10 Tuna Subs That Missed the Mark and 5 Worth Ordering Again and Again

Tuna subs can be a hit-or-miss sandwich experience. When done right, they’re creamy, tangy, and satisfying. But when done wrong? You’re stuck with soggy bread, funky fish smell, or an overload of mayo that masks all flavor. Here’s a look at 10 tuna subs that fell flat—and 5 you’ll actually want to keep ordering on repeat.

1. Subway’s Classic Tuna Sub

Subway’s Classic Tuna Sub often leaves sandwich lovers underwhelmed. The overuse of mayonnaise results in a mushy texture, making it hard to enjoy the core flavors of the tuna. Many say the flavor can feel suspicious, leaving you questioning whether to take another bite. Unlike other subs, this one can be bland and unexciting. The heavy mayo content overshadows any hint of vibrant seasoning. It demands a touch of creativity—perhaps some added veggies or a splash of vinegar—to revamp its taste. A little more focus on balance could transform this sub into a much more enjoyable meal.

2. Jersey Mike’s Tuna Fish Sub

Jersey Mike’s Tuna Fish Sub can be a salty surprise, and not always in the best way. Often it makes an inconsistent impression from one store to another, offering a watery, soggy experience due to the abundance of shredded lettuce. This inconsistency can be frustrating for fans seeking a reliable tuna fix. While it aims to deliver a satisfying meal, the saltiness sometimes takes the spotlight, overshadowing the natural taste of the tuna. Finding that perfect bite can feel like a game of chance, leaving some patrons longing for a more balanced flavor profile.

3. Firehouse Subs Tuna Salad Sub

Firehouse Subs Tuna Salad Sub struggles with an imbalance between bread and filling. The tuna itself tends to get lost amidst the heavy bread-to-filling ratio, leaving you yearning for that perfect bite of tuna salad. The lack of crunch or brightness further diminishes its appeal. While the bread provides a decent bite, the overall experience can feel disappointingly one-dimensional. A little more creativity with the texture and seasonings could elevate this sub significantly. Fans of Firehouse Subs might appreciate the bread quality but might wish for more tuna prominence.

4. Jimmy John’s Totally Tuna

Jimmy John’s Totally Tuna takes simplicity to the extreme, leading to a dry and basic experience. It arrives without cheese, pickles, or much seasoning, leaving it feeling somewhat unfinished. This sub seems to miss the mark in delivering a full-flavored sandwich. The straightforward approach may appeal to some, but many crave a touch of creativity to bring out the tuna’s potential. By adding a few more ingredients or condiments, it could transform into a more satisfying meal. As it stands, it remains a minimalist option for those seeking a quick, uncomplicated bite.

5. Wawa Classic Tuna Hoagie

Wawa Classic Tuna Hoagie often falls victim to an overly mushy texture, sometimes served at a less than ideal temperature. The tuna-mayo ratio is often off, making for a soggy experience that can leave some patrons disappointed. Though Wawa is known for its convenience, this particular sub can feel lacking in freshness and flavor. The hoagie cries out for some added crunch or seasoning to lift it above mediocrity. Despite its flaws, it serves its purpose as a quick meal, but those seeking more might look elsewhere for a satisfying tuna fix.

6. Blimpie Tuna Sub

Blimpie Tuna Sub tends to blend into the background, offering nothing that stands out. The sub can feel bland and overly processed, quickly succumbing to a soggy texture. For those seeking flavor, this might not be the first choice. The lack of distinct seasoning or crunch leaves it tasting underwhelming. It’s a basic sub that serves its purpose but doesn’t inspire excitement. Some loyal fans may appreciate its simplicity, but others might wish for a bit more creativity in its presentation and flavor. It’s a straightforward choice in a crowded sub market.

7. Publix Tuna Sub

Publix Tuna Sub can swing between being acceptable and too wet, often overloaded with mayonnaise. This inconsistency can be frustrating for those who depend on Publix for a reliable meal. The wetness can overshadow the flavor and texture of the tuna, making it less appealing. Adding pickles or banana peppers can introduce some much-needed zing, but it doesn’t always save the day. For a truly satisfying experience, a better balance is needed. Despite its occasional shortcomings, Publix continues to be a go-to deli for many, offering potential for delightful customization.

