We Tasted Every Girl Scout Cookie Ranked From Best To Worst
In the world of Girl Scout Cookies, every flavor tells a story of nostalgia, indulgence, and sweet delight. From timeless classics to modern innovations, we embarked on a flavorful journey to rank these cookies from best to worst. Here’s our take on these beloved treats, each offering its own unique taste and texture adventure.
1. Thin Mints
Crisp and cool, Thin Mints are the gold standard of Girl Scout Cookies. Their refreshing minty bite, wrapped in a crisp chocolate shell, has enchanted taste buds for generations. A popular choice for freezing, these cookies are perfect for a chilled indulgence.
Their versatility makes them a favorite for cookie-based desserts. Often regarded as the benchmark for mint cookies, Thin Mints never fail to impress. If they don’t match your taste preference, it’s a testament to the diversity of palates.
Their legacy is a testament to quality, embodying the essence of classic Girl Scout spirit.
2. Caramel deLites / Samoas
Caramel deLites, known as Samoas in some areas, are a chewy delight. The luscious combination of coconut, gooey caramel, and chocolate creates a flavor explosion that lingers long after the last bite.
These cookies are not just about taste; they evoke memories of campfires and storytelling. Their sticky sweetness is beautifully contrasted by the crisp cookie base. Despite their rich profile, they maintain a balance that is hard to find in similar treats.
Every bite is a journey through textures, making them both memorable and irresistible.
3. Tagalongs / Peanut Butter Patties
Tagalongs, or Peanut Butter Patties, offer a sweet-salty symphony in each bite. With a crispy cookie foundation, creamy peanut butter filling, and a smooth chocolate coating, they deliver a harmonious blend of textures.
These cookies are a nostalgic nod to childhood afternoons filled with laughter and snacks. Their rich flavor profile makes them a standout among peanut butter treats. The interplay of ingredients is a tribute to culinary creativity, turning a simple cookie into a gourmet experience.
Perfect for peanut butter enthusiasts, they promise satisfaction in every piece.
4. Adventurefuls
Adventurefuls are a newer addition to the Girl Scout lineup. These cookies are brownie-inspired with a surprise caramel center, offering a rich and indulgent experience.
They bring the essence of a dessert into a snack format, appealing to chocolate-lovers with their deep cocoa notes. Their indulgent nature is complemented by a subtle caramel touch, adding a layer of complexity.
As a modern contender, Adventurefuls have carved a niche for themselves, inviting both admiration and curiosity from cookie enthusiasts.
5. Trefoils / Shortbread
Trefoils, or Shortbread cookies, are simple yet elegant. Their buttery texture and smooth taste evoke the charm of traditional baking. Perfect with a warm cup of tea or coffee, they offer a comforting experience.
These cookies are an ode to simplicity, proving that less is often more. Their understated flavor allows for versatile pairing with various beverages, enhancing the overall tasting experience.
Despite their modest appearance, Trefoils hold a special place in the cookie hierarchy, celebrating the art of classic shortbread making.
6. Do-si-dos / Peanut Butter Sandwich
Do-si-dos, or Peanut Butter Sandwich cookies, are a hearty option among Girl Scout Cookies. With real peanut butter sandwiched between two oatmeal cookies, they offer a wholesome taste.
These cookies harken back to traditional homemade treats, providing a rustic and satisfying chew. Their earthy flavors are a tribute to comforting, old-fashioned snacks.
Though they may not always be the first choice, their classic appeal and authentic taste make them a cherished option for those seeking a traditional cookie experience.
7. Lemonades
Lemonades are a zesty delight, offering a unique twist on traditional cookies. Their tangy lemon icing atop a sturdy shortbread base provides a refreshing contrast.
These cookies awaken the senses with their bright citrus notes, perfect for summer picnics and sunny afternoons. The blend of tartness with a hint of sweetness creates a balance that is both invigorating and indulgent.
While their bold flavor can be polarizing, Lemonades stand out for their originality and refreshing taste, making them a memorable choice.
8. Toast-Yay!
Toast-Yay! cookies bring the delightful essence of French toast into a bite-sized treat. Their sugary glaze and subtle maple flavor evoke the warmth of a cozy breakfast.
Though inspired by a breakfast classic, the texture leans towards the drier side, providing a distinct crunch. The playful design adds a touch of whimsy, making them a fun snack.
While some might find the flavor a bit artificial, their novelty and creative inspiration are sure to capture attention, offering a unique cookie experience.
9. Toffee-tastic (Gluten-Free)
Toffee-tastic cookies cater to those seeking gluten-free options without compromising on taste. These cookies are crumbly and buttery, dotted with sweet toffee bits that offer a delightful crunch.
While they might lack the cohesive texture of traditional cookies, their rich buttery base compensates with flavor. The toffee pieces add a touch of sweetness that complements the overall profile.
Though not universally appealing, Toffee-tastic carves its niche by providing a gluten-free option that delights the taste buds with its buttery toffee goodness.
10. Lemon-Ups
Lemon-Ups are more than just cookies—they’re a source of inspiration. Each cookie is stamped with a motivational quote, adding a personal touch to the zesty flavor.
With a crisp texture, they offer a light lemon taste that is both refreshing and uplifting. These cookies capture the spirit of positivity and zest for life.
Their airy nature may not cater to everyone, but Lemon-Ups provide a unique experience that combines flavor with a motivational boost. Perfect for those who appreciate a little cheer with their snack.