I Tried 39 Flavors Of Crumbl Cookies And Ranked Them From Worst To Best

Exploring the universe of Crumbl Cookies can be an adventurous and flavorful journey. With 39 unique flavors in the lineup, each cookie brings its own twist and taste to the table. From the classic Pink Sugar to the indulgent Peanut Butter Brownie, the variety is endless. This ranking gives insight into each flavor, highlighting their distinct qualities and what to expect with each bite. Get ready to discover which Crumbl Cookies hit the sweet spot and which ones crumble under pressure.

1. Pink Sugar (Classic)

This cookie has gained notoriety among fans and critics alike for its overly sweet taste that leaves a lingering artificial aftertaste. Many have found its dryness to be a drawback, making it less appealing than other flavors. The signature pink hue may be visually appealing, but it doesn’t make up for the lack of flavor depth. Imagine biting into a cookie that promises so much with its vibrant color, but delivers little in terms of taste and texture. It’s a cookie that might look good on Instagram, but disappoints in reality.

2. Cotton Candy

The Cotton Candy flavor is a nostalgic nod to a childhood favorite, yet it misses the mark with its overwhelming sweetness. The taste of blue frosting prevails, overshadowing any subtlety the cookie might have offered. It’s a bold choice that might appeal to those with a strong sweet tooth, but lacks balance in its flavor profile. The cookie attempts to capture the whimsical essence of a fairground treat, but its execution is more regret than delight. For those seeking a nuanced experience, this might not be the cookie to choose.

3. Carrot Cake

Carrot Cake, a classic dessert turned cookie, struggles to live up to its roots. The soggy spiced base doesn’t quite capture the essence of a traditional carrot cake, and the cream cheese frosting overpowers rather than complements. Many expected a harmonious blend of flavors, but instead, this cookie feels unbalanced. The spices are there, but they don’t shine through as they should. For fans of the original cake, this cookie might be a letdown, lacking the rich, moist texture and flavor they love.

4. Peach Cobbler

Peach Cobbler offers a taste of southern comfort, but the texture leaves much to be desired. The cookie’s base tends to be soggy, making it a challenge to enjoy. The flavor is reminiscent of canned peaches, which doesn’t quite capture the fresh, juicy essence that one might hope for. While the idea is charming, the execution falls short, leaving a warm, mushy impression. It’s a flavor that aims to transport you to a sunny afternoon dessert, but instead, it feels more like a warm, mushy mistake.

5. Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Pie, often a refreshing dessert, takes on a different form in this cookie. The base crumbles easily, and the neon green filling might look appealing, but its tartness doesn’t quite hit the mark. It’s more key slime than key lime, leaving a sour impression that’s hard to shake. Fans of the traditional pie might find this cookie lacking the balance of sweet and tart that makes the original so beloved. In its attempt to capture the tropical essence, it misses out on the subtlety needed.

6. Strawberry Ice Cream Bar

The Strawberry Ice Cream Bar cookie attempts to bring a classic summer treat to life, but falls short in the flavor department. The fake strawberry taste overpowers the cookie, overshadowing any potential nuance. The dry base doesn’t help matters, making it difficult to enjoy the intended ice cream experience. While the concept is cute and playful, the execution leaves much to be desired, resulting in a cookie that might look appealing but leaves fans craving something more authentic.

7. Pumpkin Chocolate Chip

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip brings the warmth of fall spices and chocolate, but the cakey texture doesn’t satisfy as expected. While the autumn vibes are present, the cookie lacks the depth that could make it exceptional. The blend of pumpkin and chocolate is promising, yet the flavors don’t meld as harmoniously as they should. For those hoping to capture the essence of fall in a bite, this cookie might leave them wanting more. The promise is there, but the execution doesn’t fully deliver the cozy experience.

