8 Buffalo Sauces That Totally Miss the Mark And 9 Store-Bought Brands That Bring the Heat

Buffalo sauce is more than just spice—it’s a perfect balance of tang, heat, butteriness, and bold flavor. But not all store-bought versions hit the target. Some taste like vinegar water, others are oddly sweet, and a few are just straight-up bland. Here’s a roundup of 8 buffalo sauces you might want to skip, and 9 store-bought bottles that totally deliver the fiery flavor you crave.

1. Frank’s RedHot Buffalo Wings Sauce (Pre-Mixed Version)

Frank’s RedHot Buffalo Wings Sauce in its pre-mixed form falls short of expectations. Unlike the classic Frank’s, this version is diluted, lacking the bold kick that fans of spicy flavors crave. Many find it weak and watery, with a texture that doesn’t cling well to wings or other dishes.

Despite its iconic brand status, this product doesn’t deliver on the promise of authentic buffalo taste. The absence of the rich combination of hot sauce and butter leaves it tasting flat and uninspired. For those looking for that classic Frank’s punch, this pre-mixed option is not the ideal choice.

2. Sweet Baby Ray’s Buffalo Wing Sauce

Sweet Baby Ray’s Buffalo Wing Sauce might surprise fans expecting traditional buffalo heat. Known for its unexpected sweetness, this sauce leans more towards barbecue than buffalo. The sugary profile overshadows any hint of spice, leaving a peculiar aftertaste many find puzzling.

For those accustomed to Sweet Baby Ray’s barbecue offerings, this might feel like an awkward transition into buffalo territory. The sauce’s texture is appealing, yet its flavor profile departs significantly from what buffalo sauce enthusiasts typically seek. If you’re craving authentic buffalo heat, this one might not hit the mark as desired.

3. Kroger Brand Buffalo Wing Sauce

Kroger Brand Buffalo Wing Sauce offers an experience that many find lacking. Its thin consistency and overwhelming vinegar taste make it less than ideal for wing enthusiasts. The sauce doesn’t adhere well, leaving a watery trail rather than the desired zesty coating.

Though budget-friendly, the sauce fails to impress with its generic flavor profile. Those seeking the full-bodied, spicy depth of a genuine buffalo sauce might find this option disappointing. It’s a clear example of getting what you pay for, leaving many wishing for more heat and richness in their wing sauce experience.

4. Texas Pete Buffalo Wing Sauce

Texas Pete Buffalo Wing Sauce is an entry that doesn’t live up to its fiery name. With far too mild a heat level, it leaves spice lovers yearning for more. The sauce presents a simple, singular note without the complexity or depth that defines a great buffalo sauce.

It’s often described as more of a “spicy orange” sauce rather than a genuine buffalo experience. While it may suit those with a low tolerance for heat, it won’t satisfy those craving the bold tang and burn associated with true buffalo sauces. A surprising miss from an otherwise reputable brand.

5. Primal Kitchen Buffalo Sauce

Primal Kitchen Buffalo Sauce takes a health-conscious approach but misses the mark on flavor. Marketed as clean and paleo-friendly, its taste leans heavily towards coconut oil and vinegar, overshadowing the traditional buffalo elements. This results in a flavor that feels out of place for buffalo purists.

While it might appeal to those on specific diets, the sauce doesn’t capture the buttery, tangy notes expected. It lacks the robust heat and creamy texture typical of a satisfying buffalo sauce. Ultimately, it leaves those seeking authentic taste longing for a more traditional route.

6. Wing-Time Medium Buffalo Wing Sauce

Wing-Time Medium Buffalo Wing Sauce enters the scene with decent ingredients yet fails to make a lasting impression. Its blandness in flavor and slightly oily texture don’t stand out in the crowded buffalo sauce market.

Although it promises a medium heat, the result is more subdued than anticipated, lacking the exciting punch that wing lovers often desire. The sauce struggles to elevate wings or dishes with its uninspired profile. While it may appeal to those preferring a gentler experience, many will find it lacks the boldness typical of top-tier buffalo sauces.

7. Market Pantry (Target) Buffalo Sauce

Market Pantry Buffalo Sauce, exclusive to Target, leaves much to be desired. Its artificial taste and chemically sharp notes overshadow any redeeming qualities it might possess. The cost savings don’t compensate for the lack of genuine buffalo flavor.

For those seeking the balanced heat and tang buffalo sauce is known for, this variant disappoints with its harsh, synthetic undertone. While the packaging might attract budget-conscious shoppers, the sauce itself doesn’t deliver on the promise of a satisfying wing-enhancing experience. Better options are available, even within the same price range.

8. Ken’s Buffalo Wing Sauce

Ken’s Buffalo Wing Sauce is another entry that falls short of expectations. Dominated by vinegar, it lacks the heat and thickness characteristic of a quality buffalo sauce. The watery consistency doesn’t provide the robust coating that wings deserve.

Despite its popularity in salad dressings, Ken’s struggles to translate the success into the buffalo sauce domain. The sauce’s thinness and overpowering vinegar presence leave a lot to be desired. Those seeking a rich, spicy experience may find themselves reaching for other brands to satisfy their buffalo cravings adequately.

