7 Fast Food Fish Sandwiches That Flop And 9 That Are Crispy, Flavorful Winners

Fast food fish sandwiches tend to make their rounds during Lent, but some chains keep them year-round. And while crispy, flaky fish on a bun sounds like a simple win, the reality is hit or miss. Some are soggy, bland, or more breading than actual fish. Others? Surprisingly delicious. Here’s a breakdown of the flops you can skip—and the ones that are actually worth the drive-thru detour.

1. McDonald’s Filet-O-Fish

A classic, but it’s more nostalgia than quality. Small, squishy, and barely warm cheese on a steamed bun. Those who grew up with it might find a sense of comfort, yet the taste doesn’t live up to the memory.

The fish fillet is often overshadowed by the bun and cheese. For many, it’s a staple during Lent but lacks the crispiness one desires in a fish sandwich.

The texture often leaves much to be desired, with a soft and sometimes soggy exterior. Despite its shortcomings, it remains a nostalgic favorite for many.

2. Dairy Queen Wild Alaskan Fish Sandwich

Fish quality is decent, but the bun and toppings are uninspired. Lacks crunch and seasoning.

The fish itself is often overshadowed by a plain, unremarkable bun. While the fillet has the potential for greatness, the lack of seasoning leaves it bland.

Toppings are minimal, often leaving the fish sandwich feeling incomplete. It’s a sandwich that might appeal to those seeking simplicity, but for those craving flavor, it falls short.

3. Jack in the Box Fish Sandwich

Frequently soggy with a limp fillet and generic tartar sauce—more filler than flavor.

The sandwich often fails to deliver the satisfying crunch one expects from a fish fillet. Instead, the experience is marred by a limp texture.

Tartar sauce, meant to uplift, adds little more than a generic taste. For those seeking a flavorful fish experience, this sandwich might not meet expectations.

4. Sonic Fish Sandwich

Often inconsistently cooked, with soft breading and a bland fillet that leans greasy rather than crispy.

The Sonic Fish Sandwich struggles with consistency, often arriving with a less-than-ideal texture.

The fish fillet, while promising, tends to lack flavor, leaving a greasy aftertaste. It’s a hit-or-miss option for fast food fish enthusiasts.

5. Arby’s Crispy Fish Sandwich

A massive piece of fish, but the texture is mushy and the flavor leans overly salty. Bigger isn’t always better.

The sandwich presents an impressive appearance with its large fish fillet, yet it struggles with texture.

The flavor, while initially promising, is often overwhelmed by saltiness, leaving a less satisfying taste. Those who enjoy bold flavors might find it appealing, but others may wish for balance.

6. Rally’s/Checkers Crispy Fish Sandwich

Cheap and forgettable. Thin patty, lackluster breading, and very little fish inside.

While the price may be appealing to some, the lack of substantial fish content can be disappointing.

The thin patty often lacks the flavor and texture desired in a fish sandwich, leaving much to be desired. It’s a choice for those looking for affordability, but not necessarily flavor.

7. A&W Pub-Style Fish Sandwich

While the fish itself can be decent, it’s often drowned in tartar sauce and overwhelmed by a too-sweet bun.

The fish fillet has potential, but the excessive tartar sauce tends to mask its natural flavors.

A bun with a hint of sweetness may appeal to some, but for many, it detracts from the overall fish experience. Those with a sweet tooth might enjoy it, yet others may seek balance elsewhere.

8. Popeyes Classic Flounder Fish Sandwich

Crispy, flaky, and seasoned like their famous chicken. Served on a brioche bun with tangy pickles—bold and satisfying.

The sandwich stands out with its flavorful seasoning, reminiscent of Popeyes’ renowned chicken.

The brioche bun adds a touch of luxury, while the pickles provide a tangy contrast to the flaky fish. It’s a delightful option for those seeking a satisfying fish sandwich experience.

9. Wendy’s Crispy Panko Fish Sandwich

Made with wild-caught Alaskan pollock and coated in crunchy panko. Good texture, great flavor, and quality toppings.

The sandwich impresses with its use of high-quality ingredients, delivering a satisfying crunch with each bite.

Toppings complement the fish, enhancing the overall taste without overpowering it. It’s a choice for those who value both quality and flavor in their fast food fish sandwiches.

10. Culver’s North Atlantic Cod Filet Sandwich

Hand-battered cod cooked to order with a real fillet feel—flaky, juicy, and generously portioned.

The sandwich offers an authentic fish experience with its hand-battered approach, ensuring freshness in every bite.

Generous portions make it a satisfying choice for those with a hearty appetite. It’s a standout option for those seeking both quality and quantity in their fish sandwich.

11. White Castle Panko Breaded Fish Slider

Surprisingly crispy for its size, with a buttery bun and solid flavor balance in just a few bites.

The slider, though small, delivers a satisfying crunch that belies its size.

A buttery bun complements the crispy fillet, offering a delightful contrast of textures. It’s an ideal choice for those seeking a quick, flavorful snack-sized fish option.

12. Long John Silver’s Fish Sandwich

Classic fast food fish done right—crispy batter, flaky fish, and just enough tartar to tie it together.

The sandwich excels with its golden, crispy exterior, offering a satisfying crunch with each bite.

Flaky fish contrasts beautifully with the tartar sauce, creating a harmonious flavor profile. It’s a reliable choice for those who appreciate classic fast food fish offerings.

13. Captain D’s Giant Fish Sandwich

True to its name, with two crunchy fillets stacked high and a nice toasted bun. Comfort food in sandwich form.

The sandwich impresses with its generous portions, delivering a satisfying meal for those with a hearty appetite.

A toasted bun adds warmth and texture, enhancing the overall experience. It’s a comforting choice for those seeking a fulfilling and flavorful fish sandwich.

14. Chick-fil-A (Seasonal Fish Sandwich)

Only available during Lent, but worth hunting down—lightly breaded and well-seasoned with a clean finish.

The sandwich offers a limited-time treat for those eager to enjoy Chick-fil-A’s take on a fish sandwich.

Its light breading and balanced seasoning create a delightful flavor profile. It’s a seasonal favorite for those in search of a unique, fast food fish experience.

15. Burger King Big Fish

Surprisingly solid: a flaky white fish patty with tangy pickles and tartar sauce on a sesame seed bun. Simple and tasty.

The sandwich presents a straightforward approach, delivering a satisfying meal with each bite.

Pickles add a tangy twist, complementing the flaky fish patty beautifully. It’s an unexpected delight for those seeking a reliable fast food fish option.

16. Bojangles’ Bojangler (Seasonal)

Zesty, crispy, and unique thanks to the Cajun-seasoned breading. Great heat and texture combo when it’s available.

The sandwich stands out with its distinctive Cajun seasoning, offering a flavorful kick to fast food fish.

Its crispy texture ensures a satisfying crunch with each bite. It’s a must-try for those who enjoy a bit of spice in their seafood sandwiches.