3 Fast-Food Apple Pies That Disappointed—And 4 That Were Sweet, Flaky Perfection

Not all fast-food apple pies are created equal. While some are nostalgic, flaky, and packed with cinnamon-spiced apples, others fall flat with soggy crusts or bland filling. Here’s a look at 3 that disappointed—and 4 that truly delivered sweet, flaky perfection.

1. McDonald’s (Current Version – Baked)

Once renowned for its fried apple pie, McDonald’s baked version doesn’t quite hit the mark. With a texture often described as mushy, it lacks the satisfying crunch that its predecessor boasted. The crust, though lower in calories, feels lackluster compared to the golden fried delight that many nostalgically remember.

Fans often reminisce about the past, expressing a longing for the original’s bubbly crunch and rich flavor. Despite its healthier profile, the modern version leaves some feeling underwhelmed, craving the harmonious blend of texture and taste that truly defines a comforting apple pie experience.

2. Burger King

Burger King’s attempt at an apple pie leaves much to be desired. Served warm and fried, the crust tends to be greasy, overshadowing the potentially delightful filling. Alas, the filling itself can be overly gelatinous or too sweet, lacking the spice and balance expected in a great apple pie.

This combination can deter those seeking a classic apple pie experience, leaving them with a sense of missed potential. The pie’s presentation promises much but delivers little, making it a choice for those less concerned with the nuances of flavor and texture.

3. Wendy’s

Wendy’s doesn’t universally offer an apple pie, and where it does, the dessert feels more like a store-bought substitute than a freshly baked treat. Pre-packaged and often overly sweet, it lacks the homemade touch that elevates an apple pie to a comforting delicacy.

This dessert option can leave one yearning for a more authentic experience, as the convenient packaging sacrifices the warm, inviting sensation of a freshly made pie. The balance between sweetness and apple flavor feels off, adding to the disappointment for pie enthusiasts.

4. Popeyes

Popeyes’ apple pie stands out with its perfectly fried, golden crust lightly dusted with cinnamon sugar. This crispy exterior houses a gooey filling brimming with spiced apples, creating a delightful contrast in each bite.

Fans flock to this favorite, appreciating the harmonious blend of textures and flavors that it consistently delivers. The pie’s ability to evoke a sense of indulgence and warmth makes it a celebrated choice among fast-food desserts. Its delightful balance of spice and sweetness marks it as a standout in the world of fast-food apple pies.

5. Church’s Texas Chicken

At Church’s Texas Chicken, the apple pie is a triumph of texture and taste. Served fried, it boasts an extra-crispy crust generously dusted with cinnamon sugar. Inside, the filling is warm and flavorful, with spiced apples that entice the palate.

This pie doesn’t just satisfy; it delights those who crave a sweet indulgence done right. The pie’s execution is meticulous, ensuring that each element complements the other beautifully. It’s a treat that resonates with those seeking a perfect blend of crunch, warmth, and sweetness in their dessert.

6. Jollibee

Jollibee offers a delightful twist on the traditional apple pie. With a thin, crispy crust and a filling that is modestly sweet, it captures a balance that many say rivals the original McDonald’s fried version.

Fans of Jollibee appreciate the pie’s ability to deliver on taste without overwhelming sweetness, allowing the spiced apples to shine. It’s a crispy, satisfying treat that resonates with those who cherish a well-executed, classic dessert. The pie’s subtlety in sweetness makes it a refreshing option for those who seek harmony in their dessert choices.

7. Arby’s (Limited Time)

Arby’s apple turnover is a limited-time delight that captures attention with its buttery, flaky crust. Filled with tangy-sweet apple chunks, it promises a unique twist on the classic pie experience.

The icing drizzle adds a layer of sweetness that complements rather than overwhelms, ensuring the turnover remains light and flavorful. This limited offering calls to those who appreciate a nuanced dessert that doesn’t shy away from delivering on taste. Arby’s pie stands as a testament to the possibilities within fast-food desserts, offering a refreshing change from the ordinary.