Ranking Fast Food Pies: The Worst To The Best And 3 Surprising Hidden Gems

Fast food might be best known for burgers and fries, but pies? They’re the unsung heroes of the dessert menu. Some chains have perfected the balance of flaky crusts and gooey fillings, while others serve up sad, soggy regrets. Here’s the ultimate ranking of fast food pies from worst to best—plus three unexpected underdogs that deserve more attention.

1. Burger King’s Dutch Apple Pie

Burger King’s Dutch Apple Pie might not win any awards. The flavor is decent enough, but the crust often disappoints. Overbaked and dry, it lacks the flaky texture that makes a pie delightful. The filling, while sweet, can taste overly processed, reducing the dessert’s appeal.

This pie is not the worst on the menu, but it’s certainly not a standout either. For those seeking a comforting apple pie experience, this option may fall short. A sprinkle of nostalgia might be needed to enjoy this treat fully.

2. Popeyes Cinnamon Apple Pie

Fried and dusted with cinnamon sugar, Popeyes Cinnamon Apple Pie sounds like a dream. However, it can be hit-or-miss in reality. Sometimes undercooked, sometimes excessively greasy, this pie often struggles to deliver a consistent experience.

The apple flavor, a crucial element, tends to get lost in the crust, leaving a less satisfying bite. When it’s good, it’s decent, but when it’s not, it’s disappointing. A classic example of unfulfilled potential in the fast-food dessert world.

3. KFC Chocolate Chip Cake

Technically, KFC’s Chocolate Chip Cake isn’t a pie. However, it tries to fill that dessert void. Beware if you’re expecting a richness akin to chocolatey bliss. This option often turns out dry, leaving taste buds longing for moisture.

Though it has its moments, they are rare and fleeting. The cake’s dryness overshadows the potential for indulgence. Consider it an honorable mention for fast food dessert seekers who are pie fans at heart.

4. McDonald’s Baked Apple Pie

McDonald’s Baked Apple Pie is a classic in the fast-food dessert lineup. Nostalgia surrounds it, but has it lived up to its past glory? While it used to be fried and magical, today’s version is more wholesome than craveable.

The baked crust loses some of the crispiness that once made it special. It’s a comforting treat, but one that might not inspire the same longing as it once did. A piece of fast food history, now somewhat faded.

5. Bojangles’ Sweet Potato Pie

Bojangles’ Sweet Potato Pie is a warm embrace of Southern comfort. Its spiced filling, wrapped in a flaky crust, creates a satisfying and unique dessert experience. Unlike many fast food pies, it isn’t overly sweet.

This mini pie is a seasonal favorite, embodying the essence of a cozy autumn day. It’s comforting and delightful, making it a hidden gem that should be available year-round. A taste of the South in every bite.

6. Jollibee Peach Mango Pie

Jollibee’s Peach Mango Pie is a tropical delight in a crispy shell. The exterior is golden and crunchy, while the inside offers a lava-hot, syrupy-sweet experience. It perfectly balances tangy fruit flavors with indulgent richness.

This pie often steals the show from its savory counterparts. It’s an international sensation, bringing a burst of sunshine to the dessert menu. A true standout in the world of fast food pies.

7. McDonald’s Fried Apple Pie (International Version)

In select international markets, McDonald’s still offers its original Fried Apple Pie. This version is every bit as crispy, golden, and delicious as you might remember. It’s a nostalgic treat that deserves its top spot.

This pie’s international presence keeps the magic alive, offering a taste of what once was in the U.S. A call for its comeback echoes among avid fast-food lovers. It’s a piece of culinary nostalgia worth traveling for.

8. Church’s Chicken Apple Pie

Church’s Chicken Apple Pie combines the best of a churro and an apple pie. This cinnamon-sugar-coated, deep-fried pocket delivers a crunchy and sweet experience. Often overlooked, it’s a hidden gem in the fast-food dessert world.

With a satisfying texture and delightful flavor, it captures hearts and taste buds alike. It’s a unique offering that blends familiar tastes into something extraordinary. A delightful surprise for those willing to discover it.

9. Taco Bell Caramel Apple Empanada

Taco Bell’s Caramel Apple Empanada may be discontinued, but it remains legendary. Its gooey caramel and tart apple filling inside a flaky, handheld shell created a memorable dessert experience.

Those who tasted it remember the indulgence fondly. Though no longer available, its memory lingers, a testament to its popularity. A lost treasure in the fast-food dessert lineup.

10. Jack in the Box Mini Churros

Jack in the Box’s Mini Churros aren’t exactly a pie, but they embody the vibe of a fried dessert with a gooey center. These cinnamon-dusted sticks hit the sweet spot when you least expect it.

Quirky and playful, they surprise and delight with every bite. Perfect for those who crave something different yet familiar. A fun, pie-adjacent offering that keeps dessert lovers coming back.