9 Tuna Sandwiches That Missed and 6 Sub Chain Picks You’d Actually Order Again

Tuna sandwiches are a staple in many sub chains and delis, offering a quick meal solution for those on the go. However, not all tuna sandwiches are created equal. While some tantalize the taste buds with creamy, well-seasoned flavors, others fall flat with bland, uninspired presentations. This blog explores nine tuna sandwiches that didn’t quite hit the mark and contrasts them with six sub chain options that are worth ordering again. Whether you’re in search of the perfect lunchtime treat or seeking to avoid a soggy disappointment, this guide has you covered.

1. Subway’s Classic Tuna

Subway’s Classic Tuna is a lesson in excess. The sandwich overflows with mayonnaise, masking any hint of tuna. Its mushy texture doesn’t help its cause, leaving the palate yearning for something more substantial. The flavor profile is overwhelmingly bland, with little to no seasoning to lift the dish. In contrast to Subway’s other offerings, this tuna sandwich feels carelessly thrown together, lacking the vibrancy and freshness that makes a great sandwich. Despite its shortcomings, it remains a popular choice, perhaps due to brand recognition rather than taste.

2. Jimmy John’s Totally Tuna

Imagine a tuna sandwich that lacks zest and character; Jimmy John’s Totally Tuna fits this description perfectly. The tuna blend feels almost liquid, soaking the bread and diminishing the overall experience. While the bread at Jimmy John’s is known for its quality, it often overshadows the weak tuna flavor, leaving a lackluster impression. It’s a sandwich that fails to excite, often leaving patrons wondering if a different menu choice might have been wiser. For a sandwich that promises so little, it’s surprising how consistently it underdelivers.

3. Dunkin’ Tuna Melt (RIP)

The short-lived Dunkin’ Tuna Melt was a curious creation that intrigued more than it satisfied. Weirdly sweet with an odd texture, this melt didn’t win hearts. Its quick departure from the menu speaks volumes about its lack of popularity. Combining tuna with a sweet glaze and melted cheese, the result was a clash of flavors that didn’t quite harmonize. While innovation is often welcome, this particular experiment left many scratching their heads. Despite its intriguing concept, the execution fell short, marking its swift exit.

4. Wawa Tuna Hoagie

Wawa, a brand typically associated with quality, unfortunately misses the mark with its Tuna Hoagie. The salad’s inconsistency is its downfall, oscillating between overly salty and utterly bland. While Wawa’s bread is reliably fresh, the filling often lets it down. Occasional hits of flavor are overshadowed by frequent misses, leaving the diner unsure of what to expect with each bite. It’s a sandwich that mirrors a game of culinary roulette. Although Wawa’s other offerings shine, their tuna hoagie remains a gamble at best.

5. Sheetz Tuna Sub

The Sheetz Tuna Sub feels uninspired, reminiscent of a homemade lunch rather than a crafted sandwich. The filling seems to be straight-from-the-can tuna, mixed with mayonnaise in abundance. It’s not a complete disaster but falls short of enticing. Encased in a decent roll, the sandwich provides basic sustenance without the thrill. It’s a reliable option for those in a rush, yet fails to leave a memorable impression. Sheetz offers convenience and speed, albeit at the expense of taste with this particular choice.

6. Quiznos Tuna Melt

Quiznos Tuna Melt disappoints with its greasy bread and overly rich filling. The sandwich feels weighed down, trapped by its own heaviness. While Quiznos is known for its toasted subs, this one misses the mark. The tuna blend lacks the vibrant punch one might expect, resulting in a lackluster meal experience. For a chain that promises bold flavors and creativity, this offering feels underwhelming and heavy-handed. Though it might satisfy hunger, it fails to excite the taste buds or deliver on expectations.

7. Kroger Deli Tuna Sandwich

Kroger Deli Tuna Sandwich is a study in variability. Depending on the location, it ranges from quite tasty to disappointingly soggy. Freshness is a critical factor, inconsistent in its delivery. Some days, the tuna is lively and flavorful, while other times it seems tired and limp. The bread often absorbs more moisture than it should, resulting in a less-than-optimal texture. It’s a hit-or-miss experience that can perplex shoppers. For a quick grocery store lunch, it suffices, but don’t expect culinary fireworks.

