5 Tuna Brands to Buy and 2 You Should Definitely Skip

Choosing the right tuna brand can significantly impact your culinary experience, whether you’re crafting a delicate tapas dish or simply making a sandwich. This detailed guide explores five highly recommended tuna brands known for their quality and sustainability, and highlights two that may not meet your expectations.

1. Wild Planet

Wild Planet
© Wild Planet

Wild Planet tuna is renowned for its commitment to sustainability and exceptional quality. Each can is packed with firm, flaky tuna that promises a clean, bold flavor. No added water or oil means you get pure tuna goodness. Ideal for health-conscious consumers, this brand ensures each bite remains flavorful and wholesome.



The company’s dedication to sustainable fishing practices reflects in every can. Perfect for those who value both taste and environmental responsibility, Wild Planet offers a fresh, unadulterated taste experience. Whether enjoyed straight from the can or as part of a gourmet recipe, it never disappoints.

2. Safe Catch

Safe Catch
© Safe Catch

Safe Catch stands out for its rigorous mercury testing and nutrient retention methods. Every can is slow-cooked to lock in maximum flavor and nutrition, making it a top choice for health aficionados. This brand caters to those who seek a clean, guilt-free meal option.



With an emphasis on safety, Safe Catch ensures each can meets the highest standards, providing peace of mind with every bite. Its firm texture and rich taste make it an excellent addition to any dish, whether a simple salad or an elaborate culinary creation.

3. Ortiz

Ortiz
© Ibérico Taste

Ortiz tuna brings a touch of luxury with its exquisite flavor and silky texture. Packed in olive oil, this Spanish delicacy transforms any meal into a gourmet experience. Perfect for upscale salads or indulgent tapas, Ortiz tuna is a connoisseur’s delight.



Its rich taste and smooth texture elevate everyday dishes to something extraordinary. Ortiz’s commitment to quality shines through in every can, offering a taste of Spain that captivates the palate. Whether used in a classic sandwich or a new culinary venture, Ortiz never fails to impress.

4. American Tuna

American Tuna
© GoSupps.com

American Tuna takes pride in its pole-and-line caught process, ensuring a rich, robust flavor that stands out. Caught in U.S. waters, this brand supports ethical practices while delivering a quality product. Its minimal processing allows the natural taste to shine.



Ideal for those who prioritize sustainability and flavor, American Tuna offers a satisfying bite that pairs well with various dishes. The company’s commitment to ethical fishing practices makes it a trustworthy choice for conscientious consumers. Experience a taste that truly reflects its strong ethical roots.

5. Trader Joe’s Albacore Tuna in Olive Oil

Trader Joe’s Albacore Tuna in Olive Oil
© Reddit

Trader Joe’s Albacore Tuna surprises with its high quality at a budget-friendly price. Packed in olive oil, it delivers meaty chunks with a depth of flavor uncommon in its price range. Perfect for budget-conscious gourmets, this tuna doesn’t compromise on taste.



Its rich olive oil base complements the tuna’s natural taste, creating a delightful culinary experience. No odd aftertaste here—just pure, flavorful bites that enhance any dish. From a quick sandwich to a sophisticated entrée, Trader Joe’s Albacore Tuna is a versatile choice for any kitchen.

6. StarKist Chunk Light in Water

StarKist Chunk Light in Water
© Amazon.com

StarKist Chunk Light in Water often falls short with its mushy texture and metallic aftertaste. This brand struggles to deliver the consistent quality that discerning tuna fans expect. Many find themselves reaching for condiments to mask its lackluster flavor.



Despite being a recognizable name, StarKist fails to impress those seeking fresh, vibrant taste. Its inconsistent quality makes it a less desirable choice for those who appreciate genuine seafood flavors. Better suited for heavily-dressed dishes, it may not satisfy standalone or subtle gourmet needs.

7. Chicken of the Sea Chunk Light

Chicken of the Sea Chunk Light
© Amazon.com

Chicken of the Sea Chunk Light leaves much to be desired with its soft, stringy texture and overly fishy taste. Many find it unsuitable for standalone dishes, as it lacks the fresh flavor needed for a satisfying meal.



While familiar to many, it often disappoints those seeking a more refined tuna experience. Its consistency may suit some heavily seasoned preparations, but it rarely shines as the main ingredient. Those looking for a fresh, clean taste might find themselves looking elsewhere.