8. Lemon Glaze

Lemon Glaze offers a pleasant, yet unremarkable experience with its simple sugar cookie base dipped in a light lemon glaze. The flavor is refreshing and bright, but doesn’t stand out among more complex offerings. It’s a cookie that satisfies without overwhelming, making it a safe choice for those who prefer subtlety. While it might not be the star of the show, it holds its place as a reliable, if forgettable, option. The simplicity is its strength, but also its limitation, leaving some craving more excitement.

9. French Toast

The French Toast cookie captures the essence of a comforting breakfast treat with its strong cinnamon flavor. However, its soft and bready texture might not be what cookie enthusiasts are seeking. Missing the crunch or syrup drizzle that makes French toast delightful, this cookie feels like an incomplete version of its inspiration. For those craving the cozy familiarity of the breakfast classic, it offers warmth, but not without its shortcomings. A bit more crunch could elevate it to a more satisfying experience.

10. Raspberry Cheesecake

Raspberry Cheesecake promises a tart and creamy experience, yet the graham base tends to crumble into nothingness. The raspberry flavor shines with its vibrant tartness, but the contrast between the creamy filling and fragile base feels off-balance. While fans of cheesecake might appreciate the nod to a beloved dessert, this cookie’s execution doesn’t quite capture the luxurious texture expected. It’s a creative attempt, but the lack of structural integrity makes it a tricky treat to enjoy fully.

11. Chocolate Cake

Chocolate Cake is a chocoholic’s dream, offering layers of rich, indulgent chocolate flavor. However, the decadence may be overwhelming for some, as it’s a chocolate-on-chocolate-on-chocolate experience that could easily become too much. It’s a cookie that demands attention and should be savored slowly. For those who adore chocolate, it’s a delight, but for others, it might be a bit too intense. Finding the balance between indulgence and excess is key, and this cookie walks that line precariously.

12. Classic Peanut Butter

Classic Peanut Butter brings a familiar, nutty flavor to the table, offering a nice saltiness that complements its sweetness. However, its texture leans towards dry and crumbly, missing the rich chewiness that many love in a peanut butter cookie. It’s a classic that doesn’t quite hit the mark, leaving fans longing for a softer, more indulgent experience. While the flavor is right, the texture holds it back from reaching its full potential. For peanut butter enthusiasts, it satisfies but with room for improvement.

13. Mango Frozen Yogurt

Mango Frozen Yogurt is a unique venture into tropical flavors, offering a refreshing and unusual taste that intrigues the palate. While not a traditional cookie flavor, it stands out for its creativity and adventurous spirit. The mango flavor is bright, evoking images of tropical beaches and summer days. However, the uniqueness might not make it a crave-worthy choice for everyone. It’s a bold attempt at innovation, appreciated by those who enjoy a twist on the conventional. Props for trying something new, even if it isn’t for everyone.

14. Cookies & Cream Milkshake

The Cookies & Cream Milkshake cookie offers a sweet, creamy experience that mirrors its namesake, yet lacks the crunch that would elevate it to milkshake perfection. The flavors are enjoyable, reminiscent of childhood treats, but the texture doesn’t deliver the full experience expected. For fans of cookies and cream, it’s a playful nod to a classic, but it leaves some longing for more contrast. The cookie walks a line between indulgence and nostalgia, but with a few tweaks, it could truly shine.

15. Sugar (Shark Week)

Sugar (Shark Week) brings a playful twist to the classic sugar cookie with its novelty frosting shark fin. While it shares the same overly sweet characteristics as the Pink Sugar, the whimsical design earns it a couple of extra points for creativity. The cookie feels festive and fun, perfect for a themed party or a whimsical treat. Despite its shortcomings in flavor, the visual appeal and novelty make it a delightful choice for those seeking a cookie with personality. It’s a treat more for the eyes than the taste buds.

16. Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip

Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip is a dense, satisfying cookie that delivers big Reese’s energy with every bite. The combination of chocolate and peanut butter creates a rich, indulgent experience that many find irresistible. While its density might be a bit much for some, the flavor pairing is classic and well-loved. It’s a cookie that knows what it wants to be and delivers on that promise, offering a satisfying, nostalgic experience for fans of the timeless combination. For those with a sweet tooth, it’s a true delight.

17. Lemon Poppyseed

Lemon Poppyseed offers a bright, fresh flavor that pairs beautifully with an afternoon tea. The subtle sweetness and light texture make it a delightful choice for those who appreciate understated elegance in their cookies. While it may not be the most eye-catching option on the menu, its simplicity is its strength, allowing the lemon and poppyseed to shine. It’s a cookie that doesn’t try to be more than it is, offering a peaceful moment of enjoyment in its unassuming nature. Refreshing and light, it’s a quiet delight.

18. Brownie Batter

Brownie Batter is an indulgent delight for chocolate lovers, offering a gooey, deeply chocolatey experience. Its rich texture mimics that of its namesake, making it feel like a decadent treat for any occasion. While it borders on being too rich for a full cookie, its intensity is what makes it stand out. For those who can’t get enough of chocolate, it’s a dream come true, offering a sensory overload that’s hard to resist. The cookie captures the essence of licking the bowl clean, making it a guilty pleasure.

19. Churro

Churro brings a taste of the carnival with its cinnamon-sugar dusting and cream cheese frosting. It’s essentially a snickerdoodle’s dramatic cousin, offering a playful twist on familiar flavors. The cookie captures the essence of churros, providing a hint of nostalgia and fun. While it may not replace the real thing, it offers a comforting and satisfying experience for those seeking a sweet treat with character. The combination of cinnamon and cream cheese frosting makes it a standout, offering both warmth and a touch of whimsy.

20. Banana Cream Pie

Banana Cream Pie offers a creamy, smooth experience that surprises with its balance of flavors. The texture could be firmer, but the flavor hits just right, capturing the essence of the classic dessert. It’s a cookie that feels like a comforting embrace, offering a nostalgic nod to a beloved treat. For fans of banana-flavored desserts, it’s a delightful choice, providing both sweetness and a touch of whimsy. The cookie’s charm lies in its ability to evoke fond memories, making it a welcome addition to any cookie lineup.

21. Biscoff Lava

Biscoff Lava is a sticky, sweet delight that entices with its melty Biscoff center. The cookie offers a unique twist on traditional flavors, providing a satisfying experience for those who crave something different. Its soft texture and indulgent filling create a sensory experience that delights the senses. For fans of Biscoff, it’s a dream come true, offering a rich, satisfying treat that’s hard to resist. While it may be sticky, that’s part of its charm, making it a memorable choice for those who love a bit of messiness in their desserts.

22. S’mores

S’mores brings the nostalgia of campfire nights to life with its combination of marshmallow, chocolate, and graham cracker. The cookie offers a slightly messy experience, but that’s part of its charm, capturing the essence of its inspiration. It’s a flavor that evokes fond memories of roasting marshmallows and sharing stories by the fire. While it may not be the tidiest cookie, it offers a delightful trip down memory lane, providing joy and warmth in every bite. For those seeking a taste of childhood, it’s an unbeatable choice.

23. Rocky Road

Rocky Road is a total win for those who appreciate a mix of textures and flavors. With crunchy almonds and gooey marshmallow chunks inside a soft chocolate cookie, it offers a satisfying experience that feels both indulgent and fun. The combination of ingredients creates a playful twist on a classic, providing a touch of adventure with every bite. It’s a cookie that doesn’t shy away from bold flavors, offering a delightful balance that keeps you coming back for more. For fans of rocky road, it’s a must-try.

24. Milk Chocolate Chip (Classic)

Milk Chocolate Chip is the epitome of comfort, offering a reliable, simple experience that feels like a warm hug from the oven. Its classic flavor profile is both satisfying and timeless, providing a sense of coziness with every bite. While it may not break new ground, it remains a beloved staple for those who appreciate the simplicity of chocolate chip cookies. It’s a cookie that embodies the essence of home-baked goodness, offering warmth and familiarity in every morsel. For those seeking comfort, it’s a perfect choice.

