6 Sandwich Chains Skimping on Cheese Quality And 9 That Use the Good Stuff Every Time

When it comes to sandwich chains, not all cheese is created equal. Some places cut corners with their cheese offerings, providing a lackluster experience, while others go above and beyond, serving up cheeses that elevate every bite. Whether you’re a cheese connoisseur or someone who just appreciates a good melt, knowing where to find quality cheese on your sandwich can make all the difference.

1. Subway

Subway offers basic cheese options like American, provolone, and a shredded blend. These cheeses rarely get melted unless specifically requested by the customer, making them less appealing. The overall quality of the cheese can be described as functional but far from gourmet, often leaving cheese enthusiasts unsatisfied. While the bread and fillings may have their merits, the cheese at Subway feels more like an afterthought. It lacks the richness and depth that one might hope for in a satisfying sandwich experience.

2. Arby’s

Arby’s is known for its Beef ’n Cheddar sandwich, which features a “cheddar sauce” that’s more reminiscent of neon goo than actual cheese. The sauce’s processed nature gives it a radioactive appearance, raising questions about its authenticity. While it adds a splash of color, it doesn’t contribute much in terms of flavor. True cheese aficionados might find themselves disappointed by the lack of real cheesy goodness. For many, the sauce feels more like a novelty than a genuine cheese experience.

3. Jimmy John’s

Jimmy John’s prides itself on fresh ingredients, but its cheese offerings can leave a bit to be desired. The provolone cheese, while present, tends to be bland and lacks any notable melt. It often arrives as cold slices without much flavor impact. Despite the fresh bread and quality fillings, the cheese doesn’t quite match the standard, leaving an otherwise promising sandwich feeling incomplete. Cheese lovers might find themselves yearning for a bit more character in each bite.

4. Firehouse Subs

Firehouse Subs is famous for its hearty sandwiches, packed with meats and sauces. However, the cheese often feels like a background player. While it’s there, it rarely shines, overshadowed by the robust flavors of other ingredients. Despite the generous portions of meat and flavorful sauces, the cheese fails to make a significant impression. Cheese enthusiasts may find themselves wishing for a more pronounced cheese presence to complement the robust subs.

5. Quiznos

Quiznos, once a pioneer in toasted subs, now seems to have diminished in cheese quality. The cheddar blend and mozzarella used to be premium, but they currently fall short of expectations. Although the cheese does melt, it lacks the flavorful impact it once had. The overall experience is a reminder of what used to be a superior cheese offering. For those who remember Quiznos at its peak, the current cheese quality might feel like a step down.

6. Potbelly

Potbelly offers Swiss and provolone cheese, which are decent on their own, but in some sandwich combinations, the cheese feels more like filler. They tend to be light-handed with the cheese unless you opt to pay for double portions. While the ingredients are generally quality, the cheese can sometimes get lost among the other fillings. Customers seeking a prominent cheese experience might need to request extra to achieve the desired flavor balance.

7. Jersey Mike’s

Jersey Mike’s sets itself apart by slicing cheese fresh to order, resulting in a flavorful and satisfying addition to their sandwiches. The provolone and white American cheeses are robust and elevate the sandwich, offering a taste upgrade compared to many chains. Each bite delivers a rich cheese flavor that complements the other ingredients perfectly. This attention to cheese quality makes Jersey Mike’s a go-to option for those seeking a truly enhanced sandwich experience.

8. Ike’s Love & Sandwiches

Ike’s Love & Sandwiches is celebrated for its bold and creative sandwich builds, with a cheese offering that doesn’t disappoint. Whether it’s Swiss, pepper jack, or mozzarella, the cheese is always melty and flavorful. The generous cheese portions play a significant role in each sandwich, ensuring every bite is a delightful experience. This commitment to quality cheese makes Ike’s a favorite for those who appreciate a rich and melty cheese presence.

9. Mendocino Farms

Mendocino Farms brings an upscale touch to its cheese offerings, featuring gourmet options like goat cheese, brie, and smoked cheddar. These cheeses are always creamy and flavorful, complementing the sophisticated sandwich builds. The intentional selection and application of cheese elevate the dining experience, making it a treat for cheese lovers. This dedication to high-quality ingredients ensures that every sandwich is a masterpiece in flavor and texture.

10. Lenny’s Grill & Subs

Lenny’s Grill & Subs is a regional gem known for its authentic use of real provolone and cheddar cheeses. These are melted to perfection, enhancing the sandwich experience significantly. The commitment to quality cheese ensures that each bite is rich and satisfying, setting Lenny’s apart from many other chains. Customers can expect a consistent and delicious cheese presence that complements the fresh ingredients.

11. Publix Deli Subs

Publix Deli Subs might be part of a grocery store, but their cheese quality is anything but ordinary. Offering a variety of high-quality cheese slices, customers can choose exactly what they want, like sharp cheddar. The generous portions and rich flavor make the cheese a standout component of the sandwich, enhancing every bite. Publix’s dedication to providing premium cheese options makes it a favorite for those who prioritize cheese quality in their sandwiches.

12. Which Wich

Which Wich surprises with its solid cheese selections, offering provolone, pepper jack, Swiss, and even bleu cheese. The fact that they actually melt the cheese adds to the overall enjoyment. Each cheese variety brings its own distinct flavor, contributing to a well-rounded sandwich experience. For those who appreciate a melty and flavorful cheese, Which Wich delivers both variety and quality, making it a strong contender in the sandwich chain landscape.

13. Capriotti’s

Capriotti’s sandwiches are known for being hearty and satisfying, in part due to their rich and smooth cheese options like provolone, cheddar, and American. These cheeses are never rubbery but always add a creamy texture and deep flavor to the sandwich. The careful selection and application of cheese contribute significantly to the overall quality, ensuring each bite is a delight for cheese lovers.

14. Schlotzsky’s

Schlotzsky’s takes pride in its cheese, which is melty, creamy, and layered with purpose. While not too fancy, the cheese works hard behind the scenes to enhance the sandwich’s flavor profile. It effectively pulls together the various elements of the sandwich, ensuring a balanced and cohesive bite every time. Cheese enthusiasts will appreciate the thoughtfulness with which Schlotzsky’s incorporates cheese into its offerings.

15. Eegee’s

Eegee’s, though a regional chain, brings a delightful cheese experience to its sandwiches. The flavorful cheeses complement the bread and meat perfectly, avoiding blandness entirely. Each cheese variety is selected to enhance the sandwich’s overall profile, ensuring a memorable dining experience. For those in Arizona, Eegee’s stands out as a place where cheese quality is given the attention it deserves, making every sandwich a satisfying choice.