35 Retro Sandwiches We Grew Up Loving, And Some We Hated

Explore a nostalgic list of 35 retro sandwiches, capturing the essence of culinary memories from our childhood. Some sandwiches in this list are beloved classics, while others are less fondly remembered. Dive into this mix of flavors and textures, and recall the tastes that defined our past meals, whether they were loved or merely tolerated.

1. Peanut Butter and Jelly

Peanut butter and jelly sandwiches are timeless classics. The combination of creamy peanut butter with sweet grape jelly creates a flavor profile that’s both comforting and nostalgic. This sandwich, often packed in lunchboxes, holds memories of simpler times.

The simplicity of its ingredients makes it a go-to for busy parents and a favorite among children. Layered on soft white bread, its taste is perfectly balanced between salty and sweet.

It’s a sandwich that transcends generations, evoking warm memories with every bite. Loved by many, it remains undefeated in its simplicity.

2. Grilled Cheese

Grilled cheese sandwiches bring warmth and comfort to any meal. The crispy exterior and gooey cheese center make it a beloved choice for young and old alike. Often paired with tomato soup, it’s the quintessential comfort food.

The process of grilling creates a delightful contrast between the crunchy bread and the smooth, melty cheese. Each bite is a blend of textures and flavors that satisfy the soul.

Whether enjoyed on a rainy day or as a late-night snack, grilled cheese remains an unbeatable classic in the sandwich world.

3. Tuna Salad Sandwich

Tuna salad sandwiches offer a combination of flavors and textures that make them a lunchtime staple. With crunchy celery and a touch of mustard, the filling is both flavorful and satisfying.

The cool, creamy texture of the tuna salad contrasts beautifully with the hearty bread, creating a harmonious bite. This sandwich is ideal for picnics, lunches, or a quick meal on the go.

When done right, the tuna salad sandwich is more than just a quick fix; it’s a flavorful experience that fills and delights.

4. Egg Salad Sandwich

Egg salad sandwiches are a tangy delight. Their creamy texture combined with a hint of tang makes them uniquely satisfying. Typically served on white bread with the crusts removed, they exude simplicity and nostalgia.

The filling, often enhanced with mayonnaise and mustard, appeals to those who appreciate a blend of creamy and tangy flavors. It’s a sandwich that’s as comforting as it is delicious.

Egg salad sandwiches may remind many of childhood lunches, where the care in preparation was evident in every bite.

5. BLT

The BLT sandwich is a perfect harmony of crisp, juicy, and savory elements. With crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, and ripe tomatoes, it’s a sandwich that satisfies on multiple fronts.

The addition of mayonnaise on toasted bread elevates the flavors, making each bite a delightful experience. It’s the kind of sandwich that feels both indulgent and refreshing.

Whether enjoyed as a quick lunch or a hearty snack, the BLT remains a beloved classic that balances simplicity with flavor.

6. Ham and Cheese

Ham and cheese sandwiches are the epitome of simplicity and flavor. The salty ham paired with melted cheese creates a delightful taste that’s both comforting and satisfying.

Adding a little mustard or pickles introduces a tangy twist, enhancing the overall flavor. It’s a sandwich that fits perfectly in a lunchbox or as a quick meal.

Despite its simplicity, the ham and cheese sandwich has stood the test of time, offering a reliable taste that many have grown to love.

7. Turkey and Swiss

Turkey and Swiss sandwiches offer a step up from plain ham, bringing a touch of deli-style elegance to the table. With layers of turkey and Swiss cheese, it’s a sandwich that appeals with its blend of flavors.

The addition of lettuce and tomato adds freshness, while whole grain bread provides a wholesome base. This sandwich is both filling and satisfying.

Ideal for lunchboxes or casual dining, the turkey and Swiss sandwich is a classic choice for those who appreciate quality ingredients.

8. Meatball Sub

A meatball sub is a messy yet glorious sandwich, packed with flavorful elements. The combination of marinara sauce, melty cheese, and juicy meatballs is an irresistible treat.

Served in a crusty sub roll, it offers a hearty meal that satisfies even the hungriest of appetites. Each bite is a meld of savory flavors that evoke comfort and indulgence.

The meatball sub is a classic choice for those seeking a filling and delicious sandwich experience, perfect for lunch or dinner.

