20 Best Long John Silver’s Menu Items, Tested!

Long John Silver’s is renowned for its fried seafood and delightful side dishes. If you’re navigating through their menu, you might wonder which items truly stand out. From the crispy, golden batter to the savory sides, this list highlights their top 20 menu items. Whether you’re a seafood enthusiast or looking for a quick, satisfying meal, these selections promise to dazzle your taste buds. Here’s a guide to the 20 best items, meticulously tested and curated for flavor, texture, and overall enjoyment. Dive into the world of Long John Silver’s, one bite at a time.

1. 2-Piece Fish Meal

Long John Silver’s 2-Piece Fish Meal is a quintessential choice for seafood lovers. Golden-battered fish pieces are nestled on the plate, crispy on the outside with tender, flaky insides. Accompanied by two sides, such as creamy coleslaw and crispy fries, it’s a harmonious blend of flavors and textures. The hushpuppies add an extra layer of savory delight. Whether enjoyed with tangy tartar sauce or a splash of lemon, each bite is a comforting reminder of classic seaside dining. Perfect for lunch or dinner, this meal encapsulates the essence of Long John Silver’s signature taste.

2. Fish & Chicken Platter

Can’t decide between land or sea? The Fish & Chicken Platter offers the best of both worlds. With succulent fish fillets and tender chicken planks, the platter is a feast for the indecisive diner. The chicken is as juicy as the sea’s bounty, both encased in Long John Silver’s signature crispy batter. Each bite delivers a satisfying crunch, complemented by sides like hot hushpuppies and golden fries. It’s a smorgasbord of textures and tastes, ensuring a fulfilling meal. Ideal for those who crave variety, this platter truly satisfies diverse palates.

3. Crispy Hushpuppies

Golden orbs of delight, the Crispy Hushpuppies at Long John Silver’s are a cherished side. Their crunchy exterior gives way to a moist, savory center, made from finely ground cornmeal. A staple on any seafood platter, these hushpuppies offer a burst of flavor with each bite. Served hot, they complement the main dishes perfectly. Their humble appearance belies their delicious impact, making them a must-try. Whether you’re a long-time fan or a first-time visitor, these hushpuppies are bound to steal the show and become a repeat favorite.

4. Lobster Bites

Seasonal but eagerly awaited, Lobster Bites make any visit to Long John Silver’s special. Each piece, coated in a crunchy breading, reveals tender lobster meat as you bite through. The buttery flavor harmonizes with the crispy exterior, creating a luxurious snack or appetizer. When available, these bites elevate your dining experience, offering a taste of the ocean’s finest. Ideal on their own or paired with your favorite sauce, they are a testament to indulgence and quality. Don’t miss out on them when they make their anticipated return to the menu.

5. Chicken Planks

Long John Silver’s Chicken Planks are a crowd favorite for good reason. These planks feature juicy white meat chicken enveloped in the restaurant’s iconic batter. The exterior is crispy and golden, offering a satisfying crunch with each bite. Mild and kid-friendly, they appeal to all ages without being overly spicy. Dip them into your choice of sauces for added flavor, from tangy bbq to creamy ranch. Versatile and delicious, the Chicken Planks are perfect alone or as part of a combo meal. Experience the joy of quality fried chicken with every mouthful.

6. Fried Clams

The Fried Clams at Long John Silver’s are a hidden gem on the menu. Each clam is fried to perfection, offering a burst of briny flavor combined with a crisp crust. These small bites are great as a stand-alone snack or an accompaniment to other dishes. Their rich taste pairs beautifully with a squeeze of lemon or a dip in tartar sauce, enhancing their deliciousness. The clams’ texture and flavor are a true testament to the art of frying, making them a standout choice for clam lovers everywhere. Enjoy a taste of the sea with every serving.

7. Battered Shrimp

Long John Silver’s Battered Shrimp is a delightful choice for shrimp enthusiasts. Each shrimp is encased in a peppery, golden batter, creating a crisp and flavorful bite. The succulent shrimp inside remains plump and juicy, offering a contrast of textures. Perfectly paired with cocktail sauce or ranch, these shrimp make a satisfying snack or meal addition. Their vibrant flavor, combined with the signature crunch, makes them a perennial favorite. Whether savoring them solo or as part of a combo, the Battered Shrimp is a true testament to Long John Silver’s seafood expertise.

8. Super Sampler Platter

The Super Sampler Platter is a feast for those who crave variety. This generous platter includes fish, chicken, shrimp, hushpuppies, and sides, offering a little bit of everything Long John Silver’s is known for. It’s an ideal choice for first-timers or those with hearty appetites, ensuring no taste is left unexplored. Each item is cooked to perfection, delivering a medley of flavors and textures on one plate. Perfect for sharing or indulging solo, the sampler provides a comprehensive taste of Long John Silver’s offerings, promising satisfaction with every bite.

9. Fries

Long John Silver’s Fries are a classic side that never disappoints. These crinkle-cut fries are lightly seasoned and fried to a golden crunch, offering a perfectly satisfying companion to any meal. Their simplicity is their strength, consistently delivering a delightful texture and flavor. Dip them in ketchup or enjoy them plain, their versatility shines through. Available with any combo or as a standalone snack, they’re a staple that complements the richer options on the menu. Enjoy the nostalgic comfort of fries that are always a hit, no matter the occasion.

