6 Frozen Pizzas That Disappointed And 6 Store Bought Winners You’ll Want Again and Again

Exploring the freezer aisles can be a bit of a gamble, especially when it comes to frozen pizzas. While some deliver a slice of heaven, others leave us craving something better. In this blog post, we delve into six frozen pizzas that fall short and six store-bought gems that you’ll want to savor time and again. Whether you’re looking for a quick dinner fix or planning a pizza night, these insights will guide you toward the best (and away from the disappointing) options out there.

1. DiGiorno Rising Crust Pepperoni

DiGiorno’s Rising Crust Pepperoni pizza is a well-known name in the realm of frozen pizzas, but not always for the right reasons. Many pizza enthusiasts find the crust overly thick and bready, overshadowing the rest of the pizza’s flavor profile. The sauce, while plentiful, often lands on the sweeter side, which doesn’t always pair well with the pepperoni.

Adding to the disappointment, the topping distribution can be inconsistent, leaving some slices generously covered while others feel neglected. Despite its widespread availability, this pizza often leaves taste buds longing for a more balanced and satisfying slice.

2. Tombstone Original

Tombstone Original is an affordable option that’s easy on the wallet, but its flavor leaves much to be desired. The crust is often compared to cardboard, lacking the satisfying crunch that many seek in a pizza. Moreover, the cheese and sauce are sparingly applied, resulting in a lackluster and unremarkable tasting experience.

While it might suffice in a pinch, this pizza doesn’t quite deliver on taste, leaving many customers yearning for more depth and flavor. It’s a staple in many freezers, but often as a last resort rather than the first choice.

3. California Pizza Kitchen BBQ Chicken

California Pizza Kitchen’s BBQ Chicken pizza promises a unique twist on traditional pizza, but the execution often disappoints. The concept of BBQ chicken on pizza is appealing, yet the crust tends to be too thin and soggy, failing to support the toppings effectively. The BBQ sauce, intended to be the star, ends up overpowering with its sweetness.

The chicken pieces are sparse, and combined with the dominant sauce, they don’t provide the balanced bite that one might expect. While innovative in concept, this pizza struggles to deliver a cohesive and satisfying taste experience.

4. Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni

Red Baron’s Classic Crust Pepperoni Pizza is often a nostalgic choice for many, but it doesn’t always live up to its past glory. The pizza tends to be overly greasy, with the oil from the pepperoni seeping into the crust. This heaviness can overshadow the flavors, making each bite less enjoyable.

Moreover, the toppings often taste artificial, and there’s a noticeable lack of real cheese, which is a letdown for cheese lovers. While it evokes memories of childhood pizza nights, the reality today might not match those fond recollections.

5. Amy’s 4 Cheese Pizza

Amy’s 4 Cheese Pizza is an organic and vegetarian-friendly option, which draws many customers initially. However, the taste experience often falls flat. The crust is chewy, lacking the crispness that enhances each bite, and the cheese, despite being a four-cheese blend, is applied sparingly.

Toppings are minimal, which might appeal to some but leaves others desiring a more robust flavor profile. While it caters to those seeking organic options, it may not satisfy those looking for a hearty and fulfilling pizza experience.

6. Tony’s Pepperoni Pizza

Tony’s Pepperoni Pizza is a budget-friendly choice that makes it accessible to many, yet it often falls short in flavor. The crust is dense and lacks the airy texture that characterizes a great pizza. The sauce, though plentiful, tends to be thin and sugary, overshadowing the pepperoni rather than complementing it.

Overall, the pizza lacks both freshness and balance, making it an option more suited for those prioritizing cost over quality. It’s a staple for many, but often out of necessity rather than preference.

7. Screamin’ Sicilian Bessie’s Revenge

Screamin’ Sicilian Bessie’s Revenge is a cheese lover’s dream come true, boasting an impressive amount of cheese that covers every inch of the pizza. The thick and crispy crust provides a satisfying crunch, supporting the bold flavors on top. Each bite is a cheesy delight, with the cheese melting perfectly over the robust crust.

It’s a pizza that consistently delivers on flavor and texture, leaving those who crave a rich and indulgent cheese experience thoroughly satisfied. This pizza is a go-to for anyone looking to indulge their cheese cravings fully.

8. Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Margherita

Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Margherita Pizza is a testament to simplicity done right. It features a fresh-tasting tomato sauce that harmonizes beautifully with the crunchy crust. The mozzarella and basil are balanced perfectly, providing a fresh and satisfying taste profile that feels like a slice of Italy.

Each bite offers a crispy texture combined with fresh, vibrant flavors. It’s a go-to choice for those looking to enjoy a lighter, more authentic pizza experience, reminiscent of a traditional Italian margherita pizza.

9. Motor City Pizza Co. Detroit-Style Pepperoni

Motor City Pizza Co.’s Detroit-Style Pepperoni is a true standout for fans of deep-dish pizzas. The thick, airy crust is a delight, providing a fluffy bite that complements the crispy cheese edges perfectly. This pizza’s sauce-on-top format ensures that each bite is filled with robust and rich tomato flavor.

The pepperoni adds a spicy kick, rounding off the flavors beautifully. This pizza is perfect for those who love a hearty meal with a unique twist, bringing the best of Detroit-style pizza to your home.

10. Table 87 Coal Oven Margherita

Table 87’s Coal Oven Margherita Pizza offers a unique take with its coal oven-baked crust, providing a smoky flavor rarely found in frozen options. The thin crust is perfectly crisp, acting as the ideal base for the fresh mozzarella and basil toppings.

This pizza delivers an artisanal taste that stands out in the freezer aisle, bringing the experience of a coal-fired pizzeria into your home. It’s a sophisticated choice for those who appreciate authentic flavors and a crisp, smoky finish.

11. California Pizza Kitchen White Pizza

California Pizza Kitchen’s White Pizza is a delightful surprise for those seeking something different. The creamy garlic sauce provides a rich base, complemented by spinach and mozzarella cheese. Each element blends seamlessly, creating a harmonious flavor profile.

The thin crust offers a satisfying crunch, enhancing the overall pizza experience. It’s a sophisticated option that appeals to those looking to step away from traditional red sauce pizzas, delivering a unique and enjoyable taste.

12. Talia di Napoli Margherita

Talia di Napoli’s Margherita Pizza is an imported Italian delight, wood-fired and frozen to capture its authentic taste. The thin crust has a perfect balance of crispiness and chewiness, topped with premium San Marzano tomatoes and fior di latte cheese.

This pizza showcases simple, high-quality ingredients, delivering a taste that transports you to Italy with every bite. It’s perfect for those seeking an authentic pizza experience at home, offering a fresh and refined flavor that stands out among frozen options.