9. Sloppy Joe

Sloppy Joes are a beloved cafeteria staple, known for their messy yet delightful appeal. Made with ground beef in a sweet and tangy sauce, they’re a favorite among those who enjoy bold flavors.

Served on a soft hamburger bun, the sandwich is both filling and satisfying. The sauce’s sweetness complements the savory beef, creating a delicious contrast.

Whether eaten with hands or a fork, the Sloppy Joe is an enduring favorite that brings joy to both young and old.

10. Patty Melt

Patty melts are a diner staple, blending the best of a burger and a sandwich. The grilled burger patty, combined with onions and melted cheese on rye, creates a mouthwatering combination.

This sandwich offers a satisfying crunch from the rye bread and a juicy burst from the meat. It’s a comforting choice that feels both classic and indulgent.

For those craving a hearty meal, the patty melt is an ideal choice, evoking memories of cozy diner meals.

11. Tuna Melt

Tuna melts are an unexpected delight, combining creamy tuna salad with melty cheese and grilled bread. The result is a sandwich that surprises with its flavorful depth.

The warm cheese melds with the cool tuna, creating a harmonious bite that satisfies on multiple levels. It’s a sandwich that’s both comforting and filling.

Perfect for casual lunches or light dinners, the tuna melt is a classic choice for those who enjoy a unique twist on traditional flavors.

12. PB & Banana

The peanut butter and banana sandwich is a nostalgic favorite, often enhanced with a drizzle of honey. This combination, beloved by Elvis, offers a unique blend of sweet and savory flavors.

The creamy peanut butter pairs perfectly with the soft, sweet banana slices, creating a satisfying texture. It’s a sandwich that’s both nutritious and delicious.

Whether enjoyed as a breakfast or a snack, the PB & banana sandwich remains a cherished classic, appealing to those who enjoy a touch of sweetness in their meals.

13. Bologna and Cheese

Bologna and cheese sandwiches evoke memories of childhood lunches. The combination of bologna and cheese offers a salty, satisfying taste that’s both simple and enjoyable.

Fried or cold, this sandwich delivers a nostalgic flavor that many remember fondly. Served on soft white bread, it’s an easy and accessible choice.

Despite its simplicity, the bologna and cheese sandwich remains a staple for those seeking a quick and tasty meal, reminiscent of days gone by.

14. French Dip

French Dip sandwiches bring a touch of elegance to the sandwich world. With slices of roast beef and a side of au jus, it feels sophisticated yet accessible.

The act of dipping the sandwich into the rich, savory broth adds an interactive element that enhances the flavor. It’s a dining experience that feels both indulgent and satisfying.

Whether enjoyed at a diner or home, the French Dip remains a beloved choice for those seeking a flavorful and immersive meal.

15. Club Sandwich

Club sandwiches are synonymous with hearty, satisfying meals. Featuring layers of turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato, they offer a medley of flavors that delight the palate.

The sandwich’s towering structure, often held together with toothpicks, adds an element of fun and challenge to eating. Each layer brings a unique texture and taste.

Perfect for those who enjoy a substantial meal, the club sandwich remains a classic choice for lunch or dinner, providing a satisfying blend of ingredients.

16. Chicken Salad Sandwich

Chicken salad sandwiches offer a refreshing and flavorful lunchtime option. Made with chunks of chicken, grapes, or nuts, they bring a unique combination of textures and flavors.

The creamy chicken filling is complemented by the slight crunch of nuts and the sweetness of grapes, creating a harmonious bite. Served on a croissant or bread, it’s both delicious and filling.

Ideal for picnics or casual lunches, the chicken salad sandwich is a classic choice for those seeking a refreshing twist on traditional flavors.

17. Hot Ham and Cheese (Microwaved or Toaster Oven)

Hot ham and cheese sandwiches are the quintessential after-school snack. The gooey, melty cheese combined with salty ham creates a comforting and satisfying meal.

Whether prepared in a microwave or toaster oven, the sandwich offers a quick and easy option for those in need of a warm meal. It’s a nostalgic reminder of simpler times.

Perfect for school-aged children or busy adults, the hot ham and cheese sandwich remains a beloved choice for its ease and deliciousness.

