7 Pancake Syrups That Taste Like Corn Syrup And 9 That Actually Taste Like Maple

Pancake syrups can make or break your breakfast experience. While some syrups offer an authentic maple taste, others are loaded with corn syrup that may leave you longing for genuine maple goodness. In this blog, we explore 7 pancake syrups that mimic corn syrup and 9 that provide a true maple flavor. Whether you’re a budget-conscious shopper or a maple syrup connoisseur, this list aims to guide your next syrup shopping decision.

1. Aunt Jemima Original (now Pearl Milling Company)

Aunt Jemima, now known as Pearl Milling Company, is a household name in breakfast syrups. The iconic bottle brings nostalgia, but the syrup inside is a medley of sugar and caramel coloring. Despite its widespread availability and classic branding, its flavor profile misses the mark for maple enthusiasts. Thick and syrupy, its taste leans heavily on sweetness with an artificial undertone. A staple in many pantries, but for those seeking genuine maple flavor, it’s a disappointment. The syrup caters to those who enjoy a sugar-forward taste rather than the nuanced depth of real maple.

2. Log Cabin Original

Log Cabin Original syrup is a staple in many households, known for its intensely sweet flavor and thick consistency. It serves as a nostalgic sugar bomb that doesn’t shy away from its artificial roots. The syrup’s taste is dominated by high-fructose corn syrup, giving it a one-dimensional sweetness. Its thick texture makes it cling to pancakes, ensuring a sugary bite every time. Despite its popularity, true maple aficionados may find it lacking. It’s perfect for those who prefer a straightforward sugar rush over the complex flavors of authentic maple syrup.

3. Great Value Original Syrup (Walmart)

Walmart’s Great Value Original Syrup offers budget-conscious shoppers an inexpensive alternative. However, its taste resembles liquified candy more than maple. The bright, sweet flavor is unmistakably artificial, and its consistency is thick and sticky. Ideal for those who prioritize cost over taste, it nonetheless falls short for maple purists. This syrup might serve well in a pinch, but it’s more about sugary satisfaction than authentic flavor. The absence of any real maple notes makes it a poor substitute for those seeking genuine pancake syrup experiences.

4. Hungry Jack Original Syrup

Hungry Jack Original Syrup is often chosen for its availability and price. Made predominantly from high-fructose corn syrup, it offers a thick, glossy appearance. While it may appeal to those with a sweet tooth, its flavor is one-note, lacking the complexity of real maple. The syrup’s viscous nature ensures it envelops pancakes completely, yet the overall taste experience is flat. For consumers accustomed to sugary breakfast options, it hits the mark. Conversely, maple syrup purists may be disappointed by its lack of depth and authentic flavor.

5. Mrs. Butterworth’s Original

Mrs. Butterworth’s Original syrup is synonymous with nostalgia for many. Its characteristic syrup bottle and sweet aroma make it a breakfast favorite. However, its composition is largely corn syrup, with only a hint of maple-like aroma. The texture is smooth and thick, ensuring every pancake bite is drenched in sweetness. While it may satisfy those craving sugary flavors, it leaves true maple lovers wanting more. Mrs. Butterworth’s offers an experience rooted in childhood breakfasts, but its syrup lacks the authentic maple depth.

6. Market Pantry Original Syrup (Target)

Target’s Market Pantry Original Syrup is known for its affordability. With a flavor profile that echoes artificial sweetness, it caters to those looking for an economical option. The syrup is thick, and its aftertaste is reminiscent of fake sugar. While it’s a practical choice for budget shoppers, the lack of real maple taste is noticeable. The syrup is best suited for those who prioritize cost over authenticity, offering a sweet but limited flavor experience. For pancake lovers seeking genuine maple flavors, it may not suffice.

7. Clover Valley Syrup (Dollar General)

Clover Valley Syrup from Dollar General is a cost-effective choice for breakfast enthusiasts. Its texture is notably thick, almost gelatinous, with a super sweet taste. The focus is on providing a sugary punch rather than a maple experience. While it may work for those who enjoy a straightforward, sweet syrup, it’s not for maple purists. The syrup’s simple sweetness lacks the complexity and richness of real maple. It’s an option for budget-conscious consumers but falls short of replicating a true maple syrup taste.

8. Trader Joe’s 100% Pure Maple Syrup

Trader Joe’s 100% Pure Maple Syrup is beloved for its rich, deep flavor. Unlike corn syrup alternatives, this syrup is not overly sweet, providing an authentic maple experience. The smooth texture and full-bodied taste make it a favorite among pancake lovers. Known for its quality and reasonable price, it’s sourced from real maple trees, offering a natural sweetness and complexity. This syrup is an excellent choice for those wanting a true taste of maple. Its authentic flavor is a delight for anyone serious about their pancake syrup.

