15 Discontinued Pop-Tarts Flavors We’d Love To See Again

Pop-Tarts have been a beloved breakfast treat for decades, with an ever-changing lineup of flavors. Some of these flavors, now discontinued, have left a lasting impression and are fondly remembered by fans. Here’s a look at 15 flavors we’d love to see make a comeback.

1. Frosted Grape

Do you remember the tangy burst of Frosted Grape? A staple of the ’90s, this flavor captured the essence of a grape orchard in every bite. Its vibrant color added fun to breakfast time, enchanting kids and adults alike.

Fans still fondly recall its unique tartness, a stark contrast to the other fruity options. Despite its discontinuation, Frosted Grape’s memory lives on, eagerly awaited by those who experienced its charm. A return to store shelves would surely evoke nostalgia and delight.

This flavor reminds us how Pop-Tarts once embraced bold, unconventional choices.

2. PB&J Strawberry

Who doesn’t love a PB&J sandwich? Pop-Tarts brought this timeless favorite to life with their PB&J Strawberry flavor. Real peanut butter mixed with sweet strawberry jelly made each bite a delightful blend of creamy and fruity.

This flavor was a lunchbox revolution, providing a new way to enjoy the classic pairing. Many fans still dream of tasting this perfect fusion again. A return could sate nostalgic cravings and introduce this gem to new generations.

The PB&J Strawberry Pop-Tart stands as a testament to creative flavor experimentation.

3. French Toast

Imagine waking up to the aroma of French Toast, now conveniently packed into a Pop-Tart. This flavor perfectly captured Sunday morning vibes, offering maple syrup sweetness and a hint of cinnamon.

For those who cherished leisurely breakfasts, it was a warm embrace in pastry form. Discontinued too soon, its absence left a void for cozy mornings.

Bringing it back could rekindle that comfort and joy found in a traditional breakfast favorite. The French Toast Pop-Tart remains a beloved memory of indulgent, homely flavors.

4. Wild Watermelon

Wild Watermelon wasn’t just a flavor; it was an experience. Its bright colors and unique tart-sweet taste stood out in the Pop-Tarts lineup. Perfect for summer, it evoked images of picnics and sun-soaked days.

The tartness was balanced by a sweet finish, making it a refreshing treat for any time of day. Though it left the shelves, its legacy continues among those who crave a vibrant, fruity escape.

Reviving Wild Watermelon would surely bring a splash of fun and nostalgia to breakfast tables once more.

5. Chocolate Vanilla Crème

For those with a sweet tooth, Chocolate Vanilla Crème was a dream. The rich chocolate crust paired with a sweet vanilla filling created an indulgent dessert-like experience.

It was like enjoying a slice of cake but in a convenient, toaster-ready form. Fans of this flavor reminisce about its perfect balance between chocolatey richness and creamy sweetness.

Though not on shelves today, the desire for this luxurious treat remains strong. Its return would undoubtedly satisfy cravings for a decadent breakfast option.

6. Dulce de Leche

Dulce de Leche Pop-Tarts brought a touch of Latin flair to breakfast. The caramel-flavored filling, encased in a golden crust, offered a taste of indulgence that was both exotic and comforting.

Though its presence was fleeting, it left a lasting impression on those who savored its unique taste. Many yearn for its return to experience the rich, buttery caramel once more.

This flavor’s brief existence only adds to its allure, making it a sought-after memory for fans of sweet, cultural delights.

7. Maple Bacon

Maple Bacon Pop-Tarts sparked a bold, polarizing reaction. Combining sweet maple glaze with savory bacon bits, it created a breakfast sensation that divided tasters.

For those who embraced the daring fusion, it was a harmonious blend of flavors that tantalized the taste buds. Its departure left behind a devoted fanbase eager for its revival.

Reintroducing Maple Bacon could reignite debates and delight those who miss its unique culinary experiment, celebrating the adventurous spirit of breakfast innovation.

