6 Reubens That Fall Apart in Flavor And 9 Chain Sandwiches That Absolutely Nail It

Exploring the vast landscape of chain sandwiches, this blog post aims to distinguish between those that fail to deliver on flavor and those that set the standard. From classic Reubens that miss the mark to chain sandwiches that exceed expectations, we dive into the details that make or break a sandwich experience. Discover the ones worth trying and those best left untouched.

1. Arby’s Reuben

Arby’s Reuben gives off the right appearance but disappoints in taste. The combination of watery kraut and overly salty meat on soggy rye makes for a sandwich that’s more miss than hit. Despite its promising look, biting into it reveals its shortcomings. The rye bread fails to complement the Reuben’s traditional flavors, leaving it lacking in the depth and complexity that’s expected.

For those seeking comfort in the classic Reuben, this version leaves much to be desired, making it an unfortunate letdown in what should be a flavorful experience.

2. Denny’s Reuben

At Denny’s, the Reuben arrives limp and lifeless, with bread that’s barely toasted. The dressing seems like an afterthought, failing to bring the essential balance. This diner-style sandwich misses the mark, the limp texture a far cry from the crispiness one might hope for.

Each bite lacks vigor, and the flavors meld into a forgettable medley. While Denny’s finds its strength in classic diner fare, the Reuben isn’t one of them. A sandwich that should be vibrant instead falls flat.

3. Panera Bread Toasted Reuben

Panera Bread’s take on the Reuben seems more like a sad grilled cheese than a hearty sandwich staple. Thin slices of meat and bland kraut fail to impress, lacking the robust flavors needed to cut through the heaviness. It’s a missed opportunity for a sandwich that could otherwise shine.

The lack of taste and texture leaves diners wanting more. Despite the effort to toast, the Reuben at Panera doesn’t capture the essence of what makes this sandwich a favorite for many.

4. Schlotzsky’s Reuben

Schlotzsky’s Reuben has great potential, but the execution often falls short. Overloaded with dressing, it tends to fall apart before the second bite, leaving a mess rather than a meal. The imbalance in meat-to-bread ratio is evident, disrupting the harmony.

The ambition to deliver a hefty Reuben is clear, but precision in assembly is lacking. What begins as a promising sandwich experience quickly unravels, challenging diners to manage the excess rather than enjoy the flavor.

5. Firehouse Subs’ Limited-Time Reuben

Firehouse Subs’ Limited-Time Reuben is a soggy challenge, with flavors that become muddled rather than distinct. The kraut is too wet, and the bread struggles to hold up, turning a sandwich into a fork-and-knife affair. It’s more effort than enjoyment.

While the intention to deliver a hearty Reuben is evident, the execution falters. The sandwich’s promise is drowned in its own excess, leaving a dish better suited for utensils than hands. What could be a delightful bite feels more like a chore.

6. Jason’s Deli Traditional Reuben

Jason’s Deli Traditional Reuben is a tale of inconsistency. Sometimes dry, other times drenched, it struggles to hit that perfect balance that defines a great Reuben. This unpredictability makes it hard to rely on for a satisfying meal.

While not terrible, its frequent fluctuations in quality can be frustrating. For those who crave the perfect Reuben experience, this offering may leave you guessing each time. The potential is there, but the execution wavers, holding it back from greatness.

7. Jersey Mike’s #13 The Original Italian

Jersey Mike’s #13 The Original Italian is a sandwich that gets it right every time. Packed with prime meats, fresh cheese, crisp veggies, and the signature “Mike’s Way” oil-vinegar combo, it delivers a bold and satisfying experience.

Each bite is a harmonious blend of flavors, capturing the essence of what makes a great Italian sub. The crispness and freshness are consistent, making it a reliable choice for those seeking quality and taste. It’s a sandwich that nails every detail.