8. Starbucks Tuna Melt Panini

Starbucks Tuna Melt Panini is an audacious choice with its blend of tuna and cheese. This combination proves polarizing, as the strong fishy taste often overpowers everything else. The melted cheese, intended to add richness, instead contributes to a muddled taste. While the concept might appeal, the reality is divisive. Starbucks, often celebrated for its coffee, finds itself in a challenging position with this sandwich. It’s a bold attempt that might find fans in adventurous eaters but remains a confusing option for many.

9. Pret A Manger Tuna & Cucumber

Pret A Manger’s Tuna & Cucumber sandwich offers a minimalist take that many find underwhelming. The watery cucumber slices clash with a dry tuna salad, creating a forgettable experience. This simplicity fails to capture the essence of what makes a tuna sandwich delightful. The sandwich promises freshness but often falls short, leaving a lack of satisfaction. For a brand that prides itself on quick, quality meals, this offering comes across as lackluster. It’s a choice that might appeal to those seeking something light, but lacks impact.

10. Jersey Mike’s Tuna Sub

Jersey Mike’s Tuna Sub stands out with its creamy, flavorful filling, freshly made daily. The sandwich balances taste and texture, with a variety of veggies adding a satisfying crunch. Unlike many of its counterparts, it delivers a consistent and delicious experience. The freshness of the ingredients shines, providing a meal that’s both hearty and refreshing. Whether you’re a tuna aficionado or just exploring, this sub proves to be a delightful choice. Jersey Mike’s commitment to quality and flavor is evident in every bite.

11. Panera Bread Tuna Salad Sandwich

Panera Bread’s Tuna Salad Sandwich is a harmonious blend of light and flavorful elements. The crunchy celery complements the creamy tuna perfectly, while the fresh ciabatta roll resists sogginess. This sandwich delights with its balance and attention to detail. Panera’s dedication to quality ingredients and thoughtful preparation is evident here. It’s a reliable option for those seeking a satisfying lunch that doesn’t compromise on taste. Whether enjoyed in the café or taken to go, this sandwich consistently delivers on its promise of freshness and flavor.

12. Firehouse Subs Tuna Salad

Firehouse Subs Tuna Salad is a hidden gem, not always available but memorable when it is. The tuna is chunky and flavorful, seasoned to perfection, creating a satisfying bite every time. While not a permanent fixture on their menu, its presence is eagerly anticipated by fans. The sandwich strikes a balance between quality ingredients and bold flavor, making it a standout choice. It’s a hearty offering that satisfies without overwhelming, showcasing what a tuna sandwich can be at its best. Firehouse’s care in preparation shines through.

13. Potbelly Tuna Salad Sandwich

Potbelly’s Tuna Salad Sandwich may surprise those unfamiliar with its quality. The sandwich achieves a great balance of mayonnaise, seasonings, and texture, especially when served on multigrain bread. It’s a sleeper hit that often goes unnoticed in the lineup but delivers in flavor. The tuna is well-prepared, offering a delightful creamy yet textured bite. Potbelly ensures that each ingredient contributes to a cohesive and delicious meal. It’s a choice that satisfies those looking for something more than the average. Potbelly’s attention to detail enhances the experience.

14. Erbert & Gerbert’s Bornk Tuna Sandwich

Erbert & Gerbert’s Bornk Tuna Sandwich embodies simplicity and taste. This midwestern chain offers a soft, inviting bread that houses a tuna mix with actual flavor. It’s a straightforward sandwich that doesn’t overcomplicate, focusing instead on delivering a satisfying meal. The balance of ingredients ensures that each bite resonates with flavor and comfort. Erbert & Gerbert’s quiet dedication to quality shines, making this sandwich a delight in the often overwhelming world of deli offerings. It’s an unassuming choice that surprises with its quality and taste.

15. Blimpie Tuna Sub

Blimpie’s Tuna Sub brings nostalgia and satisfaction in equal measure. Creamy and well-balanced, it’s an old-school choice that doesn’t disappoint. The sub is completely customizable, allowing for a personal touch that many appreciate. Blimpie’s commitment to tradition is evident, offering a tuna sub that remains relevant and enjoyable. It’s a sandwich that harks back to simpler times, while still providing the flavor and quality that modern diners expect. This blend of history and taste makes the Blimpie Tuna Sub a timeless option worth revisiting.