8. Cinnamon Roll

The Cinnamon Roll Pop-Tart was a comforting delight for pastry lovers. Its soft cinnamon-spiced filling and creamy icing offered a taste reminiscent of a beloved bakery treat.

Perfect for those chilly mornings, it provided warmth and comfort in every bite. Fans still talk about its absence, longing for the sweet nostalgia it evoked.

Reintroducing this flavor could satisfy cravings for a cozy, cinnamon-filled breakfast option, reminiscent of freshly baked pastries from a local bakery.

9. Gingerbread

Gingerbread Pop-Tarts were a seasonal delight, capturing the holiday spirit with spiced, ginger-filled goodness. Decorated with festive frosting, they brought warmth and cheer to winter mornings.

Its limited availability made it even more cherished, becoming a holiday staple for many. Those who enjoyed it reminisce about the cozy, spiced aroma and taste.

A comeback could rekindle holiday traditions, offering a taste of festive nostalgia that many still crave during the winter season.

10. Apple Cinnamon (Frosted)

Apple Cinnamon (Frosted) Pop-Tarts were a fall favorite, combining warm apple filling with a hint of spice. The lightly frosted crust added an extra layer of sweetness that complemented the flavors perfectly.

For those who loved seasonal treats, it was a staple during the autumn months. Its discontinuation left fans yearning for the comforting taste of apples and cinnamon.

Reviving this flavor could bring back the essence of fall, providing a cozy breakfast option for crisp mornings.

11. Oatmeal Delights – Maple Brown Sugar

Oatmeal Delights – Maple Brown Sugar was a nod to wholesome mornings. The soft-baked texture combined with the comforting flavor of maple and brown sugar created a breakfast reminiscent of a warm bowl of oatmeal.

Perfect for those seeking a hearty start, it provided the right balance of sweetness and substance. Those who tasted it remember its unique appeal and satisfying nature.

A return of this flavor could offer a nostalgic, wholesome option for those who appreciate a more traditional breakfast taste.

12. Frosted Chocolate Mocha

For coffee lovers, Frosted Chocolate Mocha was a dream come true. This Pop-Tart blended rich chocolate with subtle mocha notes, creating a coffeehouse-inspired treat.

Ideal for a morning pick-me-up, it combined the best of two worlds: coffee and chocolate. Fans still talk about its unique, energizing flavor profile.

Reintroducing this flavor could provide a decadent breakfast option for those who crave a sophisticated, caffeine-infused taste in the morning.

13. Guava Mango

Guava Mango was a tropical twist that brought the flavors of paradise to breakfast tables. Combining the exotic tastes of guava and mango, it was a short-lived delight for fruit lovers.

Its unique flavor profile stood out among the usual offerings, leaving a memorable mark on those who tried it. Many still recall the vibrant, fruity essence that set it apart.

A comeback could reintroduce this taste of the tropics, providing a refreshing escape from the ordinary morning routine.

14. Berry Creme

Berry Creme was a limited edition sensation that combined swirled berry flavors with a creamy vanilla center. It offered a playful twist on traditional fruit-filled Pop-Tarts.

Fans appreciated the balance between tangy berries and smooth vanilla, creating a dessert-like experience. Though its time was brief, its impact was lasting for those who enjoyed the unique pairing.

Reintroducing Berry Creme could bring back the delightful contrast of flavors that pleased the palates of many, offering a nostalgic treat for adventurous taste buds.

15. Orange Cream

Orange Cream was like biting into a creamsicle, bringing bright citrus and smooth cream flavors together in harmony. This Pop-Tart captured the essence of summer, offering a refreshing take on breakfast.

Its citrusy brightness was perfectly complemented by the creamy filling, creating a flavor reminiscent of sunny days and ice cream treats. Though discontinued, it remains a cherished memory for many.

A return of this flavor could provide a burst of sunshine and nostalgia, reviving the playful joy of a summer favorite.