Common Mistakes People Make When Ordering At Five Guys

Ordering at Five Guys can be an overwhelming experience with its abundant options and generous portions. While the menu is straightforward, the nuances of ordering can lead to common mistakes that many patrons make. From underestimating portion sizes to missing out on free toppings, these missteps can impact the satisfaction of your meal. This guide explores 15 common mistakes to avoid, ensuring you get the most out of your Five Guys experience. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a seasoned fan, these tips will help you navigate the menu like a pro.

1. Ordering a Regular Fry Without Realizing It Feeds Two (or Three)

Ever been surprised by the mountain of fries spilling out of your cup? At Five Guys, a regular-sized fry could easily satisfy two or even three people. The portions are notoriously generous, as each order is topped off with an extra scoop dumped into the bag. This means unless you’re sharing or exceptionally hungry, you might end up with more fries than you can handle. Save yourself from the carb overload by opting for the smaller size, which still offers an impressive amount of crispy fries. Even the small size is a feast, ensuring no fry lover leaves unsatisfied.

2. Skipping the Free Toppings

Why pay for toppings elsewhere when Five Guys offers them for free? Skipping the complimentary toppings means missing out on enhancing your burger with flavors like grilled mushrooms, spicy jalapeños, or tangy hot sauce. These add-ons can elevate your meal, transforming a simple burger into a customized delight. Don’t overlook the opportunity to experiment with different flavor combinations. The variety is part of what makes the Five Guys experience unique, so take advantage of the endless possibilities. With so many options at no extra cost, your taste buds are in for a treat.

3. Not Knowing the “Little” Burger Is Actually a Regular-Sized Patty

In the world of Five Guys, “little” doesn’t mean small. It simply refers to a single patty instead of the standard double. For those with a moderate appetite, this is the perfect choice. Despite its name, the “little” burger provides more than enough to satisfy, with a juicy patty complemented by your choice of toppings. It’s an ideal option if you’re looking to enjoy the taste of a classic burger without the heft of two patties. This hidden gem balances flavor and size, allowing you to savor each bite without feeling overly stuffed.

4. Ignoring the Grilled Cheese Hack

Ever heard of the grilled cheese hack at Five Guys? It’s a game-changer for cheese lovers. By asking for a grilled cheese sandwich with a burger patty inside, you combine the gooey goodness of melted cheese with the savory taste of beef. This not-so-secret menu item is a testament to culinary creativity, offering a delightful twist on traditional comfort food. The combination of textures and flavors provides a satisfying meal that’s both indulgent and innovative. Perfect for those looking to try something different, this hack is a must-try for adventurous eaters.

5. Forgetting That You Can Go Bunless (Or Get a Lettuce Wrap)

Looking to cut carbs without sacrificing taste? Going bunless or opting for a lettuce wrap at Five Guys is a fantastic alternative. The lettuce wrap is sturdy enough to hold all your favorite toppings while allowing the flavors of the burger to shine through. It’s a crisp, refreshing option that caters to low-carb diets without compromising on taste. Whether you have dietary restrictions or are simply looking for a lighter meal, this choice keeps your meal deliciously satisfying. Enjoy the full Five Guys experience with a fresh twist by ditching the bun.

6. Ordering a Milkshake Without Customizing It

Why settle for a plain milkshake when you can customize it with exciting flavors? At Five Guys, you have the option to mix and match ingredients for a personalized treat. Think Oreo with peanut butter or chocolate with bacon for a unique twist. The ability to tailor your milkshake adds an element of fun and creativity to your order. By experimenting with different combinations, you can enjoy a milkshake that’s perfectly suited to your taste preferences, making each sip a delightful surprise. Don’t miss out on creating your own signature shake!

7. Overloading the Burger and Making It a Mess

With all toppings included for free, it’s tempting to pile them high. But beware—overloading your burger can turn it into a soggy mess. Too many toppings can overwhelm the flavors, making it difficult to enjoy the core taste of the burger. Balance is key to savoring each component. Carefully choosing a few favorite toppings ensures a harmonious blend of flavors and textures. This way, every bite is enjoyable, not a juggling act. Remember, sometimes less is more, especially when it comes to crafting the perfect burger experience at Five Guys.