25. Chocolate Crumb Cake

Chocolate Crumb Cake is a delightful hybrid that combines the best of a chocolate muffin and a cookie. Its rich, chocolatey flavor is complemented by a crumbly topping, creating a texture that pairs perfectly with a cup of coffee. The cookie offers a comforting experience, evoking the warmth of a cozy café. It’s a treat that feels both familiar and indulgent, making it a perfect choice for those who crave a bit of luxury in their cookie experience. For lovers of chocolate and baked goods, it’s a delightful escape.

26. Oreo Cookies & Cream

Oreo Cookies & Cream is an ode to a beloved dessert, offering a soft, rich experience that’s loaded with crushed Oreo flavor. It’s essentially dessert inside a dessert, providing a playful and indulgent treat for fans of the classic cookie. The combination of flavors creates a sense of nostalgia, making it a delightful choice for those who appreciate a bit of whimsy in their sweets. While it may not be groundbreaking, it’s a comfortingly familiar experience that offers both joy and satisfaction. For Oreo lovers, it’s a real treat.

27. Molten Lava

Molten Lava is a chocolate lover’s dream, offering a warm, gooey center that demands to be savored with a spoon. Its fudgy texture creates a sense of indulgence, providing a decadent experience that’s hard to resist. The cookie captures the essence of its namesake, offering a rich, satisfying treat that feels both luxurious and comforting. For those who adore chocolate, it’s a must-try, providing a sensory experience that delights at every turn. The combination of warmth and richness makes it a standout, offering pure pleasure in every bite.

28. German Chocolate Cake

German Chocolate Cake offers a bold chocolate flavor complemented by a coconut-pecan topping that adds texture and depth. The cookie’s unexpected richness surprises and delights, offering more flavor than many anticipate. It’s a treat that feels both indulgent and authentic, capturing the essence of a beloved cake. For fans of coconut and chocolate, it’s a delightful choice, providing a satisfying experience that brings warmth and joy. The combination of flavors creates a sense of adventure, offering a taste of Germany with every bite.

29. Mint Brownie

Mint Brownie is a refreshing twist on a classic, combining cool mint with rich chocolate for a unique experience. It’s reminiscent of a Thin Mint on steroids, offering a bold, invigorating flavor that tantalizes the senses. The combination of mint and chocolate creates a delightful contrast, making it a playful choice for those who love a bit of adventure in their cookies. The cookie provides a sense of indulgence without being overwhelming, offering a balanced experience that’s both satisfying and refreshing. For mint lovers, it’s a real treat.

30. Peanut Butter & Jelly

Peanut Butter & Jelly is a nostalgic nod to a beloved childhood sandwich, offering a delightful balance of salty, sweet, and fruity flavors. The cookie captures the essence of its inspiration, providing a comforting experience that’s both playful and satisfying. For those who appreciate the simplicity of the classic combination, it’s a delightful choice that evokes fond memories. The cookie offers a unique twist on familiar flavors, making it a standout for those who love a bit of whimsy in their sweets. It’s a treat that feels both familiar and new.

31. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough is the ultimate indulgence, combining the beloved flavors of baked cookie and raw dough into one delightful treat. It captures the essence of sneaking a taste of cookie dough before baking, offering a playful, satisfying experience. The cookie feels like a guilty pleasure, providing a sense of nostalgia and joy with every bite. For fans of cookie dough, it’s a dream come true, offering a unique twist on a classic treat. The combination of flavors creates a sense of adventure, making it a standout in any cookie lineup.

