I Tried Every Soup At Panera And Here’s What’s Worth It (And What Isn’t)

From cozy classics to seasonal flops—here’s the honest ranking of Panera’s entire soup lineup. Panera Bread is known for comforting soups served in bread bowls, but let’s be real—not all of them are created equal. After tasting every soup currently available (and a few seasonal favorites), here’s the breakdown of which ones are worth slurping—and which ones you might want to skip.

1. Broccoli Cheddar Soup

Panera’s Broccoli Cheddar Soup steals the spotlight with its creamy, cheesy richness, harmoniously infused with tender broccoli and carrots. This beloved classic brings comfort in every spoonful, making it a fixture in their lineup. A warm baguette complements its savory depths perfectly.

In the world of soups, this one stands tall. As winter’s chill creeps in, it offers a cozy retreat. Whether you’re seeking solace or simply indulging a craving, the Broccoli Cheddar Soup is a sure-fire choice.

Its enduring popularity speaks volumes—a testament to its timeless appeal and comforting allure.

2. Autumn Squash Soup

Experience autumn in a bowl with Panera’s Autumn Squash Soup. Velvety smooth, it marries butternut squash, pumpkin, and a hint of curry into a symphony of flavors. Sweet and savory dance together, creating a delightful balance.

Though only available seasonally, it leaves a lasting impression with its unique blend that captures the essence of fall. Imagine sipping this by a window, watching leaves tumble—pure bliss.

A cup of this soup is like a warm hug, inviting and comforting. It’s limited-time nature makes it all the more special.

3. Chicken Tortilla Soup

Panera’s Chicken Tortilla Soup is a seasonal sensation that delivers bold flavor. Its spicy, smoky broth is packed with black beans, chicken, and corn—making every bite a fiesta in your mouth.

The crunch of tortilla strips on top adds a playful texture contrast. It’s a soup that demands attention, sparking joy with its vibrant taste.

Though it appears briefly on the menu, its impact is undeniable. A fan favorite, this soup brings warmth and excitement to chilly days, ensuring you’ll remember each tantalizing spoonful.

4. Bistro French Onion Soup

Panera’s Bistro French Onion Soup offers a savory escape to a quaint French café. With its deep broth and sweet caramelized onions, it’s a journey to culinary comfort. A cheesy crouton floats atop, melting into the soup, adding a rich and creamy finish.

Though not quite as robust as a traditional homemade version, it still satisfies with its comforting taste. Each spoonful whispers of nostalgia, evoking images of Parisian streets.

When you’re yearning for something familiar yet delightful, this soup is a delightful companion.

5. Southwest Corn Chowder

The Southwest Corn Chowder at Panera brings a taste of the southwest. Creamy and slightly spicy, it envelops roasted corn and bell peppers in a hearty embrace.

Its richness is balanced by a hint of spice, making it unique among its peers. This seasonal offering is like a summer sunset—warm, inviting, and full of flavor.

Perfect for those who love a little kick in their meal, it’s a celebration in a bowl. Every spoonful is a reminder of sunlit plains and vibrant cultures.

6. Ten Vegetable Soup

Panera’s Ten Vegetable Soup is a light, vegan-friendly option that whispers health. Though broth-based and on the simpler side, it showcases an array of vegetables, offering a fresh and nourishing experience.

Despite its wholesome nature, it lacks a certain zest, leaving some palates yearning for more. However, with a dash of hot sauce or paired with a savory side, it finds its stride.

Perfect for those seeking a light meal, it remains a staple for health-conscious patrons.

7. Turkey Chili

Panera’s Turkey Chili is a protein-packed bowl that aims to satisfy. Thick and hearty, it tries to offer the richness of traditional chili but falls slightly short in flavor complexity.

While it provides a filling meal, the spice blend feels somewhat muted, making it less memorable compared to bolder choices. However, it’s a comforting option for those seeking a milder taste.

Despite its shortcomings, it holds its place as a practical and warming dish for cooler days.

8. Cream of Chicken & Wild Rice Soup

The Cream of Chicken & Wild Rice Soup at Panera is mild and soothing. With chunks of chicken and rice nestled in a creamy broth, it offers a gentle embrace.

Though flavorful, some might find it lacking in seasoning, making it a bit understated for those who prefer bolder tastes. It’s uncomplicated, yet fulfilling in its simplicity.

Ideal for those seeking comfort without overwhelming flavors, it serves as a calming presence in Panera’s soup selection.

9. Homestyle Chicken Noodle Soup

Panera’s Homestyle Chicken Noodle Soup carries the promise of comfort but often falls short. While it offers the nostalgia of homemade soup, the broth can taste watery, with overly soft noodles that disappoint.

Despite its comforting theory, execution leaves much to be desired, lacking depth and vibrancy. It’s a missed opportunity in the world of comfort food.

For those who cherish the classic, homemade version, this might feel like a letdown, urging you to seek warmth elsewhere.

10. Lobster Bisque

Panera’s Lobster Bisque promises indulgence but delivers mixed results. Though rich in texture, the flavor leans more artificial, overshadowed by a fishy undertone that can be off-putting.

Its sweetness seems misplaced, detracting from what could be a lavish experience. It’s one of those dishes that sounds better on paper than it tastes.

For those seeking authenticity in seafood flavors, this might not be the ideal choice, leaving a quest for better options elsewhere.