18. Croque Monsieur

Croque Monsieur sandwiches bring a touch of French sophistication to any meal. Made with ham, Gruyère cheese, and béchamel sauce, they offer a rich and indulgent taste.

The golden toasted bread adds a satisfying crunch, while the creamy béchamel sauce elevates the flavors. It’s a sandwich that feels both luxurious and comforting.

Perfect for brunch or a special lunch, the Croque Monsieur stands out as a versatile and delicious choice for those seeking to indulge in French cuisine.

19. Pimento Cheese Sandwich

Pimento cheese sandwiches are a Southern classic that divides opinions. The creamy, orange filling, made with cheese and pimentos, offers a bold flavor that’s both unique and intriguing.

For some, it’s a beloved favorite; for others, the texture and taste are an acquired experience. Served on white bread, it’s a simple yet distinctive choice.

Whether loved or tolerated, the pimento cheese sandwich remains a staple in Southern cuisine, known for its bold character and unmistakable taste.

20. Spam Sandwich

Spam sandwiches offer a nostalgic taste that evokes memories of simpler times. Fried slices of Spam on white bread create a salty, satisfying taste that’s both quirky and memorable.

For some, it’s a beloved childhood favorite; for others, it’s a taste best left in the past. The addition of mustard adds a tangy twist that enhances the flavor.

Whether loved or merely tolerated, the Spam sandwich remains a unique choice that continues to evoke strong opinions and memories.

21. Olive and Cream Cheese

Olive and cream cheese sandwiches are a bold choice, combining the briny taste of olives with the creamy smoothness of cream cheese. It’s a combination that intrigues the adventurous eater.

The spread, often served on rye bread, offers a distinct flavor profile that’s both unique and satisfying. For some, it’s a cherished favorite; for others, a once-tasted curiosity.

This sandwich stands out for its bold flavors, appealing to those who enjoy a daring culinary experience.

22. Cucumber Tea Sandwich

Cucumber tea sandwiches bring a touch of elegance to any gathering. With thin slices of cucumber and a spread of cream cheese on crustless white bread, they offer a delicate taste.

Often served at tea parties, these sandwiches are as much about presentation as flavor. Their subtle taste and light texture make them an ideal choice for those seeking sophistication.

While not bold in flavor, the cucumber tea sandwich remains a classic for its refreshing taste and refined appearance.

23. Deviled Ham Sandwich (from a can)

Deviled ham sandwiches evoke a sense of nostalgia with their soft, canned ham spread. The salty and slightly spicy filling is an acquired taste that some remember fondly.

Served on white bread, the sandwich is simple yet distinctive, offering a unique flavor that stands out among more traditional options. It’s a choice that’s both intriguing and memorable.

For those who enjoy a taste of the past, the deviled ham sandwich remains a curious and flavorful option.

24. Cold Meatloaf Sandwich

Cold meatloaf sandwiches turn leftovers into a delightful meal. Slices of cold meatloaf on whole grain bread create a hearty and satisfying taste that’s surprisingly delicious.

The addition of ketchup or mustard adds a tangy twist that complements the savory meatloaf. It’s a sandwich that feels both comforting and economical.

For those who appreciate resourceful cooking, the cold meatloaf sandwich offers a unique way to enjoy a classic dish in sandwich form.

25. Cheese and Mayo Sandwich

Cheese and mayo sandwiches are a simple yet satisfying choice. With slices of cheese and a spread of mayonnaise on white bread, they offer a creamy and savory taste.

For some, this sandwich is a lazy genius; for others, it’s a low-effort meal that satisfies. The combination is both intriguing and comforting.

Despite its simplicity, the cheese and mayo sandwich offers a unique taste experience for those who enjoy straightforward flavors.

26. Liverwurst Sandwich

Liverwurst sandwiches evoke strong reactions, with their spreadable meat paste and distinctive flavor. The rich, savory taste is either loved or avoided, making it a polarizing choice.

Served on rye bread, the sandwich offers a bold taste that’s both intriguing and divisive. The addition of pickles or mustard can enhance the flavor, adding a tangy contrast.

For those who enjoy a daring culinary adventure, the liverwurst sandwich offers a unique taste experience that stands out.

