8 Overpriced Sam’s Club Buys To Skip Plus 3 That Just Aren’t Worth The Cart Space

Sam’s Club is known for bulk bargains, but not everything with a big price tag equals big value. Some items cost more per unit than you’d pay at regular grocery stores, and others just don’t justify the space they take up in your pantry—or your cart. Here are 8 overpriced buys you should skip, plus 3 more that are just a waste of space no matter how tempting they look in bulk.

1. Pre-Cut Fruit Trays

Convenience comes at a cost. Pre-cut fruit trays often feature a bright mix of fruits. Yet, the reality is far from the glossy image. Fruits like kiwi, strawberries, and melon in these trays are frequently underripe, overripe, or just plain bland. It’s the allure of convenience versus freshness.

When you buy them, you’re not just paying for the fruit; you’re paying for labor and packaging. And unfortunately, they’re usually not the freshest picks. The premium price hardly makes up for the subpar taste and quality.

Opting for whole fruits and slicing them yourself ensures freshness and flavor.

2. Name-Brand Cereal Multipacks

Bulk buying cereal can seem appealing. Name-brand cereal multipacks promise variety but often deliver disappointment. Per ounce, these multipacks can cost more than buying individual boxes on sale at your local grocery store.

The risk of staleness looms as those multiple boxes sit in your cupboard. The thrill of choice quickly wanes as the months pass. Variety might be the spice of life, but freshness is the key to flavor.

Consider purchasing smaller quantities during sales to enjoy fresh cereal without committing to a bulk pack that loses its allure over time.

3. Individual Yogurt Cups

Yogurt is a staple for many, but not all yogurt buys are created equal. Individual yogurt cups in bulk are rarely a thrifty choice. Despite their convenience, they typically cost more per ounce than larger tubs.

You’ll also contribute to more plastic waste, negating any environmental goodwill. Instead, purchasing larger tubs allows you to portion out servings as needed.

This approach not only saves money but also reduces environmental impact. Consider the larger tub for both your wallet and the planet. It’s a small change with a big impact.

4. Bottled Starbucks Frappuccinos

Starbucks Frappuccinos are a caffeine lover’s delight—when bought occasionally. Purchasing them in bulk, however, inflates costs rather than offering savings. You’re paying for the brand, convenience, and a sweet experience packaged in glass.

For far less, you can brew your own iced coffee at home with your favorite flavors. Not only is it more economical, but it’s also customizable to your taste. Adding a touch of your favorite syrup or milk creates a personalized treat without the premium price.

Invest in a coffee maker and indulge in homemade brews anytime.

5. Frozen Appetizer Platters

Frozen appetizer platters are the ultimate party hack—or are they? Their promise of convenience is tantalizing, yet their price and quality often disappoint. Tiny delights like mini quiches and puff pastries look appetizing in the packaging but often emerge tasting like freezer burn.

Homemade alternatives or store-brand versions from a local grocery usually offer better taste and value. You might find the same appetizers at a lower cost, with superior flavor, elsewhere.

For your next gathering, try homemade options, or shop local brands for a better culinary experience.

6. Large Jars of Nut Butters (Especially Organic)

Nut butter enthusiasts beware! Those colossal jars of almond or peanut butter might seem like a healthy, economical choice. However, unless you’re using them daily, they risk going rancid before you can finish them.

Especially with organic varieties, the freshness doesn’t last as long. The oils separate, and the texture becomes unappealing. Smaller jars, bought more frequently, retain their flavor and are often cheaper when bought on sale.

So unless you’re spooning it out regularly, stick to grocery sales for smaller, fresher portions that won’t break the bank—or your taste buds.

7. Sam’s Club Branded Trash Bags

Trash bags aren’t glamorous, but they are essential. Yet, Sam’s Club branded trash bags don’t necessarily offer the best deal. While they serve their basic purpose, they often lack the strength and durability of competitors.

Other retail giants like Target or Walmart can offer better quality and pricing. You don’t have to compromise durability for cost; you just need to shop smart.

Explore other brands during sales or compare prices at different stores. Fortifying your trash with a better-built bag is worth the extra effort.

8. Greeting Cards and Gift Wrap Sets

The allure of bulk greeting cards and gift wrap sets can be strong, especially during festive seasons. However, while the bulk price may seem appealing, the designs can be hit-or-miss.

You might find yourself using only a couple of cards out of an entire pack, leaving the rest to collect dust. Instead, purchasing individually allows for more thoughtful and personalized choices.

The satisfaction of selecting the perfect card shouldn’t be underestimated. Opting for individual cards and wraps ensures you get exactly what you need without excess—and all without breaking the bank.

9. Giant Boxes of Chips or Snack Mix

Snack lovers, beware! Giant boxes of chips or snack mix might catch your eye. Their allure fades fast, as half the bag is often air. The excitement of variety wears off when flavors become monotonous.

As the days pass, chips tend to go stale, making bulk purchases less appealing. Smaller bags allow for fresher snacking and less waste, keeping your pantry organized and flavors fresh.

For variety and freshness, buy smaller packs that can be consumed quickly and enjoyably. They offer flexibility without the commitment of bulk, ensuring every bite is delightful.

10. Oversized Spices

Spice up your life, but not at the cost of flavor. Oversized spices might seem economical, but they can clump or lose flavor before being fully used. That 24-ounce garlic powder is tempting, but freshness trumps bulk every time.

Spices are best purchased in smaller quantities, ensuring maximum flavor. Plus, it allows you to experiment with different spices without over-committing.

Explore ethnic markets for authentic, vibrant spices in just the right amounts. It’s a culinary adventure that won’t break the bank or flavor.

11. Humongous Baked Goods (Looking at You, Muffin Tray)

Baked goods have an undeniable charm, especially in bulk. However, humongous trays of muffins, cakes, or croissants often end up stale or in the freezer. Unless catering to a crowd, their size can be overwhelming.

The initial satisfaction diminishes as freshness fades. Smaller, freshly baked options from local bakeries or markets are often more satisfying. They offer variety in taste and quality without overwhelming quantity.

Enjoy the simple pleasure of a fresh pastry without committing to bulk. Savor each bite, and relish the freedom to choose anew with every visit.