8. Potbelly’s “A Wreck”

Potbelly’s “A Wreck” is a delightful chaos of flavors. With ham, roast beef, turkey, salami, and Swiss cheese, this sandwich is toasted to perfection, offering a layered taste sensation. It’s messy, hearty, and downright delicious.

Every ingredient stands out, yet blends seamlessly into a unified taste. The texture is just right, with each bite offering satisfaction. Potbelly’s ability to combine such a variety of flavors without losing harmony is what makes “A Wreck” an absolute hit.

9. Jimmy John’s Vito

Jimmy John’s Vito is a classic done right. Simple yet solid, it features Italian meats, provolone, and crunchy veggies wrapped in a fresh baguette. This sandwich is a go-to for its balanced flavors and fresh ingredients.

Every bite offers a satisfying crunch, with flavors that complement rather than overpower. The simplicity of its construction is its strength, making it a reliable choice for those who appreciate a straightforward, delicious sandwich experience.

10. Ike’s Love & Sandwiches “Matt Cain”

Ike’s Love & Sandwiches “Matt Cain” is a marvel in sandwich artistry. Featuring turkey, roast beef, salami, Godfather sauce, and provolone, all encased in soft Dutch crunch bread, it’s a memorable feast. The unique combination of flavors and textures make this one unforgettable.

The Godfather sauce adds a bold twist, elevating the sandwich to something extraordinary. Ike’s ability to create such a distinctive and flavorful experience sets it apart as a must-try. It’s a treat for those who seek personality in their food.

11. Mendocino Farms “The Farm Club”

Mendocino Farms’ “The Farm Club” is upscale deli flavor done right. With turkey, crispy bacon, herb aioli, and fresh avocado on toasted rustic white bread, it offers a sophisticated sandwich experience.

Each ingredient plays its part perfectly, creating a taste that’s both rich and refreshing. The combination of creamy avocado and crispy bacon is a standout, making it a favorite for those who appreciate refined flavors. Mendocino Farms knows how to elevate the ordinary to the extraordinary.

12. Which Wich “Wicked”

Which Wich’s “Wicked” is all about customization and indulgence. With five meats, three cheeses, and a variety of toppings, it allows diners to tailor their sandwich to perfection. It’s a robust and satisfying meal that rarely disappoints.

The ability to customize ensures that every bite meets personal preference. The flavors are bold, and the portion is generous, making it a favorite for those who love to indulge. Which Wich provides a canvas for creativity and taste in every sandwich.

13. Publix Deli “Chicken Tender Sub”

Publix Deli’s “Chicken Tender Sub” has achieved cult status for its unforgettable combination of crispy tenders, crunchy veggies, and perfectly baked bread. It’s more than a sandwich; it’s a regional favorite that captures hearts.

The tender chicken pairs beautifully with the fresh veggies, while the bread offers the perfect bite. For those in the know, this sub is a must-try, offering a taste that’s both familiar and exciting. Publix has mastered the art of creating a beloved community staple.

14. Lenny’s Grill & Subs “Philly Cheesesteak”

Lenny’s Grill & Subs “Philly Cheesesteak” delivers on what it promises. With steak, melted provolone, and grilled onions and peppers, it’s always hot, fresh, and bursting with flavor. The cheesesteak remains crisp without turning soggy, offering a delightful eating experience.

Each component is perfectly cooked, with flavors that complement each other in harmony. Lenny’s has managed to capture the essence of a classic Philly in every bite, making it a favorite among cheesesteak enthusiasts.

15. Capriotti’s “Bobbie”

Capriotti’s “Bobbie” is Thanksgiving in a sandwich. With turkey, cranberry sauce, stuffing, and mayo, it captures the holiday spirit in every bite. The combination is weirdly balanced yet addictive, offering a taste of nostalgia and comfort.

Every ingredient is thoughtfully placed, making the “Bobbie” a unique and flavorful treat. It stands out as a quirky but beloved option for those who enjoy a touch of holiday cheer in their daily meal. Capriotti’s knows how to blend tradition with innovation.