Ranking 17 Ben & Jerry’s Flavors From Least To Greatest

Ben & Jerry’s doesn’t just make ice cream—they craft flavor-packed experiences in a pint. With everything from cookie chunks to caramel swirls, they’ve mastered indulgence. But not every flavor hits the same. Here’s our definitive ranking of 17 Ben & Jerry’s flavors—from the slightly underwhelming to the truly unforgettable.

1. Vanilla

Vanilla is like that reliable friend who’s always there but never steals the show. It provides a creamy base that enhances sundaes but lacks the pizzazz of more adventurous flavors. While the quality is unquestionable, it often feels more like a supporting character than the star of the pint. Its simplicity can be both a strength and a weakness, depending on what you’re in the mood for. For those who appreciate the understated elegance of vanilla, it’s a comforting choice, but it won’t satisfy those craving bold and unique taste adventures.

2. Chocolate Fudge Brownie

Ever had a chocolate craving that wasn’t fully satisfied? Chocolate Fudge Brownie promises decadence, yet sometimes falls just short of its potential. The brownie pieces are generous, but their texture can vary—sometimes perfectly gooey, other times a bit dry. This flavor is a chocolate lover’s dream in theory, but in practice, it might not hit all the right notes every time. Its consistent richness can become overwhelming without the contrast of other flavors. A good choice, but perhaps not as dynamic as some of its competitors.

3. Strawberry Cheesecake

Strawberry Cheesecake brings a sweet and tangy flair to the table, complete with a graham cracker crunch. While it captures the essence of a classic dessert, the strawberry flavor occasionally veers into artificial territory. This can be a turn-off for purists seeking a natural fruit taste. Nevertheless, it offers a delightful experience for those who enjoy a mix of creaminess and crunch. The cheesecake component adds a rich, smooth texture that complements the berry flavor, making it a charming yet imperfect choice in the lineup.

4. Cherry Garcia

Cherry Garcia is the rock star of Ben & Jerry’s, with a legacy as beloved as its namesake. It blends cherry ice cream with rich fudge pieces, creating a nostalgic treat that many adore. However, the combination doesn’t always mesh perfectly, with cherry chunks occasionally disrupting the smooth harmony of flavors. This iconic flavor remains popular for its unique profile and cultural significance, even if it’s not the most exciting option. For fans of fruity and chocolatey blends, Cherry Garcia remains a solid choice, offering a taste of history in every bite.

5. Coffee Coffee BuzzBuzzBuzz!

Are you a caffeine enthusiast? Coffee Coffee BuzzBuzzBuzz! is made for those who love their java strong and bold. The coffee flavor is intense, almost like having a shot of espresso in ice cream form. It’s invigorating but might be overpowering for those with a milder palate. The chocolate espresso bean crunch adds a delightful texture and an extra kick of flavor. Fans of this flavor relish its robust profile, but it’s not for the faint of heart. If you crave a wake-up call in your dessert, this one’s for you.

6. Gimme S’more!

Gimme S’more! takes you back to campfire nights with its marshmallow, graham, and chocolate medley. It’s a sweet symphony that captures the essence of s’mores in a single pint. While delightful, the flavor can tip into overly sweet territory, leaving some yearning for balance. The texture feels sticky, mimicking the gooiness of roasted marshmallows. Fans of this flavor appreciate its nostalgic comfort, though it might not appeal to those seeking a more refined taste experience. A playful choice for those who love a bit of sugary indulgence.

7. Peanut Butter Cup

Peanut Butter Cup is a dream come true for peanut butter aficionados. Its rich, creamy base is packed with substantial chunks of peanut butter cups, offering a texture that pleases with every bite. However, the richness can be overwhelming for some, making it more of an occasional indulgence than a daily delight. Its intense flavor profile caters to those who can’t get enough of peanut butter, yet it might be too much for the uninitiated. As far as peanut butter ice creams go, this one holds its ground with gusto.

8. Netflix & Chilll’d

Netflix & Chilll’d pairs perfectly with a binge-watching session, combining peanut butter, pretzels, and fudge into a salty-sweet experience. It’s a fun flavor that adds excitement to your taste buds, although the distribution of mix-ins can sometimes feel uneven. The contrasting textures keep things interesting, preventing any one note from dominating. This flavor is a hit among those who enjoy a bit of everything in their dessert. It caters to late-night snackers and adventurous eaters alike, offering a playful twist on traditional ice cream.

