I Tried 20 Cheesesteak Sandwiches And Only One Came Out On Top

Embark on a flavorful journey as I navigate through 20 different cheesesteak sandwiches, each offering a unique taste experience. From fast-food staples to renowned Philly classics, I tried them all to find the ultimate cheesesteak. Join me as I recount the highs, lows, and everything in between, ultimately crowning the best cheesesteak of them all.

1. Subway Cheesesteak

Subway offers convenience, but their cheesesteak stands as a footlong of mediocrity. The meat is chewy, lacking the tender richness one expects. Bland cheese does little to elevate this sandwich.
It’s a meal that serves its purpose if you’re in a hurry, yet falls short of true culinary satisfaction. The bread, while fresh, doesn’t save it.
For those seeking a quick fix, it delivers in speed, not quality. Fans of authentic cheesesteaks may find themselves disappointed. Still, it’s a recognizable option for many.

2. Arby’s Fire-Roasted Philly

Arby’s Fire-Roasted Philly tries hard with a smoky flavor that hits first, yet lacks deeper substance. The meat, while generous, doesn’t sing in harmony with the cheese.
It’s a sandwich that could impress with its smoky allure, yet it leaves one craving more depth. The bread holds well, but the overall experience feels incomplete.
Ideal for those who favor a smoky profile, it nonetheless doesn’t quite capture the essence of a great cheesesteak.

3. Jersey Mike’s Philly

Jersey Mike’s Philly delivers fresh bread and decent meat, yet misses the greasy punch of authenticity. It’s a sandwich that stands firm in quality ingredients but lacks the indulgent charm some crave.
The balance of flavors is present, yet the excitement feels subdued. For those who appreciate a cleaner taste, it may satisfy.
However, the absence of that satisfying kick leaves a gap for die-hard cheesesteak fans. A reliable choice, but not a thrilling one.

4. Wawa Cheesesteak (PA/NJ)

Wawa, a beloved gas station brand, offers a cheesesteak that remains a favorite in PA and NJ. The meat-to-bread ratio feels off, yet its local charm persists.
The taste captures a nostalgic essence, melding with memories of road trips and convenience stops. It’s a sandwich that evokes hometown pride despite its culinary shortcomings.
Loved by many for its accessibility, it holds a special place, even if it doesn’t top the taste charts.

5. Quiznos Philly Cheesesteak

Quiznos brings a toasted and gooey twist to the Philly cheesesteak, yet it lacks the punch of seasoning true fans crave. The cheese melds beautifully, yet the steak texture falls short.
It’s a warm, comforting option for those seeking familiarity but not adventure. While the toasty exterior pleases the palate, the interior begs for more flavor.
For those who cherish the Quiznos style, it satisfies, but for purists, it might just miss the mark.

6. Sonic Cheesesteak Melt

Sonic delivers a Cheesesteak Melt where cheese takes the spotlight, overshadowing the salty meat beneath. It’s a sandwich that speaks to those who love their dairy.
The melt oozes with indulgence, yet the balance feels skewed. The classic drive-in charm remains intact, making it an experience in nostalgia.
For cheese enthusiasts, it holds appeal, but for those seeking steak dominance, it may disappoint. A curious blend of flavors and sensations.

7. Sheetz Steak Sub

Sheetz offers a Steak Sub that feels more like a novelty than a classic. Toppings overshadow the steak, creating a taste barrage that confuses the palate.
It’s a sub that promises variety, yet the core essence of steak gets lost. Fans of loaded sandwiches may find joy in its chaotic mix.
For those seeking a traditional experience, it strays too far from the path. A sub for the adventurous, not the purist.

8. Charleys Philly Steaks

Charleys Philly Steaks offers a solid chain option with the aid of peppers and onions. It’s a sandwich that delivers on fast food convenience, yet its meat lacks the depth of higher quality cuts.
The flavors meld well, capturing a classic essence, but the experience remains firmly within the realm of fast food.
For those seeking a quick fix without high expectations, it suffices. Yet, connoisseurs may yearn for more robust offerings.

9. Domino’s Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich

Domino’s surprises with a Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich that leans more towards a steak panini. The crusty bread and tender filling create a harmonious bite.
It’s an unexpected pleasure from a pizza chain, offering more than anticipated but still not a true Philly experience.
For those open to fusion flavors, it could delight. Yet, traditionalists might find the deviation too great. A delightful detour for the adventurous eater.

