Every Major Sandwich Chain’s Meatball Sub, Ranked From Last To First
In this blog post, we embark on a savory journey through the world of meatball subs offered by major sandwich chains. Each sandwich is meticulously evaluated, considering the quality of meatballs, sauce, bread, and overall flavor. Here are ten of the most popular choices, ranked from the least appetizing to the absolute best.
1. Blimpie – “Meatball Parmigiana”
Why it’s last: The bread barely holds up, the sauce tastes like canned tomato water, and the meatballs are rubbery and oddly sweet. It’s not offensive, but it’s definitely forgettable.
2. Subway – “Meatball Marinara”
The classic, but… It’s nostalgic, sure. But that doesn’t make it good. The meatballs are mushy, the sauce is ultra-sweet, and the cheese barely melts. For $5 nostalgia? Maybe. For flavor? Keep walking.
3. Jimmy John’s – No Official Meatball Sub
Why it’s here: JJ doesn’t offer a meatball sub. If you want one, you’re out of luck. Hence the low score—it simply doesn’t exist. (Ain’t no sandwich if it’s not on the menu.)
4. Firehouse Subs – “Sweet & Spicy Meatball”
Flavorful but intense: This one throws in zesty marinara, red pepper flakes, and melted provolone. Bold? Yes. Balanced? Not really. The spice overpowers the meatballs, but it’s worth a try if you want something different.
5. Which Wich – “Meatball Grinder”
Why it’s mid-tier: Customizable, toasty, and decent portion size. But the meatballs can be dry, and the sandwich really depends on your topping skills. Great for control freaks, just not always for meatball purists.
6. Potbelly – “Mama’s Meatball”
Solid comfort food: Warm, cheesy, and surprisingly meaty. Potbelly’s sandwich has good texture and a nicely balanced sauce. It’s not revolutionary, but it’s reliable and satisfying.
7. Jersey Mike’s – Secret Menu Style
Underground hero: While not on the regular menu, you can often order it hot and custom. Quality bread and meatball flavor that holds its own. When they do it right, it ranks surprisingly high.
8. Capriotti’s – “Meatball Barchetta”
Rich and indulgent: Stuffed with real-deal meatballs, sharp provolone, and a bold marinara. Great chew on the bread, melty cheese, and well-seasoned meat make this one nearly unbeatable.
9. Mendocino Farms – “Not So Fried Chicken Gets All the Love… But This Wins”
Curveball #1 pick: When they rotate in a meatball sub (seasonally or regionally), it’s chef-crafted and packed with flavor: juicy house-made meatballs, tangy red sauce, and quality bread. It’s not always available, but when it is—it destroys the competition.
10. Panera Bread – “Meatball Sandwich”
Unique approach: Panera offers a “Meatball Sandwich” that stands out with artisan bread and a health-conscious twist. The meatballs are tender, the sauce is subtly seasoned, and the presentation is top-notch. Although it steers towards the pricier side, it’s a delightful experience that elevates the classic meatball sandwich.