7 Air Fryer Recipes That Didn’t Impress—And 8 Foolproof Favorites You’ll Make Again and Again

Here’s a breakdown of 7 air fryer recipes that often fall flat—either in taste, texture, or practicality—followed by 8 foolproof air fryer favorites that deliver consistently crispy, delicious results every time.

1. Air Fryer Hard-Boiled Eggs

Imagine expecting perfectly smooth hard-boiled eggs, only to find them chalky and difficult to peel. This is the common outcome when using an air fryer for this task. Many believe the traditional methods of boiling or steaming are superior. Peeling these air-fried eggs can often be a challenge, as the shell stubbornly clings to the white. While it’s possible, air frying doesn’t offer the smooth texture we desire. The trade-off between convenience and quality is apparent here, making this method less appealing to egg lovers.

2. Air Fryer Baked Potatoes

Baked potatoes are a staple, but when done in an air fryer, they often lack the desired fluffy interior. While they crisp up on the outside, the cooking time is nearly as long as using a traditional oven. The space they require also monopolizes the air fryer basket, making it less efficient. For those who love a perfect baked potato, this method can be disappointing. The potato just doesn’t reach the same level of fluffiness and flavor that an oven can achieve.

3. Air Fryer Grilled Cheese

Grilled cheese is supposed to be simple, yet delicious. In an air fryer, the bread crisps beautifully, but what about the cheese? Often, it melts unevenly or leaks out, creating a mess rather than a meal. The stovetop griddle remains a better choice for those seeking the perfect grilled cheese experience. While the air fryer can give you crispy bread, it’s the consistent cheese melt that makes this classic dish satisfying. Unfortunately, the air fryer falls short in delivering that harmonious blend.

4. Air Fryer Bacon

Bacon lovers beware! While it’s feasible to cook bacon in an air fryer, the experience may not be as pleasant as expected. The grease can cause smoke, and cleanup becomes more complicated compared to using a pan or oven. Though the bacon crisps nicely, the accompanying smoke and mess make this method less desirable. If you’re in search of ease and efficiency, the traditional methods of cooking bacon might still be your best bet. The air fryer’s complexity with this task is simply not worth it.

5. Air Fryer Avocado Fries

Avocado fries promise a unique twist on a classic, but the air fryer doesn’t deliver the desired crispness. Instead, they often turn out mushy inside, losing the textural contrast that makes fries appealing. While a great idea in theory, the execution lacks satisfaction. Other air-fried veggies excel where avocado fails, leaving these fries behind in the quest for crisp perfection. The air fryer simply doesn’t do justice to this otherwise intriguing dish, making it one of those recipes you might try once, but not again.

6. Air Fryer French Toast Sticks

French toast is a delightfully indulgent breakfast treat, yet the air fryer struggles to maintain its charm. Air fryer french toast sticks often end up dry or overcooked in the center, missing the custardy texture that defines classic French toast. The promise of an easy breakfast doesn’t match the reality, as the texture disappoints. Those seeking a soft, rich center might find traditional methods far more satisfying, as the air fryer fails to deliver the cherished balance of flavors and textures.

7. Air Fryer Donuts from Biscuit Dough

Convenience meets craving with air fryer donuts made from biscuit dough. However, the result is often closer to dense biscuits than airy, yeasty donuts, leaving expectations unmet. While they’re easy to make, the trade-off in texture and flavor can be significant. For those dreaming of light, fluffy donuts, this recipe is a letdown. The air fryer’s take on donuts doesn’t quite satisfy the sweet tooth the way traditional methods do, making it a tempting yet ultimately underwhelming endeavor.

8. Air Fryer Chicken Wings

Who doesn’t love a crispy chicken wing? The air fryer excels in delivering perfectly crispy wings without the need for deep frying. Whether tossed in buffalo, garlic-parmesan, or lemon pepper, they’re guaranteed crowd-pleasers. The convenience and reduced grease make this a favorite for wing enthusiasts. It’s a go-to recipe that doesn’t compromise on taste or texture. For game days or casual dinners, air fryer chicken wings are a delightful surprise that you’ll return to time and again.

9. Air Fryer Brussels Sprouts

Brussels sprouts, once feared by children, are reborn in the air fryer. Crispy on the outside and tender inside, they’re customizable with balsamic glaze, garlic, or chili crunch. This dish turns skeptics into fans, offering a modern twist on a classic vegetable. The air fryer’s ability to cook them evenly and deliciously makes them an unexpected favorite. Whether as a side dish or a snack, air fryer Brussels sprouts are a revelation, transforming a humble veggie into a crispy, flavorful delight.

10. Air Fryer Salmon

Salmon lovers rejoice! The air fryer delivers moist and flaky salmon with a crispy edge, all in under 10 minutes. This method requires minimal cleanup, making it both quick and convenient. The flavor remains intact, and the texture rivals more traditional methods. For those seeking a healthy, delicious meal, air fryer salmon is an easy win. The simplicity and perfection of this dish make it a staple for weeknight dinners or impressive yet effortless entertaining.

11. Air Fryer Sweet Potato Fries

Sweet potato fries are a beloved alternative to regular fries, and the air fryer makes them even better. Crisping beautifully with just a touch of oil, they’re a healthy yet indulgent treat. Serve them with spicy mayo or honey mustard for a delightful twist. The air fryer’s ability to cook them to perfection without the greasiness of deep frying is a major win. For sweet potato lovers, this recipe is a must-try, offering both flavor and satisfaction in every bite.

12. Air Fryer Breaded Chicken Tenders

Chicken tenders are a classic favorite, and the air fryer transforms them into something even more special. Golden and crunchy on the outside, yet juicy inside, they’re perfect for both adults and kids. The minimal oil required makes them a healthier option, without compromising on taste. Whether for a quick meal or a party snack, air fryer breaded chicken tenders are a hit. Their appeal crosses age barriers, making them a staple in many households.

13. Air Fryer Cauliflower Bites

Cauliflower bites take on a new life in the air fryer, becoming a vegetarian favorite. Tossed in spices or buffalo sauce, they’re both flavorful and crispy, offering a satisfying crunch. For those seeking a meatless option that doesn’t sacrifice taste, this dish delivers. The air fryer’s ability to cook them perfectly makes them a go-to for vegetarians and meat-eaters alike. Whether as an appetizer or a side, air fryer cauliflower bites are a delightful addition to any meal.

14. Air Fryer Stuffed Peppers

Stuffed peppers are a comforting dish, and the air fryer makes them quicker and easier. Evenly cooked and full of flavor, they’re perfect for meal-prepped dinners or leftovers. The air fryer reduces the cooking time significantly, without losing taste or texture. For those looking for a convenient, delicious meal, air fryer stuffed peppers are a great choice. The vibrant appearance and rich filling make them a visually appealing and satisfying dish.

15. Air Fryer Egg Rolls

Egg rolls, whether homemade or frozen, reach new heights of crispiness in the air fryer. Without the grease, they come out perfectly, making them an ideal choice for those who crave crunch. Paired with sweet chili sauce or soy dip, they’re a tantalizing treat that’s hard to resist. The air fryer elevates this classic appetizer, turning it into a must-have for any gathering. The ease and consistency make air fryer egg rolls a favorite for both casual snacks and elegant appetizers.