10. Jimmy John’s Steak Club

Jimmy John’s presents a Steak Club that feels more deli than cheesesteak. The ingredients shine in quality, adding a fresh and flavorful bite.
While it doesn’t capture the full cheesesteak essence, it delights in its own right. The sandwich stands as a testament to clean, simple tastes.
For those who enjoy deli-style offerings with a hint of steak, it satisfies. Yet, purists might find it lacking in authentic cheesesteak flair.

11. Capriotti’s Cheese Steak

Capriotti’s offers a Cheese Steak with a savory and perfectly balanced profile. The roll, top-tier in quality, complements the tender meat beautifully.
It’s a sandwich that feels complete, each bite resonating with flavor harmony. A standout for those who appreciate quality craftsmanship in their meals.
For anyone seeking a blend of tradition and taste, it delivers splendidly. A true gem in the cheesesteak lineup, beloved by many.

12. Fat Sal’s (LA)

Fat Sal’s in LA offers a massive and indulgent cheesesteak, filled to the brim with chaotic flavor. It’s a sandwich that sparks excitement, yet may overwhelm with its size.
The bold combination of ingredients creates an unforgettable experience for those daring enough to try. However, simplicity is sacrificed in the name of extravagance.
For thrill-seekers and big appetites, it’s a winner. Yet, those craving subtlety might find it too much.

13. Boo’s Philly Cheesesteaks (LA)

Boo’s brings a legit taste of Philly to the West Coast with their cheesesteaks. Sharp provolone shines as a standout feature, enhancing the authenticity.
It’s a sandwich that transports you to Philly with every bite, capturing the true spirit of the classic. For those missing home or seeking genuine flavor, it delivers.
A delightful find in LA, proving that cheesesteak love knows no bounds. Perfect for both locals and visiting aficionados.

14. Steve’s Prince of Steaks (Philadelphia)

Steve’s Prince of Steaks serves a classic, simple cheesesteak heavy on the Whiz. It’s a local go-to, honored for its straightforward approach.
While it may not wow every palate, it holds a cherished place in Philly’s culinary heart. A sandwich for those who appreciate tradition over innovation.
For first-timers and seasoned fans alike, it offers a taste of Philly’s rich heritage, though it didn’t top this round.

15. Geno’s Steaks (Philadelphia)

Geno’s Steaks captures attention with its bright and flashy presence, yet the steak lacked seasoning this time around. It’s a sandwich that dazzles visually more than it satisfies the taste buds.
While still a staple in the Philly scene, it leans on its vibrant style rather than robust flavor. For those drawn to spectacle, it’s intriguing.
However, seekers of authentic taste might find it wanting. A Philly experience not to be missed, but not the crowning glory.

16. Pat’s King of Steaks (Philadelphia)

Pat’s King of Steaks holds the title of original legend, yet felt rushed and dry on this occasion. It’s a sandwich steeped in history, yet not meeting expectations this round.
While it remains a must-visit for its iconic status, the experience didn’t deliver on the day.
For those seeking a piece of cheesesteak history, it’s still essential, though perhaps not the ultimate champion.

17. Tony Luke’s (Philadelphia)

Tony Luke’s offers a cheesesteak with great bread and solid steak, yet the freshness didn’t shine through as expected. It’s a sandwich that promises much, delivering on some fronts but not all.
For those who appreciate a good roll, it stands out, yet the overall flavor needed more spark.
A reliable choice for many, it holds a strong position in Philly’s food scene but isn’t the ultimate standout on this journey.

18. John’s Roast Pork (Philadelphia)

John’s Roast Pork presents a cheesesteak with tender steak, perfectly grilled onions, and sharp provolone on a crusty seeded roll. It’s a sandwich that feels elite in every sense.
Each element is masterfully balanced, creating a flavor symphony that resonates deeply.
For those seeking the pinnacle of cheesesteak artistry, it’s a top contender, offering a genuine taste of Philly’s finest.

19. Dalessandro’s Steaks (Philadelphia)

Dalessandro’s Steaks impresses with finely chopped, juicy meat and super flavorful profile. It’s a sandwich that stands out for its rich taste and meticulous preparation.
Ideal for those who appreciate texture and flavor working in harmony, it captures the essence of a great cheesesteak.
A tough contender in the lineup, its delightful nuances make it unforgettable for many.

20. Angelo’s Pizzeria (Philadelphia)

Angelo’s Pizzeria emerges as the winner, with a cheesesteak that has it all. Juicy, thick-cut ribeye, rich melted Cooper Sharp cheese, and caramelized onions create a perfect harmony.
The roll, crunchy outside and fluffy inside, soaks up flavor without becoming soggy. Each bite is a flavor bomb, an experience beyond just a sandwich.
For those seeking the ultimate indulgence, it’s unrivaled. A true masterpiece that leaves a lasting impression.