8 Chain Cheesesteaks That Fall Flat—And 8 That Truly Hit the Spot

Cheesesteaks are a beloved American classic, offering savory satisfaction with every bite. However, not all cheesesteaks are created equal. In this article, we explore eight chain cheesesteaks that don’t quite meet expectations and eight that truly satisfy your taste buds. Whether you’re a cheesesteak aficionado or just curious, this list will help you navigate the highs and lows of chain offerings. From beloved spots in Philadelphia to national favorites, let’s discover which ones deserve a visit.

1. Subway – The Steak & Cheese

Subway’s Steak & Cheese often lands more as a hot sandwich than a true cheesesteak. The meat tends to be thin and somewhat bland, lacking the robust flavors that make a cheesesteak iconic. Inconsistent toasting leaves the bread soft, detracting from the overall experience.

While convenient for a quick bite, it doesn’t capture the essence of a traditional cheesesteak. With competing flavors from various toppings, the sandwich can feel muddled rather than harmonious. Those seeking the authentic experience may find themselves underwhelmed and longing for something more substantial.

2. Charleys Cheesesteaks – Classic Philly (at lower-traffic locations)

Charleys Classic Philly can be a hit or miss, especially in lower-traffic locations. When fresh, it holds potential, but often the meat ends up chewy, and toppings are unevenly layered. The lack of consistency can be frustrating for those expecting a reliable experience.

The bread often lacks the crispness needed to complement the fillings, and flavors may feel unbalanced. For those in search of a dependable cheesesteak, visiting a bustling location might yield better results. The potential is there, but execution varies, leaving some diners less than satisfied.

3. Wawa – Hot Philly-Style Sandwich

Wawa’s Hot Philly-Style Sandwich is all about convenience, but it sacrifices some quality in the process. The beef often lacks the seasoning needed to stand out, leaving it bland. The roll, while soft, can become soggy too quickly, diminishing the experience.

For those on-the-go, it’s an easy option, but it may not satisfy true cheesesteak enthusiasts looking for bold flavors. While the sandwich has its merits in terms of accessibility, it doesn’t quite hit the mark on taste and texture. Consider it more a quick fix than a culinary delight.

4. D’Angelo Grilled Sandwiches – Steak Number 9

D’Angelo’s Steak Number 9 is a New England favorite, yet it struggles to deliver a consistently exciting flavor profile. Without extra toppings, the sandwich can lean towards blandness, and the quality of bread varies from location to location.

Fans of the chain might appreciate the regional charm, but newcomers could find it lacking the punch needed to impress. While the sandwich can be elevated with add-ons, its standard form leaves much to be desired. It’s a classic case of potential overshadowed by inconsistent execution.

5. Sheetz – Classic Steak Sandwich

The Sheetz Classic Steak Sandwich is prepared with speed in mind, but that comes at a cost to its appeal. The meat-to-bread ratio is often skewed, with more bread than filling, making each bite less satisfying. Generic ingredients don’t help capture the true essence of a cheesesteak.

For those seeking a quick snack, it serves its purpose, but it may leave you craving a more balanced, flavorful experience. It’s a convenient option, yet it struggles to meet the expectations of cheesesteak purists. This sandwich might need a little more substance to truly shine.

6. Firehouse Subs – Steak & Cheese

Firehouse Subs’ Steak & Cheese offers a unique steamed preparation, yet this method mutes both texture and flavor. The cheese rarely achieves that gooey melty state that makes cheesesteaks so delectable.

While the sandwich has its fans, it may not satisfy those looking for the traditional experience. The subdued flavors might appeal to some, but leave others wanting more depth and richness. For a true cheesesteak aficionado, this option might not fully hit the spot, despite its novelty.

7. Jimmy John’s – No standard cheesesteak

Jimmy John’s doesn’t offer a standard cheesesteak, which leaves fans of the classic sandwich out in the cold—literally. Trying to build one from cold cuts results in a poor substitute, missing the hot, melty goodness essential to a true cheesesteak.

While their sandwiches are known for freshness, without a hot steak option, it simply doesn’t measure up for cheesesteak lovers. Despite the potential for customization, this workaround fails to capture the essence of what makes the original so revered.

8. Quiznos – Peppercorn Steak

Once a popular choice, Quiznos Peppercorn Steak now faces challenges with consistency, often becoming hit-or-miss in both freshness and flavor. As locations decline, so does the opportunity for a reliable cheesesteak experience.