9. Frank’s RedHot Original (Add Your Own Butter)

Frank’s RedHot Original remains a classic choice for buffalo sauce enthusiasts. When combined with melted butter, it transforms into the gold standard for authentic buffalo flavor. The sauce’s tangy, spicy profile, paired with the richness of butter, creates a perfectly balanced taste.

Unlike pre-mixed versions, this combination allows for customization, ensuring the heat and texture meet personal preferences. It’s a straightforward, reliable choice that stands up to traditional methods. Fans of buffalo wings often return to this combo for its consistency and ability to deliver every time, keeping the flavor legacy alive.

10. Noble Made by The New Primal Medium Buffalo Sauce

Noble Made by The New Primal Medium Buffalo Sauce offers a clean and flavorful experience without sacrificing taste. Whole30-approved, it combines healthy ingredients with a good level of heat to satisfy cravings. This buffalo sauce is versatile, complementing everything from wings to cauliflower.

Unlike many health-focused alternatives, it maintains the boldness expected of buffalo sauces. The sauce’s rich texture and pleasant zing make it a standout choice for those who prioritize quality ingredients. It’s an excellent option for those seeking a mindful yet delicious addition to their culinary adventures.

11. Melinda’s Creamy Style Wing Sauce

Melinda’s Creamy Style Wing Sauce introduces a unique spin on traditional buffalo flavor. Blended with habanero and cayenne, it offers a richer, creamier take that doesn’t skimp on spice. The sauce’s smooth texture complements its fiery kick, providing a delightful contrast.

This creative twist appeals to those looking for more than just standard heat. Melinda’s manages to pack intense flavor into a creamy format without losing the essence of what buffalo sauce lovers adore. It’s a flavorful choice that stands out on the shelf for its innovative approach and satisfying punch.

12. Tessemae’s Mild Buffalo

Tessemae’s Mild Buffalo brings boldness in a mild format, crafted organically and sugar-free. This sauce is perfect for those who enjoy buffalo flavors without an overpowering heat. Its balance makes it suitable for marinating or as a dipping sauce.

The clean ingredient profile ensures a natural taste that respects dietary preferences while retaining the beloved tangy notes of buffalo sauce. Tessemae’s provides a refreshing option for those looking to enjoy familiar flavors with a mild twist, keeping health and taste in harmony for a satisfying culinary experience.

13. Moore’s Original Buffalo Wing Sauce

Moore’s Original Buffalo Wing Sauce is beloved for its buttery, spicy, and thick consistency. Ideal for coating wings, it clings perfectly, delivering a burst of flavor in every bite. This fan favorite stands out for its ability to enhance dishes without slipping off.

The sauce’s rich profile is a testament to its popularity, balancing heat and buttery goodness seamlessly. Whether used for wings or other culinary creations, Moore’s provides a reliable option for those seeking an elevated buffalo experience. It continues to garner praise for its dependable quality and flavorful impact.

14. Buffalo Wild Wings Medium Sauce (Bottled)

Buffalo Wild Wings Medium Sauce, now available in bottled form, captures the essence of the restaurant’s beloved flavor. Known for its savory, rich profile, it delivers just the right amount of heat to satisfy buffalo sauce enthusiasts.

This bottled delight allows fans to enjoy the restaurant’s signature taste in the comfort of their homes. Its balanced zing and smooth consistency make it a versatile option for various dishes. Lovers of the original will appreciate the authenticity and convenience offered by this bottled version, making it a staple in many kitchens.

15. Noble Made Hot Buffalo Sauce

Noble Made Hot Buffalo Sauce elevates the standard with its intense heat while maintaining the classic buffalo flavor profile. This sauce appeals to those who desire a fiery kick without sacrificing the familiar tang.

It’s a bold choice for those ready to turn up the heat on their favorite dishes. The robust combination of spice and flavor ensures a memorable experience that stands out from milder options. Fans of hot and zesty will find this sauce delivers on its promise, pushing the limits of traditional buffalo while honoring its roots.

16. Crystal Wing Sauce

Crystal Wing Sauce from the makers of Crystal hot sauce brings a bold vinegary kick to the table. Known for its heat, it satisfies those who appreciate a strong, sharp flavor profile.

This sauce stands out for its ability to balance vinegar-forward notes with satisfying spice, offering a distinctive twist on traditional buffalo sauces. The boldness and depth make it a favorite among those who enjoy a tangy, lively sauce that packs a punch. Crystal’s reputation for flavorful heat shines through in this wing sauce offering.

17. Yellowbird Bliss & Vinegar Buffalo Sauce

Yellowbird Bliss & Vinegar Buffalo Sauce offers a unique take on traditional buffalo with its habanero fire and umami punch. This sauce isn’t your typical buffalo offering—it’s wild, tangy, and undeniably memorable.

The blend of habanero heat with a vinegar base creates an experience that stands apart from conventional sauces. It’s for those who appreciate an adventurous twist on their favorite condiment, providing a burst of flavor that surprises and delights. Yellowbird’s creativity shines, making this sauce a noteworthy choice for those seeking bold and exciting tastes.