9 Cracker Barrel Meals You Should Never Try

Cracker Barrel might be known for its comforting Southern-style food, but not every item on the menu is worth the calories (or the regret). Whether it’s due to disappointing flavor, sky-high sodium, or just being downright heavy, here are 9 Cracker Barrel meals that diners often wish they had skipped.

1. Chicken Fried Chicken

Start with a Southern classic gone awry. The Chicken Fried Chicken at Cracker Barrel is an oversized breaded delight drowning in gravy. Packed with sodium and saturated fat, it leaves you feeling sluggish and parched. The first bite might remind you of home-cooked meals, but soon enough, the saltiness takes over. For those watching their intake, this dish is a hefty choice. You might crave a refreshing drink more than dessert afterward. Despite its comforting appearance, this meal often falls short, leaving diners wishing they had chosen something lighter.

2. Country Fried Shrimp

Shrimp sounds light, right? Unfortunately, not when it’s Cracker Barrel’s Country Fried Shrimp. Breaded and fried to oblivion, these shrimp are more batter than seafood. Diners often find the texture disappointing, with the crunch overpowering the shrimp’s natural flavor. Accompanied by hushpuppies and fries, this meal is a calorie bomb. The abundance of fried elements leaves little room for freshness. Customers might anticipate a coastal treat but end up with a fried overload. If you’re looking for seafood, you might want to explore other menu options.

3. Double Cheeseburger

In a place famous for its Southern fare, a heavy burger feels out of place. The Double Cheeseburger at Cracker Barrel is a greasy indulgence that might not satisfy every craving. Overcooked patties and a soggy bun take away from the experience. While it promises a comforting bite, the reality is often different. Diners report uneven textures and flavors. If you’re there for authentic Southern cuisine, this option might be disappointing. Seek the comfort of a classic dish instead, leaving the burgers to other establishments renowned for them.

4. Fried Catfish

Catfish can be delightful, but not when it emerges from the kitchen over-fried. Cracker Barrel’s Fried Catfish is often criticized for being soggy and underseasoned. The delicate fish flavor can be overshadowed by the unappetizing batter. Diners frequently mention a lack of seasoning, leaving the dish tasting either bland or overwhelmingly fishy. While it might look appealing, appearances can be deceiving. Those craving a flavorful seafood experience may need to look elsewhere. It’s a reminder that not every dish is a catch of the day at this establishment.

5. Macaroni n’ Cheese (as a side)

Surprisingly, the Macaroni n’ Cheese at Cracker Barrel doesn’t hit the mark. It appears creamy yet lacks the sharp cheesy flavor many anticipate. What starts as a promising side dish often turns gummy quickly. Diners expecting a rich, cheesy experience might find themselves disappointed. Despite its classic appearance, the taste is often underwhelming. If you’re seeking a flavorful side to complement your meal, you might want to consider other options on the menu. This side dish serves as a reminder that looks can be deceiving.

6. Grilled Chicken Tenders

For those looking for a healthier choice, the Grilled Chicken Tenders might seem appealing. However, they can often be dry and uninspiring. Intended as a light meal, the tenders sometimes lack the juiciness one expects from a good cut of chicken. With each bite, diners may long for more flavor. A sprinkle of seasoning could make a world of difference, yet it’s often missing. While the idea of grilled tenders is enticing, execution is key. If you’re after a memorable dining experience, this might not be the best option.

7. Meatloaf

Meatloaf at Cracker Barrel is a gamble. Sometimes moist and flavorful, other times dry or overly sweet. The inconsistency can be frustrating for those yearning for a comforting meal. When it hits the mark, it’s delightful, but unfortunately, that’s not always the case. The texture can be spongy, leaving you questioning the ingredients. For a dish meant to evoke warmth and nostalgia, it often misses the target. If you’re in the mood for reliable comfort food, this might not be the safest bet. Exploring other menu items could be wiser.

8. Biscuit Breakfast Sandwiches

A biscuit sandwich sounds like a breakfast dream, but beware. Cracker Barrel’s version often suffers from a dry, crumbly biscuit that causes the sandwich to disintegrate. The uneven distribution of egg and cheese can turn breakfast into a messy affair. Despite the appealing idea, execution is crucial. Diners expecting a seamless blend of flavors might be left wanting. A breakfast sandwich should be comforting and easy to enjoy, yet this one can be more work than it’s worth. Perhaps another breakfast choice would start the day on a better note.

9. Sunday Homestyle Chicken (if you’re in a rush)

On a leisurely day, the Sunday Homestyle Chicken is a treat. However, if time is of the essence, this meal can be a frustration. Made to order, it typically takes longer than expected, causing impatience for those in a hurry. While flavorful and satisfying, the wait can overshadow the enjoyment. It’s perfect for a relaxed dining experience but unsuitable for rushed meals. Dining with children? The long wait might test their patience. A reminder that timing is everything when choosing this dish.