9. Kirkland Signature Organic Maple Syrup (Costco)

Costco’s Kirkland Signature Organic Maple Syrup offers a genuine maple flavor at a great value. This syrup is bold and smooth, capturing the essence of maple with each pour. Unlike its corn syrup counterparts, it tastes as if it came directly from a tree. The organic nature assures quality and purity, making it a staple for those who appreciate authentic flavors. Perfect for topping pancakes, it provides a luxurious syrup experience without the artificial additives. This syrup satisfies maple enthusiasts seeking an uncomplicated yet rich flavor profile.

10. Coombs Family Farms Pure Maple Syrup

Coombs Family Farms Pure Maple Syrup stands out with its trusted brand reputation and full maple flavor. Offering an earthy-sweet balance, it’s crafted to perfection from real maple trees. The syrup’s rich taste and smooth consistency make it ideal for any breakfast table. Known for its quality, it ensures a delightful maple experience without any artificial interference. This syrup speaks to those who appreciate tradition and authenticity, providing a genuine taste of maple. It’s perfect for syrup connoisseurs looking for that perfect pancake pairing.

11. Butternut Mountain Farm Maple Syrup

Butternut Mountain Farm Maple Syrup, crafted in Vermont, is known for its high quality. The Grade A amber variety is particularly smooth and embodies classic maple flavor. With a rich, full-bodied taste, it captures the essence of Vermont’s famed maple industry. This syrup is a celebration of tradition and quality, providing a luxurious experience with every drop. Ideal for those who appreciate a true maple taste, it doesn’t rely on artificial enhancements. Butternut Mountain Farm offers a premium syrup option for pancake lovers.

12. Crown Maple Syrup

Crown Maple Syrup offers a refined option for syrup enthusiasts, known for its clean and robust flavor profile. This syrup is on the pricier side, reflecting its high-end quality. It offers a smooth and not overly sticky texture, making it a sophisticated addition to any breakfast. For those who enjoy a more elegant syrup experience, Crown Maple delivers. It captures the essence of maple without the excessive sweetness of corn syrup alternatives, providing a true gourmet experience. Ideal for those who savor a distinctive syrup taste.

13. Anderson’s Pure Maple Syrup

Anderson’s Pure Maple Syrup, an old-school Midwestern brand, is celebrated for its strong maple presence. Free from artificial ingredients, it provides a genuine syrup experience that pancake lovers cherish. The syrup’s robust flavor and smooth texture make it a standout choice for breakfast. Anderson’s dedication to quality and tradition is evident in every bottle, capturing the authentic sweetness of maple. This syrup speaks to purists seeking a straightforward, unadulterated maple taste. It’s a reliable option for those who prefer natural flavors over sugary imitations.

14. Maple Grove Farms Pure Maple Syrup

Maple Grove Farms Pure Maple Syrup, widely available in grocery stores, offers a no-nonsense maple experience. Free from corn syrup fillers, it provides a straightforward maple taste. This syrup is ideal for those who seek authenticity without the frills. The pure and simple flavor makes it a reliable choice for topping pancakes. Known for its consistent quality, Maple Grove Farms stands as a testament to genuine syrup craftsmanship. Ideal for everyday use, it satisfies those who prioritize real ingredients and maple flavor over artificial additives.

15. Runamok Maple Syrup (Flavored Varieties Too)

Runamok Maple Syrup, based in Vermont, is known for its traditional and infused options like bourbon-barrel aged varieties. This high-end syrup is full-flavored, offering unique and adventurous tastes for those willing to explore beyond the classic maple flavor. The infusion process adds a layer of complexity, enhancing the syrup’s appeal. Perfect for those who enjoy experimenting with flavors, Runamok stands out as a premium choice. It’s a delight for the adventurous palate, providing not just a syrup but an experience. Ideal for those who love variety.

16. Hidden Springs Maple Syrup

Hidden Springs Maple Syrup offers a smooth and pure maple experience, perfect for breakfast or even in coffee. This small-batch syrup enjoys a loyal following due to its authentic flavor and dedication to quality. Its rich and natural taste makes it a favorite among maple enthusiasts, capturing the true essence of maple trees. Ideal for those who value artisanal quality, Hidden Springs delivers a syrup that’s crafted with care. It’s a wonderful choice for anyone seeking an authentic and flavorful syrup experience.