32. Cinnamon Roll

Cinnamon Roll is a delightful transformation of a beloved breakfast treat into cookie form, offering warm, gooey goodness with a frosting drizzle that entices the senses. The cookie captures the essence of a mall favorite, providing a comforting, nostalgic experience. For fans of cinnamon and sugar, it’s a delightful choice that offers both warmth and joy. The combination of flavors creates a sense of indulgence, making it a standout for those who love a sweet start to their day. It’s a treat that feels both familiar and exciting.

33. Salted Caramel Cheesecake

Salted Caramel Cheesecake is a dessert lover’s dream, offering a creamy, sweet experience with just enough salt to keep it interesting. The cookie provides a real showstopper moment, capturing the essence of indulgence and elegance. For those who appreciate the contrast of sweet and salty flavors, it’s a delightful choice that feels both luxurious and satisfying. The combination of textures and flavors creates a sense of adventure, making it a standout in any cookie collection. It’s a treat that offers a bit of sophistication along with its sweetness.

34. Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin Pie is like Thanksgiving in cookie form, offering rich spice and soft texture that feels like a comforting embrace. The creamy topping adds a layer of indulgence, making it a delightful choice for those who love the warmth of fall flavors. The cookie captures the essence of the holiday season, providing a sense of nostalgia and joy with every bite. For fans of pumpkin-flavored treats, it’s a must-try, offering a unique twist on a beloved classic. The combination of flavors creates a sense of warmth and coziness, making it a standout choice.

35. Red Velvet White Chip

Red Velvet White Chip offers a deep cocoa flavor complemented by melty white chocolate chips, creating a rich, satisfying experience. The cookie’s soft center feels indulgent, providing a sense of luxury with every bite. For fans of red velvet, it’s a delightful choice that captures the essence of the beloved cake. The combination of flavors creates a sense of joy and satisfaction, making it a standout for those who love a bit of decadence in their desserts. It’s a treat that feels both familiar and exciting, offering a taste of elegance in cookie form.

36. Snickerdoodle Cupcake

Snickerdoodle Cupcake is a cozy, craveable treat that combines the warmth of cinnamon with the indulgence of buttercream. The cookie offers a comforting experience, reminiscent of a beloved childhood treat. For fans of cinnamon and sugar, it’s a delightful choice that feels both familiar and exciting. The combination of flavors creates a sense of nostalgia and joy, making it a standout for those who love a sweet escape. It’s a treat that feels both playful and indulgent, offering a taste of comfort with every bite.

37. Maple Bacon

Maple Bacon offers a bold flavor combination that brings sweet, smoky, and salty elements together in perfect harmony. It’s a cookie that might raise eyebrows, but its unique character is what makes it special. For fans of adventurous flavors, it’s a delightful choice that offers a full sensory experience. The combination of maple and bacon creates a sense of indulgence and surprise, making it a standout for those who love a bit of excitement in their sweets. It’s a treat that feels both innovative and comforting, offering a taste of adventure with every bite.

38. Chocolate Chip (Mom’s Recipe)

Chocolate Chip (Mom’s Recipe) brings the comfort of home-baked goodness to the cookie lineup, offering a satisfying experience that feels familiar and warm. The combination of oats, chocolate, and peanut butter chips creates a delightful texture that evokes memories of baking in a family kitchen. For those who appreciate the simplicity and warmth of homemade treats, it’s a delightful choice that offers both joy and nostalgia. The cookie captures the essence of family gatherings and cherished moments, making it a standout for those seeking comfort in their sweets.

39. Peanut Butter Brownie

Peanut Butter Brownie is an indulgent delight, offering a rich chocolate base complemented by a salty peanut butter topping. It’s a cookie that satisfies cravings with its perfect balance of flavors, providing a sense of luxury with every bite. For fans of chocolate and peanut butter, it’s a must-try, offering a delightful experience that feels both comforting and exciting. The combination of textures and flavors creates a sense of indulgence, making it a standout in any cookie collection. It’s a treat that offers both sophistication and satisfaction, providing pure joy in cookie form.