We Ate Dozens Of Little Debbie Snacks—Here Is Our Ultimate Ranking

In a comprehensive taste test, Delish editors sampled 24 Little Debbie snacks to determine the ultimate ranking. While personal preferences may vary, their top picks included Nutty Buddy, praised for its crispy wafer layers and balanced peanut butter and chocolate flavors, and Star Crunch, noted for its unique combination of crispy rice, caramel, and chocolate, offering a satisfying texture. Cosmic Brownies were recognized for their dense, fudgy texture and nostalgic appeal, though some found them overly sweet. Oatmeal Creme Pies were appreciated for their chewy cookies and creamy filling, delivering a comforting taste. Zebra Cakes were valued for their moist cake layers and distinctive striped icing, though some considered them generically sweet. Lower on the list were items like the Christmas Cherry Cordials, criticized for artificial flavors, and Powdered Mini Donuts, which were deemed dry and lacking in taste.

1. Nutty Buddy

Nutty Buddy, a quintessential favorite, delights with its crispy and creamy layers. One bite reveals the satisfying wafer crunch, harmoniously complemented by a rich, peanut butter filling. Covered in a smooth chocolate coating, it offers a balanced taste that appeals to both young and old.

This snack’s popularity is anchored in its textural contrast and flavor fusion, making it a go-to for peanut butter lovers. Whether enjoyed as a midday treat or a simple dessert, Nutty Buddy never disappoints. Its longstanding presence in lunchboxes speaks to its enduring charm and delicious consistency.

2. Star Crunch

Star Crunch captivates with its uniquely chewy and crispy combination. The interplay of caramel, chocolate, and puffed rice delivers an unexpected texture that intrigues the palate.

While its chewy caramel heart satisfies sweet cravings, the crunchy rice adds a delightful twist. Each bite is a playful contrast of textures and flavors, making it both a nostalgic and fun treat.

Star Crunch stands out not just for its taste but for its delightful textural journey, providing an experience both satisfying and novel for chocolate-caramel aficionados.

3. Cosmic Brownies

Cosmic Brownies, adorned with vibrant candy sprinkles, offer a journey back to childhood nostalgia. Their dense, fudgy texture sits at the heart of their appeal, providing a rich chocolate experience with every bite.

Sweetness might be intense for some, but fans relish this sugary indulgence. The colorful toppings add a playful visual element, making them fun as well as tasty.

Their iconic status in snack aisles highlights their universal appeal, combining both visual whimsy and chocolate decadence, perfect for satisfying intense sweet tooth cravings.

4. Oatmeal Creme Pies

Oatmeal Creme Pies evoke warmth and comfort with their chewy oatmeal cookies sandwiching a sweet, creamy filling. The soft texture of the cookies, combined with the light, fluffy creme, offers a delightful contrast.

This snack has a comforting, homemade quality that resonates with many snack enthusiasts. Often associated with childhood memories, Oatmeal Creme Pies provide a satisfying mix of wholesome oatmeal and indulgent sweetness.

Beloved for their simplicity and classic taste, these pies have secured their place as a timeless favorite, cherished by generations.

5. Zebra Cakes

Zebra Cakes, with their signature striped icing, offer a taste experience that’s both familiar and delightful. The moist cake layers, enveloped by sweet icing, create a harmony of textures that’s hard to resist.

Though some might find them overly sweet, many appreciate their unique design and nostalgic taste. Each bite provides a satisfying contrast between the soft cake and the slightly firm icing.

Their playful appearance and comforting taste have made Zebra Cakes a staple in many households, retaining their popularity across generations.

6. Christmas Cherry Cordials

Christmas Cherry Cordials present a festive treat with a glossy cherry center wrapped in chocolate. The burst of cherry flavor provides a contrast to the smooth chocolate coating, offering a unique taste experience.

Some may find the flavors artificial, yet it remains a seasonal favorite for its bold, festive profile. Its association with holiday traditions adds to its appeal.

Despite mixed reviews, Christmas Cherry Cordials hold a special place during the holiday season, celebrated for their distinctive taste and festive novelty.

7. Powdered Mini Donuts

Powdered Mini Donuts, small yet mighty, are often seen as a classic breakfast or snack item. The light powdered sugar coating provides a sweet dusting that contrasts with the soft, cake-like interior.

Some find them dry, yet others appreciate their simplicity and hint of nostalgia. Their convenient, bite-sized nature makes them an easy grab-and-go treat.

Though opinions may vary, these donuts continue to be a staple in snack packs, cherished for their effortless charm and classic taste.