5 Italian Subs That Fall Flat And 6 Sandwich Chain Picks That Truly Hit the Spot

In a quest for the perfect Italian sub, many sandwich chains have taken a stab at creating the ultimate flavor-packed experience. However, not all subs are created equal. This post explores five Italian subs that miss the mark, alongside six that truly stand out with their taste and authenticity. The journey takes us through a variety of flavors, textures, and culinary craftsmanship, unveiling both disappointments and triumphs in the world of Italian sandwiches.

1. Subway’s Italian B.M.T.

Subway’s Italian B.M.T. is an attempt at capturing the essence of an Italian sub but falls flat with its reliance on processed meats. While visually inviting, the sandwich is dominated by slices of salami, pepperoni, and ham that lack the bold flavors one might expect.

The sub’s composition is further compromised by a scant offering of fresh vegetables. Despite the potential of its freshly baked bread, the B.M.T. often misses the mark, leaving a desire for more authentic flavor combinations.

This effort results in a bland experience, rather than the robust journey of tastes it promises.

2. Quiznos’ Classic Italian

Quiznos’ Classic Italian sub aims to deliver a hearty meal but ends up being excessively salty and oily. The sandwich is stacked with the usual suspects: ham, salami, and pepperoni, but the balance is off, leaning heavily towards saltiness.

The sub lacks the crisp freshness that should contrast the rich meats, often leaving a greasy aftertaste that overshadows subtler flavors.

While the promise of a toasted sub might draw one in, the execution leaves much to be desired, with the textures and flavors not living up to the classic Italian sub expectations.

3. Firehouse Subs Italian

Firehouse Subs’ Italian sandwich is robust and hearty, but tends to feel weighed down by greasy meats and an overpowering dressing. The roast beef, ham, and pepperoni create a meat-heavy profile, yet the balance one seeks in authentic Italian subs is lacking.

The dressing, meant to enhance, often floods the palate with too much richness, overshadowing other subtle flavors.

Despite being a filling option, the sandwich fails to capture the delicate harmony and satisfying experience that an Italian sub should provide, leaving diners with a sense of heaviness rather than delight.

4. Jimmy John’s Italian Night Club

Jimmy John’s Italian Night Club presents itself with an invitingly fresh loaf, but the filling inside doesn’t quite match the initial promise. While the bread provides a satisfying crunch, the meats and toppings lack the zest that defines a true Italian sub.

Slices of salami, capicola, and smoked ham make an appearance but deliver a one-dimensional flavor that feels underwhelming.

The freshness of the bread is a standout feature, yet it highlights the insufficiency of the other components, leaving a too-safe taste that doesn’t push the boundaries of what an Italian sub can be.

5. Jersey Mike’s Stickball Special

Jersey Mike’s Stickball Special serves as a reminder of the potential within a classic sub experience, but it doesn’t fully deliver. The sandwich is lighter on meats, combining provolone, ham, and salami, but misses the robust punch one hopes for.

While the “Mike’s Way” topping style adds a familiar touch, it doesn’t elevate the sub beyond the ordinary.

The Stickball Special’s attempt at simplicity might appeal to some, but for those seeking depth and richness in their Italian subs, this option feels like a missed opportunity to shine.

6. Jersey Mike’s #13 Original Italian

Jersey Mike’s #13 Original Italian stands out as a quintessential choice for Italian sub enthusiasts. Overflowing with provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and pepperoni, it presents a medley of flavors that harmonize beautifully.

The sandwich’s charm is further enhanced by “Mike’s Way” toppings, which add a splash of vinegar, oil, and spices, making each bite excitingly textured and flavorful.

This sub captures the essence of an authentic Italian deli experience, delivering a hearty, satisfying meal that resonates with lovers of Italian cuisine and sandwich aficionados alike.

7. Capriotti’s Bobbie (with Italian Sub Modifications)

Capriotti’s Bobbie, traditionally known for its turkey, transforms into a noteworthy Italian sub with a few modifications. By swapping in Italian meats, the sandwich achieves a freshness and balance that delights the palate.

The combination of flavors creates a unique twist on the classic, offering both a nod to tradition and a departure from the expected.

This modification results in a well-rounded sandwich where the juiciness of the meats complements the crunch of fresh vegetables, providing an engaging and satisfying bite that stands out in the Italian sub category.

8. Potbelly’s Italian Sandwich

Potbelly’s Italian Sandwich offers a classic taste nestled within a toasted roll, creating a warm and comforting meal option. With layers of salami, capicola, mortadella, and provolone, this sub balances flavors with finesse.

Each ingredient contributes to a harmonious taste profile, where the richness of the meats is offset by the creaminess of the cheese and the crunch of the toasted bread.

The sandwich’s toasting process enhances the aromas and adds a delightful crispness, ensuring each bite is filled with both texture and flavor that satisfies Italian sub cravings.

9. PrimoHoagies Italian Diablo

PrimoHoagies Italian Diablo captures the spirit of a fiery Italian sub with its bold and spicy offerings. Layered with capicola, hot soppressata, and pepperoni, this sandwich sets itself apart with a tantalizing kick.

The use of authentic seeded rolls adds a traditional touch, complementing the spicy meats and cheeses beautifully.

For those seeking a sub that awakens the senses, the Italian Diablo delivers with its strong flavors and satisfying heat. This option embodies the vibrant and passionate side of Italian cuisine, appealing to adventurous eaters and spice lovers alike.

10. Lenny’s Grill & Subs Italian

Lenny’s Grill & Subs Italian shines as a traditional favorite among sandwich aficionados. Crafted with high-quality meats like ham, salami, and capicola, this sub emphasizes freshness and flavor.

The generous toppings complement the meats, adding a burst of crisp texture and taste, while the seasoning brings everything together in perfect harmony.

This sub offers a comforting and familiar taste, reminiscent of classic Italian deli sandwiches, making it a reliable choice for those who appreciate well-prepared, satisfying subs that hit all the right notes in texture and flavor.

11. Mendocino Farms Italian Deli Sub

Mendocino Farms Italian Deli Sub redefines the classic with a gourmet twist. Featuring premium meats, artisan bread, and housemade spreads, this sandwich offers an upscale take on the beloved Italian sub.

The attention to detail is evident in the careful selection of ingredients, each contributing to a refined yet hearty experience.

For those seeking a more sophisticated palate experience, this sub delights with its innovative combinations and elegant presentation. The Italian Deli Sub captures the essence of gourmet dining within the familiar form of a sandwich, providing a fresh perspective on a traditional favorite.