak (#43)

Prepare for a heatwave with the Chipotle Cheesesteak, where smokiness meets spice in perfect harmony. Steak and cheese form the base, offering a hearty, satisfying bite. The addition of chipotle mayo brings a fiery kick, adding depth and excitement. Peppers and onions contribute sweetness and crunch, creating a balance that’s both spicy and savory. This sandwich is all about bold flavors and adventurous tastes, making it a perfect choice for spice lovers. Indulge in a fiery creation that’s as exciting as it is delicious, offering a taste bud-tingling experience that’s hard to forget.

9. Tuna Fish (#10)

The Tuna Fish sandwich is a polarizing choice, loved by some and avoided by others. This creamy concoction features a fresh tuna salad, rich and flavorful. Lettuce and tomatoes add a refreshing crunch, creating a delightful contrast. It’s a classic choice, offering a taste of nostalgia with every bite. However, its richness can be overwhelming for some, making it a divisive option. This sandwich invites you to explore the depth of flavors that tuna can offer, providing a creamy, satisfying experience for those who dare to indulge.