6 American Candies That Confuse Everyone And 10 Sweet Treats That Deserve the Spotlight
Not all American candies are created equal. Some have quirky textures, unexpected flavors, or retro charm that leaves people—especially non-Americans—scratching their heads. But others have earned their place in the spotlight with bold flavor and lasting appeal. Here are 6 American candies that confuse just about everyone, and 10 that deserve more love (and a spot in your snack stash).
1. Necco Wafers
Necco Wafers are the embodiment of nostalgia wrapped in a candy form. Chalky, dry, and oddly perfumed, these century-old discs have perplexed taste buds for generations. With flavors like licorice and clove, they offer a taste experience unlike any other.
Despite their unique taste, they hold a cherished place in the hearts of many Americans who grew up with them. The vibrant pastel colors and retro packaging add to their vintage charm. However, for those unfamiliar, their flavor profile can be unexpected and, at times, bewildering.
Necco Wafers remain a fascinating relic from candy history.
2. Candy Corn
Candy Corn evokes the spirit of Halloween like no other treat. With its tri-color design resembling kernels of corn, it raises more questions than it answers. Is it wax? Is it sugar? This seasonally iconic candy, with its oddly smooth texture, sparks debates every autumn.
Its sugary sweetness is undeniable, yet its waxy texture leaves many puzzled. For some, it’s a nostalgic reminder of childhood festivities; for others, a confusing confection that defies logic.
Regardless of opinion, Candy Corn remains an enduring symbol of American Halloween, a sweet enigma wrapped in tradition.
3. Circus Peanuts
Circus Peanuts, the marshmallow-like candy that confounds all who encounter it, stand out not just for their neon orange hue but also for their flavor—banana. Despite being shaped like peanuts, their taste and spongy texture surprise many.
Their chewy yet airy consistency is a deception to the eyes and the palate. For some, they’re a nostalgic treat reminiscent of simpler times, but for others, a sugary puzzle that leaves more questions than answers.
These quirky candies, though not universally loved, remain part of America’s candy tapestry.
4. Good & Plenty
Good & Plenty, the iconic pink and white candy-coated licorice, is a treat that divides candy lovers into fans and skeptics. With its vibrant candy shell and unexpected black licorice center, it offers a jarring contrast in both taste and texture.
While some appreciate its old-fashioned charm, for others, the strong licorice flavor is an acquired taste. It’s a candy that has stood the test of time, beloved by licorice aficionados but often a surprising venture for the uninitiated.
Good & Plenty continues to be a staple for those with adventurous palates.
5. Tootsie Rolls
Tootsie Rolls are the chewy logs of mystery that have puzzled candy lovers for generations. They beg the question: chocolate, caramel, or taffy? Their flavor is a blend that’s uniquely their own, wrapped in a familiar, shiny wrapper.
The chewy texture and subtle cocoa flavor provide a consistent yet perplexing experience. Some are drawn to their nostalgic appeal, reminding them of simpler times at the candy store.
Though its true flavor identity remains elusive, the Tootsie Roll is a testament to enduring curiosity and is cherished by many.
6. Wax Lips
Wax Lips are more of a costume prop than a sweet treat, captivating with their whimsical appearance. Technically edible, they offer a chewy wax texture with a hint of sweetness, leaving many confused about their purpose.
For some, they are a playful throwback to childhood antics, while others find them an oddity in the candy world. Their bright red hue and oversized design add to their humor and charm.
Though not a culinary delight, Wax Lips have an undeniable place in the playful side of candy history.
7. Take 5 Bar
Take 5 Bar is the candy equivalent of a flavor symphony, combining pretzels, caramel, peanut butter, peanuts, and chocolate in a single bar. This sweet and salty mashup is a sensory delight.
Its crunchy, chewy, and creamy textures merge to create a treat that’s both satisfying and underrated. Each bite presents a new discovery, making it a favorite for those who appreciate complexity in their confections.
Although it may not boast the same fame as other candy bars, its unique combination makes it deserving of more recognition.
8. 100 Grand Bar
100 Grand Bar is a textural dream wrapped in chocolate, offering chewy caramel and crisped rice in every bite. It’s an experience that tantalizes the senses and delivers satisfaction to those who seek it.
