8 Fried Fish Chains to Skip — And 8 That Serve It Just Right

When it comes to fried fish chains, not all are created equal. Some leave you yearning for more, while others provide a delightful seafood experience. In this post, we’re diving into eight fried fish chains you might want to skip and eight alternatives that serve it just right. Whether you’re craving a nostalgic bite or a modern twist, this guide will help you navigate the sea of options to find the perfect place for your next fish fry indulgence.

1. Skip: Long John Silver’s

Long John Silver’s, once a staple of fast-food seafood, often leaves diners with a greasy disappointment. The fish comes out coated in a soggy batter that lacks the satisfying crunch many seek. It’s paired with sides that are overly salted, making the overall meal feel like a salt overload. Patrons hoping for a crispy, flavorful bite might find themselves unsatisfied and searching for a napkin to dab off excess oil. In recent years, reviews suggest that quality and consistency have slipped, leaving this chain as more of a nostalgic memory rather than a current favorite.

2. Try Instead: Captain D’s

Captain D’s offers a refreshing alternative to the typical fast-food seafood experience. Known for its consistency and quality, this chain provides a wider variety of seafood, including healthier grilled options. The fried fish is often praised for its crispiness and flavor, leaving diners satisfied with each bite. The sides offer more balance, complementing the main dish rather than overwhelming it. With a more inviting atmosphere and an eye for better presentation, Captain D’s stands out as a worthwhile option for seafood lovers seeking more than just a quick fix.

3. Skip: Arthur Treacher’s

Arthur Treacher’s, once a flourishing name in fried fish, now struggles to maintain relevance and quality. The fish, often criticized for being heavily battered, lacks the flavorful punch many crave. Its sides do little to elevate the meal, leaving patrons with a one-note dining experience. As locations dwindle, so does the appeal, making it a choice only for those seeking a taste of nostalgia. The decor and offerings feel stuck in the past, failing to attract a new generation of seafood enthusiasts. It’s a chain that many find to be a shadow of its former self.

4. Try Instead: Ivar’s Seafood Bar

Ivar’s Seafood Bar, a Pacific Northwest treasure, is renowned for serving up golden, crispy fish that delights locals and visitors alike. The use of fresh ingredients shines through in the sides, which complement the main dish perfectly. The tartar sauce, a fan favorite, adds a zesty kick that enhances the meal. The setting is cozy and welcoming, reflecting the region’s love for quality seafood. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Ivar’s offers a fried fish experience that’s rich in flavor and warmth, making it a must-visit on any seafood lover’s list.

5. Skip: Skippers

Skippers, a name that once evoked nostalgic memories for many, now seems to fade into the background of fast-food options. The decor feels like a relic of a bygone era, and the food quality has not kept up with modern tastes. Many patrons notice a decline in the crispiness and flavor of the fish, with sides that do little to inspire. Once cherished for its straightforward approach, Skippers struggles to compete with contemporary chains offering more freshness and flair. It’s a place that may still attract the nostalgic, but for others, there are better options to explore.

6. Try Instead: Legal Sea Foods

Legal Sea Foods, a staple on the East Coast, offers a refreshing take on fried fish that keeps patrons coming back for more. The fish is crisp and clean-tasting, served with delectable house-made sauces that enhance the dining experience. The commitment to freshness is evident in every bite, making it a standout choice for seafood enthusiasts. With an upscale yet approachable atmosphere, Legal Sea Foods provides a dining experience that feels both special and satisfying. It’s a must-try for anyone seeking quality seafood without compromising on flavor or presentation.

7. Skip: Red Lobster

Red Lobster, while famous for its cheddar biscuits, often falls short when it comes to fried seafood. The dishes can be overly breaded and greasy, leaving diners with an experience that feels heavy and less satisfying. Despite the allure of a well-known name, the fried options may not live up to the expectations of true seafood fans. Many find the cost doesn’t justify the meal, especially when flavor and freshness are lacking. For those seeking a more balanced and flavorful fried fish experience, looking beyond Red Lobster’s offerings might be the better choice.

8. Try Instead: Bonefish Grill

Bonefish Grill redefines the fried fish experience with a touch of elegance and modern flair. The lightly fried fish is often praised for its delicate flavor and crisp texture, making it a delightful choice for seafood lovers. Accompanied by contemporary sides, the meal feels well-rounded and satisfying. The plating is thoughtful, adding to the overall dining experience. With a focus on quality and presentation, Bonefish Grill stands out as an upscale casual option that elevates the fried fish dining scene. It’s perfect for those seeking a polished, yet approachable seafood experience.

