6 Fast-Food Shakes That Cut Corners And 9 That Are Made with Real, Creamy Ice Cream

A good milkshake should be rich, creamy, and indulgent—something that feels like a true treat. But not all fast-food shakes are created equal. Some are nothing more than overly sweet, whipped-air mixes made with artificial flavoring and “shake base.” Others go the extra mile, using real ice cream and quality ingredients to deliver thick, satisfying sips. Here’s a breakdown of the fast-food shakes that disappoint—and the ones that actually deliver the creamy, dreamy shake experience you’re craving.

1. McDonald’s Shakes

Smooth and sweet, these shakes are crafted from a premixed “shake syrup.” While tasty, they lack the rich depth of real ice cream.

Their flavor profiles rely heavily on artificial enhancements, making them more of a sugary treat than a creamy indulgence.

This approach to milkshake making might cut costs, but it doesn’t deliver the authentic ice cream experience shake enthusiasts crave.

2. Burger King Shakes

Thick and satisfying, yet these shakes are born from a soft-serve base. Coupled with flavored syrups, they fall short of the handcrafted quality.

The result is a drink that emphasizes texture over true flavor richness. While they offer enjoyable sips, the absence of real ice cream is noticeable.

Fans of authentic shakes might find themselves yearning for more substance beneath the sweetness.

3. Sonic Drive-In Shakes (Regular Tier)

Sonic has real ice cream available, yet their basic shakes lean on artificial flavors. These syrups and sweeteners overshadow natural creaminess.

While these shakes offer a tempting variety of flavors, the overreliance on artificial elements diminishes their potential.

For those seeking the richness of real ice cream, this regular tier might not fully satisfy their cravings.

4. Dairy Queen Shakes

Dairy Queen’s soft-serve is beloved, but it doesn’t meet the FDA’s definition of ice cream due to lower milkfat.

These shakes deliver on sweetness and smooth texture but miss the mark on creamy richness. It’s a trade-off between iconic taste and authentic creaminess.

While enjoyable, purists might seek a more genuine ice cream experience elsewhere.

5. Checkers/Rally’s Milkshakes

Checkers offers a fun array of flavors, but the core base is overly sweet. Real dairy richness is sacrificed for sugar-laden enjoyment.

The shakes deliver on novelty with exciting options, yet the lack of true creaminess is apparent.

For those looking for a genuine ice cream shake, this might not fulfill their indulgent desires.

6. Jack in the Box Shakes

Relying on mix over scoops, these shakes focus on sugar and whipped toppings. Flavor depth gives way to sweetness.

While the shakes offer a quick fix for a sweet craving, they might not satisfy those seeking rich, creamy flavors.

Their convenience is a plus, but for true shake connoisseurs, the absence of real ice cream is a letdown.

7. Shake Shack

Dense and rich, Shake Shack’s shakes are made with real frozen custard. This results in a thick and flavorful experience.

These shakes are not just a drink but a dessert in themselves, offering deep satisfaction with each sip.

For those looking to indulge, this shake promises a true treat, making every sip worth the splurge.

8. Culver’s Fresh Frozen Custard Shakes

Culver’s shakes are made with real frozen custard, offering a creamy and indulgent treat. Each blend is tailored to order.

The shakes serve as a delightful dessert in a cup, ensuring a rich, satisfying experience with every sip.

For those who appreciate quality ingredients, these shakes are a standout option for true indulgence.

9. In-N-Out Burger Shakes

In-N-Out offers simple, classic shakes crafted from real ice cream. No mystery mixes here, just genuine creamy delight.

Each shake provides a satisfying texture and flavor, making it a favorite for those seeking authenticity.

The simplicity of ingredients ensures a true taste of what a milkshake should embody, rich and fulfilling.

10. Chick-fil-A Milkshakes

Hand-spun with real ice cream, Chick-fil-A shakes are topped with whipped cream and a cherry.

These shakes are smooth and satisfying, offering a sweet and creamy experience with every sip.

Perfect for those who enjoy a traditional, indulgent milkshake with genuine ingredients and a classic topping.

11. Freddy’s Frozen Custard Shakes

Freddy’s shakes are dense and custardy, offering an array of mix-in options.

The creamy texture allows you to taste the real cream, making it a delightful indulgence.

For those who appreciate variety and richness, Freddy’s shakes are a top choice that truly delivers on flavor.

12. Potbelly Milkshakes

Old-school shakes crafted with hand-dipped ice cream, Potbelly shakes are thick and creamy.

They are an underrated treat that brings nostalgia with each sip, perfect for those seeking genuine taste.

For fans of classic milkshakes, Potbelly delivers an indulgent and satisfying experience worth trying.

13. Smashburger Shakes

Crafted with Häagen-Dazs ice cream, Smashburger shakes stand out immediately.

The premium ice cream provides a creamy, rich base, elevating the milkshake experience.

For those seeking a luxurious shake, Smashburger offers a treat that’s hard to beat, blending quality with flavor.

14. Cook Out Milkshakes

With over 40 flavors, Cook Out shakes are made with real ice cream. Thick and rich, they’re packed with mix-ins.

These shakes require a spoon, making them a substantial treat for shake lovers.

For those who enjoy variety and richness, Cook Out delivers a truly indulgent experience with every flavor option.

15. Steak ’n Shake Classic Shakes

Made with hand-scooped ice cream, Steak ’n Shake mixes to order.

The shakes offer a go-to experience for those who love old-school flavors and texture, ensuring satisfaction.

For those who appreciate classic milkshake craftsmanship, Steak ’n Shake remains a beloved choice.