Despite its lack of widespread fame, this candy bar combines a rich chocolate shell with a delightfully chewy and crispy interior, making it a hidden gem among confections.
Its name suggests opulence, and its taste certainly delivers on that promise, offering a delectable surprise for those who give it a try.
9. Reese’s Fast Break
Reese’s Fast Break is like a power-packed version of a classic Reese’s, blending soft nougat and creamy peanut butter under a thick chocolate coating. It’s a bar designed for those who need a quick yet indulgent snack.
The layers create a seamless blend of textures and flavors, offering a smooth, satisfying taste with every bite. Fans of Reese’s products will find this bar a delightful detour from the ordinary.
With its robust combination, it deserves more spotlight, appealing to those who crave a rich, nutty delight on the go.
10. PayDay
PayDay is an unassuming yet bold candy bar, trading chocolate for a salty-sweet blend of peanuts and caramel. Its simplicity is its strength, offering a distinctive taste unlike any other.
For those who prefer a departure from the typical chocolate-covered confection, PayDay stands as a satisfying alternative. The crunchy peanuts paired with gooey caramel provide a delightful contrast.
This candy bar is a go-to for those seeking something different and is cherished by those who appreciate its unique flavor profile.
11. Almond Joy
Almond Joy is a tropical escape wrapped in chocolate, combining moist coconut, crunchy almond, and smooth milk chocolate. It’s a treat that offers a delightful surprise with its unique blend.
Often overshadowed by its sibling, Mounds, the inclusion of an almond adds a crunchy contrast that makes a significant difference. For coconut lovers, it’s a sweet indulgence that transports the senses.
Almond Joy deserves more attention, providing a refreshing twist on the traditional chocolate bar with its exotic flavor and satisfying texture.
12. Charleston Chew
Charleston Chew is a retro candy classic that comes with a suggestion: freeze it for an enhanced experience. Its nougat center encased in chocolate becomes a delightful challenge when frozen, bringing out a cult following.
Its nostalgic appeal lies not just in its flavor but in the playful ritual of cracking it into pieces. This candy offers a fun experience for those who enjoy a bit of interaction with their sweets.
Though its popularity has waned over the years, Charleston Chew remains a cherished nostalgic treat.
13. Whatchamacallit
Whatchamacallit is a candy bar that stands out not just for its quirky name but for its intriguing flavor profile. Featuring a crispy peanut-flavored center, caramel, and chocolate, it’s a harmonious blend of textures.
The name may be whimsical, but the taste is seriously satisfying. It’s a candy bar that invites curiosity and delivers on flavor, making it a delightful choice for those seeking something a bit different.
Though it may not be a household staple, Whatchamacallit commands attention with its unique composition.
14. Heath Bar
Heath Bar is a toffee lover’s dream, pairing buttery toffee with smooth milk chocolate. Its crunchy texture and rich flavor make it a versatile treat, whether enjoyed alone or crumbled over ice cream.
This candy bar has found a loyal fan base among those who appreciate its classic combination. The toffee provides a satisfying crunch that complements the sweetness of the chocolate.
For those who treasure bold flavors, Heath Bar is a delectable option that deserves a prominent place in any candy collection.
15. Bit-O-Honey
Bit-O-Honey is a slow burn of flavor, offering a chewy, nutty experience with a hint of honey. It’s a candy that invites savoring, rewarding those who take the time to enjoy its complexity.
Its unique taste and texture set it apart from more mainstream options, and its honeyed sweetness paired with almond bits creates an intriguing blend.
Though not as widely known as other candies, Bit-O-Honey maintains a devoted fan base that appreciates its distinct charm and enduring appeal.
16. Peanut Butter M&M’s
Peanut Butter M&M’s are a step up from the classic, offering a creamy peanut butter center wrapped in a crunchy candy shell. Bigger and more flavorful, they are a treat for those who crave a rich peanut butter experience.
The smooth peanut butter complements the crispy shell perfectly, creating a harmonious blend that’s hard to resist. They stand out in the vast M&M’s lineup for their bold flavor.
For peanut butter enthusiasts, these candies are a must-try, delivering satisfaction in every colorful piece.