9. Skip: Captain Hook’s Fish & Chicken

Captain Hook’s Fish & Chicken, often found in less conventional locations like gas stations and corner shops, struggles with consistency. The preparation varies wildly, leaving diners unsure of what to expect with each visit. The flavors are often underwhelming, missing the mark on what makes fried fish appealing. For many, the experience lacks the satisfying crunch and seasoned flavor that elevates a simple dish. It’s a place that might suffice in a pinch, but for a truly enjoyable fried fish meal, there are other options better suited to deliver on flavor and quality.

10. Try Instead: Hook Fish Co.

Hook Fish Co., based in California, offers a modern twist on fried fish with a focus on sustainability and flavor. The seafood is sourced responsibly, ensuring each bite is not only crispy but also guilt-free. The seasoning reflects a vibrant West Coast vibe, enhancing the natural taste of the fish. Patrons appreciate the crisp textures and thoughtful preparation that make every visit memorable. With a commitment to quality and eco-friendly practices, Hook Fish Co. is a delightful choice for those seeking a responsible yet delicious fried fish experience.

11. Skip: Rally’s/Checkers Fish Sandwich

Rally’s/Checkers seasonal fish sandwich often leaves much to be desired for true seafood fans. The sandwich lacks the flavor and crispiness that make fried fish enjoyable, resulting in a rather underwhelming bite. The texture feels processed, detracting from the experience of a real fish sandwich. While convenient in a drive-thru setting, it fails to capture the essence of a satisfying seafood meal. For those who crave a more authentic and flavorful fried fish sandwich, alternatives available at other chains offer more satisfaction and taste, making it worth seeking out better options.

12. Try Instead: Culver’s North Atlantic Cod Sandwich

Culver’s North Atlantic Cod Sandwich has become a standout option for those seeking quality seafood in a fast-food setting. The hand-battered cod fillet is crisp and flaky, offering a delightful texture that pairs perfectly with the toasted bun. Patrons often praise the sandwich for its flavor, which stands out among typical fast-food offerings. It’s a surprising find that showcases how thoughtful preparation can elevate a simple dish. For fans of fried fish looking for a quick yet satisfying meal, Culver’s offers a pleasant surprise that delivers both taste and convenience.

13. Skip: McDonald’s Filet-O-Fish

The Filet-O-Fish at McDonald’s holds nostalgic value for many, yet falls short in delivering a satisfying seafood experience. The small portion and processed nature of the sandwich often leave true seafood enthusiasts wanting more. While the packaging might evoke memories of simpler times, the actual meal may not satisfy the cravings of those seeking fresh, flavorful fish. It’s a choice that might work for a quick fix, but for a more fulfilling bite, other options provide a better showcase of what a fried fish sandwich can be.

14. Try Instead: Arby’s Crispy Fish Sandwich

Arby’s Crispy Fish Sandwich stands out as a more satisfying alternative for those seeking a hearty seafood bite. The larger fillet offers a better texture and flavor profile, complemented by a tangy tartar sauce that adds zest to each bite. It’s a fast-food option that manages to deliver on taste, making it a worthwhile choice for anyone craving fried fish without the fuss. The attention to quality and flavor elevates it from the typical fast-food fare, offering a more enjoyable experience for those who love a good, crispy fish sandwich.

15. Skip: H. Salt Fish & Chips

H. Salt Fish & Chips, once a staple for quick seafood, now feels like a relic of the past. The thick, oily batter often overshadows the fish itself, leaving diners with a greasy aftertaste. Sides such as slaw and fries fail to impress, offering little in the way of flavor or innovation. The overall dining experience feels dated, lacking the freshness and appeal that many seek in their seafood meals. For those in search of a vibrant and flavorful fried fish feast, H. Salt may no longer be the go-to choice.

16. Try Instead: The Codfather

The Codfather brings a taste of Britain to the fried fish scene with its authentic fish and chips offering. The flaky cod is perfectly cooked, enveloped in a crispy coating that satisfies every craving. Real malt vinegar adds the traditional touch that elevates the meal, providing a tangy contrast to the rich flavors. Found in Texas and other regional spots, The Codfather delivers a delightful dining experience that combines classic tastes with local charm. It’s a must-visit for anyone looking to enjoy fish and chips done right, with flavor and flair.