Pancake Syrups Ranked Worst To Best

Pancakes without syrup? Not a chance. But not all syrups are created equal. Some are corn syrup-heavy disappointments that taste more like chemicals than maple, while others deliver rich, buttery goodness that elevates your stack to brunch heaven. Whether you’re loyal to the real stuff or open to flavored blends, here’s a definitive ranking of pancake syrups—from worst offenders to breakfast royalty.

1. Aunt Jemima (Original or Lite)

Aunt Jemima, recently rebranded as Pearl Milling Company, sits in the grocery aisle offering a stark reminder of what happens when corn syrup overshadows authentic flavor. The syrup, whether original or lite, boasts a consistency that many find unappealingly artificial. With its overly sweet profile, it lacks the depth that real maple enthusiasts crave. Despite its long-standing presence on breakfast tables, it struggles to stand up to the richer, more genuine syrups available today.

2. Great Value Original Syrup (Walmart)

Great Value Original Syrup from Walmart may offer budget-friendly pricing, but its flavor leaves much to be desired. Its thin, watery texture fails to provide the satisfying drizzle desired over a stack of pancakes. Moreover, the synthetic aftertaste, reminiscent of chemicals rather than nature, turns off true syrup lovers. While it may serve in a pinch, the syrup’s lack of genuine maple character makes it a less-than-ideal choice for those seeking something more authentic.

3. Hungry Jack Lite Syrup

For those keeping an eye on calories, Hungry Jack Lite Syrup may seem enticing. However, the trade-off often lies in flavor and texture. This lite version offers a watery consistency that fails to coat pancakes adequately. With its muted taste, the syrup doesn’t deliver the robust maple experience that breakfast aficionados yearn for. Its lackluster performance suggests that it’s often better to indulge in smaller servings of the real thing.

4. Mrs. Butterworth’s Original

Mrs. Butterworth’s Original syrup carries with it a wave of nostalgia, yet its flavor often falls short. Though the bottle’s iconic shape is memorable, its content remains overly sweet with minimal maple essence. The syrup’s one-dimensional taste doesn’t live up to the richness that genuine maple syrup aficionados expect. For some, it’s a beloved classic, but for those seeking depth and character in their syrup, alternatives might be worth exploring.

5. Log Cabin Original

Log Cabin Original syrup is frequently encountered in households, yet its taste can be somewhat misleading. This syrup promises the essence of maple but delivers an overwhelmingly sweet and artificial flavor. The absence of true maple undertones leaves a waxy residue on the palate, making it less than desirable for those with refined syrup tastes. For those who cherish the authenticity of maple, Log Cabin might not be the cabin retreat they’re searching for.

6. IHOP at Home Syrup

IHOP at Home Syrup attempts to bring the diner experience directly to your kitchen, yet often misses the mark. Its flavor is reminiscent of syrup found at diners, offering a sticky and overly sweet profile. While it may evoke memories of breakfast outings, the syrup lacks the complexity and depth expected from top-tier syrups. It’s a one-note experience, serving adequately in casual settings but not as a standout option among syrup connoisseurs.

7. Trader Joe’s Organic Maple Agave Syrup Blend

Trader Joe’s Organic Maple Agave Syrup Blend offers a blend that aims to bridge the gap between affordability and authenticity. While it presents an improvement over corn syrup-based options, the blend falls short of delivering the pure maple experience. Its flavor carries hints of maple and agave, offering a slightly more sophisticated taste. However, for those who seek the unadulterated richness of true maple, this blend serves as a middle-ground option.

8. Kroger Original Syrup

Kroger Original Syrup, often found on supermarket shelves, provides a surprising step above other generic brands. Though its thickness may appeal to some, the flavor remains primarily artificial with a syrupy sweetness. This syrup performs its job adequately but lacks the layered complexity that sets apart high-quality maple syrups. For those on a budget, it offers a serviceable option, but true maple enthusiasts will find themselves yearning for more authentic offerings.

9. Aunt Jemima Butter Lite

Aunt Jemima Butter Lite attempts to enhance its flavor profile with a buttery note, setting it apart from its original counterpart. However, it still falls short of capturing the essence of real maple syrup. The added butter flavor provides a slight improvement, yet the overall experience remains somewhat synthetic. While it might cater to those who appreciate a buttery twist, true maple syrup aficionados continue to seek syrups that offer genuine richness and depth.

10. Stonewall Kitchen Maple Syrup

Stonewall Kitchen Maple Syrup stands as a beacon for those who appreciate high-quality, authentic maple syrup. Its rich, genuine maple flavor is a standout, offering an indulgent experience that elevates any breakfast. Though its price reflects its quality, many find it a worthwhile investment for the unparalleled taste it provides. This syrup embodies what true maple enthusiasts seek, capturing the essence of maple trees with every pour.

11. 365 Organic Maple Syrup (Whole Foods)

365 Organic Maple Syrup from Whole Foods offers a commendable option for those seeking a pure maple experience without a hefty price tag. Its earthy, smooth taste resonates well with those who appreciate the natural sweetness of maple. This syrup presents a straightforward yet satisfying flavor, making it a reliable choice for breakfast lovers. Its organic nature adds to its appeal, providing a wholesome alternative for the discerning syrup aficionado.

12. Butternut Mountain Farm Maple Syrup

Butternut Mountain Farm Maple Syrup, a favorite from Vermont, captures the bold maple essence that enthusiasts cherish. Its deep flavor profile and smooth pour make it a top contender for those who admire the true taste of maple. This syrup’s ability to evoke the natural beauty of Vermont’s forests in each drizzle sets it apart. It’s a celebration of nature’s sweetness, offering a genuinely authentic experience for syrup lovers everywhere.

13. Crown Maple Syrup

Crown Maple Syrup takes pride in its small-batch production, delivering a smooth, refined taste that appeals to the discerning palate. Notes of caramel and vanilla complement its complex flavor profile, making it a luxurious choice for those who seek more than just sweetness. Its artisanal nature ensures a quality experience, transforming ordinary pancakes into a gourmet delight. For syrup connoisseurs, Crown Maple represents an exquisite indulgence.

14. Coombs Family Farms Maple Syrup

Coombs Family Farms Maple Syrup offers an organic, dark amber option that stands out for its rich maple character. Its not-too-runny consistency makes it easy to pour, showcasing the bold, authentic flavor that real maple lovers seek. This syrup is a testament to Coombs’ commitment to quality and tradition, providing a hearty taste that resonates with those who appreciate the depth of genuine maple. It’s a staple for breakfast enthusiasts.

15. Kirkland Signature Organic Maple Syrup (Costco)

Kirkland Signature Organic Maple Syrup from Costco delivers impressive value with its authentic, rich taste. This syrup provides a legitimate maple experience without being overly sweet, appealing to those who seek quality without breaking the bank. Its robust flavor profile makes it a reliable choice for both casual breakfasts and special occasions. For those who appreciate a genuine maple taste, Kirkland Signature offers one of the best bangs for your buck.

16. Anderson’s Pure Maple Syrup

Anderson’s Pure Maple Syrup is celebrated for its smooth, balanced profile that resonates with pure maple syrup lovers. Its 100% pure nature makes it an ideal choice for everything from pancakes to oatmeal. Real maple enthusiasts often swear by its quality, appreciating the authentic taste that’s hard to match. For those who yearn for the classic maple experience, Anderson’s offers a delightful embodiment of nature’s sweetest gift.