The sandwich, when made well, offers a delightful peppery kick, but the odds of receiving that perfect bite have dwindled. For those seeking the familiar taste of Quiznos, the unpredictability may lead to disappointment. It’s a reminder of former glory, with flashes of what once was but not always what is today.

9. Jersey Mike’s – Big Kahuna Cheese Steak

Jersey Mike’s Big Kahuna Cheese Steak is a flavor-packed delight and a fan favorite for good reason. Grilled fresh with onions, peppers, jalapeños, and mushrooms, it offers a burst of bold flavors. The gooey white American cheese ties everything together, creating a satisfying experience.

Each bite is a harmonious blend of spicy and savory, making it a go-to for those seeking a full-flavored cheesesteak. With its generous toppings and well-balanced ingredients, it truly hits the spot, offering a taste of cheesesteak heaven.

10. Penn Station East Coast Subs – Philly Cheesesteak

Penn Station East Coast Subs serves up a classic with their Philly Cheesesteak, grilled to order with fresh-sliced steak and toasted bread. The juiciness of the meat combined with customizable toppings makes it a standout choice for cheesesteak lovers.

The option to tailor your sandwich ensures each bite is tailored to your tastes, enhancing the overall experience. It’s a winning combination of tradition and personalization, capturing the essence of what makes cheesesteaks so beloved. For anyone craving authenticity and flavor, this is a must-try option.

11. Pat’s King of Steaks (Philadelphia, PA)

Pat’s King of Steaks is synonymous with the original Philly cheesesteak, offering the legendary “Whiz wit” experience. Located in Philadelphia, the simplicity of melted cheese whiz and onions on a classic roll captures the spirit of the city.

For those making a pilgrimage to cheesesteak ground zero, Pat’s is a must-visit. Here, tradition reigns supreme, and each bite transports you to the heart of Philly’s culinary heritage. Whether you’re a first-timer or a regular, Pat’s delivers the genuine article every time.

12. Geno’s Steaks (Philadelphia, PA)

Geno’s Steaks stands as a rival to Pat’s and a true staple in Philadelphia’s cheesesteak scene. Known for quick service and a crisp roll, it offers a beefy experience that’s both bold and satisfying.

The rivalry adds to the flavor, making each visit an adventure for the senses. If you’re exploring Philly’s cheesesteak offerings, Geno’s is a necessary stop. The combination of tradition and vibrant flavors ensures that every cheesesteak lover leaves with a satisfied smile.

13. Tony Luke’s (Multiple Locations & Stadiums)

Tony Luke’s extends the authentic Philly cheesesteak experience across multiple locations and stadiums. Known for high-quality ribeye and a seeded roll, it captures the authentic flavors that make cheesesteaks a beloved staple.

For those seeking a consistent and delicious experience, Tony Luke’s delivers with every sandwich. Whether you’re at a game or just out for a bite, the robust taste and perfect texture make it a standout choice. It’s a slice of Philly wherever you may find it.

14. Steve’s Prince of Steaks (Philadelphia area)

Steve’s Prince of Steaks is a beloved spot in the Philadelphia area, known for its creamy cheese melt and generous meat portions. It’s a no-frills option that focuses on delivering deliciousness in every bite.

Fans appreciate the hearty approach, ensuring that each sandwich is both filling and flavorful. For those exploring the cheesesteak capitals, Steve’s stands out as a must-try. It’s a testament to simple, well-done ingredients creating something truly special in the cheesesteak realm.

15. Capriotti’s – Cheese Steak

Capriotti’s Cheese Steak offers a delightful balance of meat and cheese, nestled in sturdy bread. It’s especially delicious when ordered “the works,” featuring peppers and onions for added flavor.

The sandwich provides a satisfying experience, with each component working in harmony to create a taste sensation. For those seeking a reliable and enjoyable cheesesteak, Capriotti’s makes for a commendable choice. The robust flavors and generous ingredients ensure a memorable meal for every cheesesteak enthusiast.

16. South Philly Cheesesteaks & Fries

South Philly Cheesesteaks & Fries surprises with its quality, offering thinly sliced steak and melted cheese in a crusty roll. Found in malls and food courts, it delivers unexpected satisfaction.

Despite the unassuming location, the sandwich holds its own with robust flavors and satisfying textures. For a quick stop during a shopping trip, it’s a pleasant surprise that captures the essence of a traditional cheesesteak. It proves that even in a mall setting, great taste can be achieved.