8. Not Realizing Cajun Fries Come Spicy

Craving fries with a kick? Five Guys’ Cajun fries offer a spicy alternative to the classic version, seasoned with a bold blend of spices. However, if you’re sensitive to heat, these might surprise you. The peppery kick can be quite intense, so it’s best to know what you’re getting into before ordering. For those who love spicy food, these fries are a flavorful treat that adds excitement to your meal. But if you prefer milder flavors, you might want to stick with the regular fries or share with someone who enjoys the heat.

9. Skipping the Peanuts (While They Last)

Waiting for your order is a bit more enjoyable at Five Guys, thanks to the free peanuts available in-store. Snacking on these while you wait is part of the Five Guys experience. However, not all locations offer them, and they might disappear as you hesitate. Enjoying a handful of peanuts adds a touch of nostalgia, reminiscent of old-school burger joints where peanuts were a staple snack. It’s a simple pleasure that complements your visit, providing a light, crunchy bite before your main meal. Grab some peanuts if you see them—they’re a classic treat.

10. Not Ordering Online to Skip the Wait

Long lines at Five Guys can be daunting, especially during peak hours. Luckily, ordering online saves time and ensures your meal is hot and ready upon arrival. This convenience allows you to skip the wait and enjoy your food without delay. It’s an ideal solution for those short on time or wanting to avoid the hustle of busy service. By planning ahead, you can relish the full Five Guys experience without the stress of waiting in line. Embrace technology and streamline your order for a smooth, efficient meal pick-up.

11. Forgetting to Ask for Extra Crisp on the Fries

Love your fries extra crispy? At Five Guys, you can request them to be cooked to your liking. Asking for extra crispiness ensures that each fry delivers a satisfying crunch with every bite. This simple request can elevate your fry experience, offering a delightful contrast to the fluffy interior. Whether you enjoy them on their own or as a side to your burger, extra crispy fries are a treat that shouldn’t be overlooked. Next time, give them a try and enjoy fries just the way you like them—crispy and delicious.

12. Assuming All Locations Serve Milkshakes

Craving a milkshake? Not every Five Guys location has a shake machine, so it’s important to check beforehand. This oversight can lead to disappointment if you’re expecting a creamy treat with your meal. While many locations do offer milkshakes, availability varies, so a quick call or check online can save you the surprise. For milkshake lovers, ensuring your location serves them is key to a complete Five Guys experience. Don’t let this assumption lead to unfulfilled cravings; verify before you visit to satisfy your sweet tooth.

13. Not Knowing the Burgers Come Standard as Doubles

At Five Guys, a standard hamburger or cheeseburger comes with two patties unless specified otherwise. Newcomers might not realize this, leading to unexpected fullness. If you prefer just one patty, ask for the “little” version. This choice offers the same great taste with a more manageable portion size. Understanding the default double ensures you order exactly what you want, whether you’re looking for a hearty meal or something lighter. Being aware of this can help tailor your order to suit your appetite, making your visit more enjoyable and satisfying.

14. Skipping the Hot Dogs

While burgers steal the spotlight, Five Guys’ hot dogs are a hidden gem worth trying. Their beef hot dogs are split and grilled to perfection, offering a satisfying alternative to the classic burger. Topped with your choice of condiments, these hot dogs provide a delicious change of pace, perfect for those seeking variety. Don’t miss out on this underrated menu item that delivers both flavor and texture. Next time you’re at Five Guys, consider ordering a hot dog and enjoy a different taste experience that still upholds the brand’s quality standards.

15. Not Taking Advantage of Free Sauce on the Side

Did you know you can ask for extra sauces on the side at Five Guys? This allows you to control the flavor and avoid a soggy bun by adding just the right amount of your favorite condiments. Whether it’s BBQ, mayo, or mustard, having sauces on the side offers versatility and enhances your meal. This option lets you savor each bite the way you prefer, with the ability to mix and match flavors. By managing the sauce distribution, you can enjoy a perfectly balanced burger experience every time.