27. Tongue Sandwich

Tongue sandwiches, featuring slices of beef tongue, are more common than one might think in old-school delis. The unique flavor and texture make it a rare treat for adventurous eaters.

Served on rye bread with horseradish sauce, the sandwich offers a distinctive taste that’s both savory and bold. It’s a choice that intrigues those seeking a culinary challenge.

For those willing to try something different, the tongue sandwich offers an opportunity to enjoy a traditional deli favorite.

28. Banana and Mayo Sandwich

Banana and mayo sandwiches are a Southern delicacy that confounds many. The combination of sweet banana slices with mayonnaise offers a unique taste experience that’s both intriguing and perplexing.

For some, it’s a cherished childhood memory; for others, it’s a taste that’s difficult to embrace. The sandwich’s simple ingredients create a surprising blend of flavors.

Whether loved or questioned, the banana and mayo sandwich remains a conversation starter and a testament to unique culinary traditions.

29. Sardine Sandwich

Sardine sandwiches are a bold choice, known for their strong, fishy flavor. Packed with sardines and lettuce on rye bread, they offer a taste that’s both distinctive and memorable.

The addition of vinegar pickles adds a tangy contrast, enhancing the sandwich’s flavor profile. It’s a choice that appeals to those who enjoy bold and adventurous tastes.

For those willing to embrace the unique, the sardine sandwich offers a taste experience that stands apart from more conventional options.

30. Peanut Butter and Pickle

Peanut butter and pickle sandwiches are a quirky combination that intrigues the adventurous eater. The smooth peanut butter alongside crunchy dill pickles creates a contrast that’s both intriguing and satisfying.

While some call it a genius pairing, others find it perplexing. The combination of salty, sweet, and tangy flavors makes for a unique taste experience.

For those willing to explore unconventional flavors, this sandwich offers a surprising and delightful culinary adventure.

31. Cold Hot Dog Sandwich

Cold hot dog sandwiches are simple yet surprising, featuring a cold hot dog with ketchup on white bread. It’s a straightforward choice that evokes memories of quick meals and casual lunches.

The combination is both familiar and unexpected, offering a taste that’s reminiscent of summer picnics and childhood snacks. The addition of potato chips adds a crunchy texture.

For those who enjoy a nostalgic bite, the cold hot dog sandwich remains a quirky and memorable option.

32. Butter and Sugar Sandwich

Butter and sugar sandwiches are a sweet, sticky treat that offers a taste of nostalgia. With a layer of butter and a sprinkle of sugar on white bread, they create a deliciously simple dessert.

Often made as a last-minute solution, these sandwiches are both economical and satisfying. The combination of creamy butter and sweet sugar is a delight for those with a sweet tooth.

For those seeking a taste of childhood, the butter and sugar sandwich provides a comforting and indulgent experience.

33. Tomato and Mayo Sandwich (Soggy Version)

Tomato and mayo sandwiches, when fresh, are a Southern treasure. However, when left too long, they can become a soggy disappointment. With slices of tomato and mayonnaise on white bread, they offer a simple yet flavorful taste.

The contrast between juicy tomatoes and creamy mayo creates a satisfying bite that’s perfect for summer lunches. When fresh, it’s a delightful treat.

For those who appreciate the classics, the tomato and mayo sandwich remains a flavorful choice, even if occasionally soggy.

34. American Cheese and Ketchup

American cheese and ketchup sandwiches are a simple yet polarizing choice. With slices of plastic-like cheese and a dollop of ketchup on white bread, they offer a taste that’s both familiar and controversial.

For some, it’s a childhood favorite; for others, it’s a taste better forgotten. The combination of creamy cheese and tangy ketchup creates a distinct flavor that’s both intriguing and puzzling.

For those who appreciate simplicity, the American cheese and ketchup sandwich remains a quirky and memorable option.

35. Powdered Drink Mix Sandwich (Yes, Really)

Powdered drink mix sandwiches are a curious creation, featuring Kool-Aid powder sprinkled on buttered bread. It’s a taste that’s both sweet and slightly tangy, reminiscent of childhood experiments.

For some, it’s a cherished memory of culinary creativity; for others, it’s a taste best left in the past. The combination of flavors is surprisingly intriguing.

For those willing to try something unusual, the powdered drink mix sandwich offers a sweet and quirky taste adventure.