9. The Tonight Dough

The Tonight Dough is a late-night showstopper, packed with cookie dough and caramel swirls. It’s as chaotic as a comedy sketch, blending multiple elements into a pint of indulgence. The various textures and flavors make every spoonful a new adventure, though some might find it a bit overwhelming. It’s a love letter to those who embrace the richness of cookie dough and caramel. Whether you’re winding down after a long day or just seeking a sweet escape, The Tonight Dough offers a flavor-packed journey in every bite.

10. Milk & Cookies

Milk & Cookies takes a classic pairing and elevates it to new heights. The combination of chocolate chip cookies, chocolate cookies, and cookie dough creates a comforting flavor that’s hard to resist. Each bite is reminiscent of dunking cookies into a cold glass of milk, offering a nostalgic experience that delights the senses. The balance of flavors ensures no one element overshadows the others, making it a consistently satisfying choice. For those who appreciate a simple yet effective flavor profile, Milk & Cookies is a go-to favorite.

11. Phish Food

Phish Food swims into your senses with its gooey marshmallow and caramel swirls, accented by chocolate fish swimming through every scoop. It’s a harmonious blend that has won fans for its rich and balanced profile. The marshmallow brings a fluffy lightness, while the caramel adds depth and sweetness. Each spoonful offers a delightful mix of textures and flavors, making it a classic in the Ben & Jerry’s lineup. Phish Food’s playful nature and satisfying taste make it a favorite choice for those who enjoy a sweet, whimsical escape.

12. Americone Dream

Created in collaboration with Stephen Colbert, Americone Dream is a punny tribute to one of America’s favorite comedians. This flavor combines vanilla ice cream with caramel swirls and fudge-covered waffle cone pieces, creating a crunchy, creamy delight. It’s both sophisticated and playful, offering a mix of textures that keeps your taste buds entertained. Each bite is a reminder of why this flavor has become a legend in its own right. Fans of Americone Dream appreciate its balanced complexity and the way it pays homage to classic American treats.

13. Chunky Monkey

Chunky Monkey might sound like an oddball, but it’s got a charm that wins over the daring. Banana ice cream mingles with fudge chunks and walnuts to create a bold, unique flavor that’s anything but ordinary. The fruity base is complemented by the crunchy and sweet add-ins, making it a delightful surprise for those willing to try something different. It doesn’t shy away from its quirky identity and is loved for its adventurous spirit. If you’re looking for a flavor that stands out from the crowd, Chunky Monkey is a daring choice.

14. Half Baked

Half Baked combines the best of both worlds, featuring brownie batter and cookie dough in one deliciously indulgent pint. It’s a nostalgic flavor that captures the joy of licking the spoon after baking. The interplay of chocolate and vanilla ice creams provides a canvas for the rich mix-ins, ensuring every bite is a new adventure. Half Baked has become a staple for those who appreciate a balance of sweetness and texture, offering a comforting, familiar taste that never goes out of style. A beloved classic in Ben & Jerry’s repertoire.

15. Cinnamon Buns

Cinnamon Buns brings the warmth of a bakery-fresh treat into the frozen aisle. The cinnamon ice cream is infused with a luscious caramel swirl and chunks of cinnamon bun dough, replicating the gooey center of a cinnamon roll. It’s a flavor that evokes the comforting aroma of freshly baked pastries, providing a cozy, sweet experience. Fans love its ability to transport them to a Sunday morning brunch with just one scoop. Cinnamon Buns offers a unique twist on traditional ice cream flavors, making it a delightful choice for cinnamon lovers.

16. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough is the epitome of classic indulgence, blending soft, flavorful dough with a creamy vanilla base. It’s a flavor that has stood the test of time, beloved for its simplicity and reliable deliciousness. Each bite transports you back to childhood, sneaking cookie dough before it’s baked. The dough pieces are generously scattered throughout, ensuring a delightful surprise in every scoop. This flavor is a testament to the timeless appeal of cookie dough, offering a satisfying treat that resonates with ice cream lovers of all ages.

17. Salted Caramel Core

Salted Caramel Core is the showstopper that demands attention. With a thick, gooey center of salted caramel enveloped by chocolate and sweet cream ice creams, it tantalizes the taste buds with each bite. The interplay of salty and sweet creates a harmonious balance that delights the senses. It’s a flavor that pushes boundaries, offering a luxurious experience that elevates the concept of ice cream. Fans of Salted Caramel Core appreciate its boldness and indulgence, making it a must-try for those who crave a decadent dessert adventure.