10. Coleslaw

Long John Silver’s Coleslaw provides a cool, refreshing counterpoint to their fried offerings. This creamy side dish features finely chopped cabbage and carrots, dressed in a tangy, slightly sweet sauce. The crunchiness of the vegetables and the smoothness of the dressing create a delightful contrast. Served alongside the richer, fried items, it offers a balance that elevates the overall meal experience. Whether enjoyed on its own or as part of a combo, the coleslaw is a testament to the art of pairing flavors and textures. Discover a fresh, crisp bite in every spoonful.

11. Rice

At select Long John Silver’s locations, rice offers a wonderful alternative to the usual fried sides. Lightly seasoned and fluffy, it serves as an excellent base for those looking to craft their own bowls or simply avoid fried options. The mild flavor complements the bold, fried entrees, providing a subtle yet satisfying addition to any meal. Garnished with fresh herbs, the rice is both flavorful and versatile. It’s perfect for those days when you crave something lighter, yet still wish to enjoy the delightful offerings of Long John Silver’s menu.

12. Grilled Salmon Bowl

The Grilled Salmon Bowl at Long John Silver’s is a refreshing departure from their traditional fried fare. Featuring a perfectly grilled salmon fillet atop a bed of rice and colorful mixed vegetables, it’s a lighter, healthier option for guests. The salmon is tender and flavorful, accentuated by the fresh, crisp veggies. This bowl offers a nutritious yet satisfying meal choice, ideal for those seeking a balance of flavors and textures. Available at select locations, it’s a must-try for anyone looking to enjoy the sea’s bounty in a health-conscious manner.

13. Grilled Shrimp Tacos

When in season, the Grilled Shrimp Tacos at Long John Silver’s provide a delightful twist on traditional offerings. Warm tortillas cradle succulent grilled shrimp, topped with a tangy slaw that adds a refreshing crunch. Each bite is a harmonious blend of smoky, savory, and tart flavors. These tacos are perfect for those seeking a lighter option without sacrificing taste. Garnished with a squeeze of lime, they transport you to a coastal paradise with every bite. Don’t miss these tacos when they appear, as they’re a seasonal treat that’s truly unforgettable.

14. Fish Sandwich

Long John Silver’s Fish Sandwich is a classic choice for sandwich lovers. A generous fish filet, fried to golden perfection, is nestled within a soft bun. Topped with crisp lettuce and creamy tartar sauce, each bite is a delightful blend of flavors. The sandwich is both hearty and satisfying, offering a convenient way to enjoy the chain’s signature fish. Whether eaten on the go or sitting down for a meal, it’s a versatile option that never disappoints. Experience the simple pleasure of a well-crafted fish sandwich that’s sure to please.

15. Chicken Sandwich

Understated yet delicious, the Chicken Sandwich at Long John Silver’s is a must-try for chicken enthusiasts. Featuring a crispy chicken filet, it’s complemented by fresh lettuce and a creamy dressing, all encased in a toasted bun. The simple ingredients come together to create a satisfying and flavorful sandwich. Perfect for a quick meal, its straightforward goodness makes it a popular choice. Enjoy it as is, or customize with your favorite toppings. The Chicken Sandwich proves that sometimes, simplicity is key to creating a delightful dining experience.

16. Pineapple Cream Cheese Pie

For those with a sweet tooth, the Pineapple Cream Cheese Pie offers a delightful tropical twist. A flaky, golden crust encases a creamy filling, rich with the flavors of pineapple and cream cheese. Each bite is a harmonious balance of sweet and tangy, offering a refreshing end to any meal. The pie’s vibrant flavor profile makes it a standout among desserts, ensuring it leaves a lasting impression. Whether enjoyed as a treat on its own or shared with friends, this dessert promises to transport you to a sun-kissed paradise with every bite.

17. Crab Cakes

When available, Long John Silver’s Crab Cakes are a true delicacy. These cakes, crafted with real crab meat, are fried to a perfect golden brown. The exterior is crispy, while the inside is rich with savory flavors that celebrate the ocean’s bounty. Paired with your choice of dipping sauce, they’re a treat for any seafood lover. The crab cakes’ robust flavor and tender texture make them a standout on the menu. Whether as a starter or main, they offer a taste of elegance and indulgence that shouldn’t be missed.

18. Jalapeño Poppers

For those who enjoy a bit of heat, Long John Silver’s Jalapeño Poppers are a spicy delight. These poppers are filled with creamy cheese, enveloped in a crispy, golden shell. Each bite delivers a fiery kick, balanced by the rich, smooth filling. Perfect as a snack or side, they’re sure to please spice enthusiasts. Their bold flavors make them a standout choice, offering an exciting contrast to the milder menu items. Whether you’re daring or simply curious, the Jalapeño Poppers promise a flavorful adventure in every bite.

19. Mac & Cheese

Long John Silver’s Mac & Cheese is comfort food at its finest. Creamy and indulgent, this side dish features tender pasta enveloped in a rich cheese sauce. Each spoonful is a warm embrace of flavor, with a golden crust that adds a delightful texture. Perfect for kids and adults alike, it’s a beloved classic that pairs well with any main course. Whether enjoyed on its own or as part of a meal, the Mac & Cheese is a satisfying choice that never goes out of style. Discover the comforting taste of this timeless favorite.

20. Battered Onion Rings

Thick-cut and golden, Long John Silver’s Battered Onion Rings are a crunchy delight. Each ring is perfectly cooked, offering a sweet onion flavor encased in a crispy, golden batter. They’re an ideal side for any meal, providing a satisfying crunch that complements the main dishes. Served hot and fresh, they’re hard to resist. Dip them in your favorite sauce for an added layer of flavor and enjoy the classic taste that has made them a favorite. Relish the simple pleasure of onion rings done right, every time you visit.