8. Quiznos Tuna Melt

Quiznos Tuna Melt attempts to stand out with its toasting, but unfortunately, the saltiness of the tuna often takes over. While the gooey cheese is a tempting addition, it sometimes masks the star of the show—the tuna. The combination can make for an uneven eating experience, leaving some bites feeling more satisfying than others. Fans of melted cheese might find solace in its warmth, but the overall saltiness can detract from its potential. A touch more balance in seasoning could elevate this sub to greater heights, making it a preferred choice.

9. Sheetz Tuna Sub

Sheetz Tuna Sub can feel like a missed opportunity for freshness, often leaning towards a heavy-on-oil experience. The pre-mixed nature of the tuna eliminates any potential for texture or freshness. For those seeking a crisp and vibrant sub, this might not hit the mark. The lack of texture can make it feel unappealing, especially later in the day. While Sheetz offers convenience, those craving a flavorful tuna experience might look elsewhere. A bit of reimagining in the preparation could transform this into a more exciting option for fast-food lovers.

10. QuickChek Tuna Sub

QuickChek Tuna Sub, while affordable and available, often falls flat in the flavor department. The sub can feel overly chilled, which diminishes its appeal and leaves it as a last resort for some. While it provides a quick meal option, the lack of flavor complexity can disappoint those seeking more than just a basic sandwich. The chilled nature of the sub might appeal to some, but others might prefer a warmer, more inviting option. A little more focus on flavor and presentation could make this a more desirable choice for hungry customers.

11. Potbelly’s Tuna Salad Sandwich

Potbelly’s Tuna Salad Sandwich offers a delightful balance of freshness and flavor. It’s not drowning in mayo, allowing the quality of the tuna to shine through. The toasted bread adds a satisfying crunch, enhancing the overall experience. Fans of Potbelly appreciate the well-balanced concoction that feels both hearty and refreshing. A touch of creativity in the choice of ingredients provides a unique twist, making it a favorite for many. For those who appreciate a well-crafted sub, Potbelly delivers a delightful treat worth savoring again and again.

12. Ike’s Love & Sandwiches “Tom Brady” (Tuna Version)

Ike’s Love & Sandwiches “Tom Brady” (Tuna Version) packs a punch with its vibrant personality. Avocado, pickles, and zesty sauces transform this tuna sub into a crave-worthy delight. Each bite offers a burst of flavor that keeps you coming back for more. Ike’s unique approach to sandwiches shines through, making it a beloved choice for adventurous eaters. The combination of fresh ingredients and tantalizing sauces creates a masterpiece that stands out. Fans of bold flavors will find this sub an irresistible option that’s hard to forget.

13. Mendocino Farms “Not So Fried” Tuna Melt

Mendocino Farms’ “Not So Fried” Tuna Melt raises the bar with an artisan-level upgrade. The seared albacore offers a rich yet balanced flavor, complemented by pickled onions and melted cheese. Each element plays a role in crafting a satisfying dish that feels both indulgent and refined. Fans of Mendocino Farms appreciate the attention to detail and quality ingredients that elevate this melt. It’s a sophisticated take on a classic, making it a go-to for those seeking a gourmet experience. This melt is a testament to flavor innovation, worth every bite.

14. Capriotti’s Tuna Sub

Capriotti’s Tuna Sub delivers a consistently satisfying experience with its creamy, well-seasoned tuna. The texture finds a perfect balance, creating a sub that feels both luxurious and fulfilling. Generous fillings and fresh greens enhance the flavor, making each bite enjoyable. Fans of Capriotti’s value the predictable quality that makes this sub a reliable favorite. The attention to detail and commitment to flavors make it stand out in the crowded world of tuna subs. For those in search of a dependable and tasty option, Capriotti’s Tuna Sub is a must-try.

15. Local Deli Tuna Melt on Rye

Local Deli Tuna Melt on Rye can be a delightful find when everything aligns perfectly. With crisp bread, sharp cheddar, and fresh tuna salad, it’s a combination that sings when done right. This melt varies by location, but when a local spot gets it right, it offers an unbeatable experience. Fans of unique flavors appreciate the risk and reward of finding a perfect melt at their neighborhood deli. It’s a testament to the magic of local cuisine, where a simple yet expertly made sandwich can become a cherished memory.