28 Calorie-Laden Pizzas In America That’ll Blow Your Diet

Explore a mouthwatering list of the top 28 calorie-heavy pizzas in America that will surely challenge your diet. From coast to coast, these pizza choices stand out for their indulgent ingredients and calorie-packed slices. Whether you’re a fan of classic pepperoni or adventurous with seafood toppings, this list offers a taste of everything that’s rich and satisfying.

1. Pizza Hut’s Meat Lover’s Stuffed Crust (Large)

Pizza Hut’s Meat Lover’s Stuffed Crust is not just a meal—it’s an experience. With each slice overflowing with layers of pepperoni, sausage, and hearty cheese, this pizza is a carnivore’s delight. The stuffed crust adds an unexpected twist, turning the standard pizza slice into a gooey, cheesy adventure. Perfect for those who believe that more is always better, this pie doesn’t skimp on satisfaction. But beware, as the calorie count climbs higher, the decision between another slice or fitting into your jeans becomes a challenge. It’s a classic dilemma for any pizza aficionado.

2. Domino’s ExtravaganZZa Hand-Tossed (Large)

Domino’s ExtravaganZZa is the epitome of abundance. Picture a hand-tossed crust loaded with every topping imaginable: pepperoni, sausage, onions, mushrooms, and more. Each slice is a symphony of flavors designed to overwhelm the senses. It’s like having a pizza party on your plate. For those who can’t choose just one topping, this pizza offers the ultimate indulgence. However, this flavor fiesta comes with a side of caloric density, making each bite both a pleasure and a test of willpower.

3. Papa John’s The Works with Original Crust

Papa John’s The Works is a classic favorite for those who crave a balanced mix of meats and veggies. The substantial original crust serves as a sturdy foundation for layers of pepperoni, sausage, onions, and peppers. Every slice is a satisfying encounter, offering a taste of everything, all at once. It’s a pizza that promises fullness in every sense, both in flavor and in caloric intake, almost turning each slice into its own meal. A delicious challenge for anyone daring enough to indulge.

4. Little Caesars 3 Meat Treat

Little Caesars’ 3 Meat Treat is the definition of simplicity meeting indulgence. Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon, this pizza brings a trio of meat flavors to the forefront. Despite its budget-friendly price, each slice is deceptively dense and packed with flavor. The high sodium content adds to the guilty pleasure, making it a treat that’s hard to resist and easy to devour. An unexpected delight, this pizza proves that sometimes, less is indeed more—if by ‘less’ we mean less space left in your calorie count.

5. California Pizza Kitchen’s Five Cheese + Fresh Tomato

California Pizza Kitchen’s Five Cheese + Fresh Tomato is a harmonious blend of simplicity and richness. At first glance, it might seem like a lighter choice, but don’t be fooled. The combination of mozzarella, fontina, gouda, and romano cheeses creates a creamy, decadent experience. Topped with fresh tomatoes, each slice is a celebration of gourmet flavors. It’s a pizza that whispers sophistication while still packing a caloric punch, reminding you that even simplicity can be indulgent. A sophisticated choice for cheese lovers everywhere.

6. Blaze Pizza Meat Eater Build-Your-Own (Loaded)

Blaze Pizza’s Meat Eater takes customization to a new level. Imagine crafting your own pizza masterpiece, only to load it with a variety of meats and rich sauces. Each personal pie is a unique creation, perfectly tailored to satisfy any carnivorous craving. With options to pile on as many toppings as you wish, the calorie count quickly escalates. This is pizza for the adventurous eater, one who isn’t afraid to embrace the full potential of their cravings. A personal indulgence that’s as risky as it is rewarding.

7. Marco’s All Meat Specialty Pizza

Marco’s All Meat Specialty Pizza is a celebration of all things meaty. With a crust that’s both crisp and chewy, it serves as the perfect base for an array of meats including ham, pepperoni, and sausage. Each slice is a hearty feast, making it the go-to choice for those who believe in going big or going home. This pizza isn’t just a meal; it’s a statement. While it satisfies the biggest of appetites, it also packs a hefty caloric punch, reminding us that indulgence often comes at a price.

8. Giordano’s Deep Dish (Chicago, IL)

Giordano’s Deep Dish is a Chicago staple that redefines the pizza experience. Known for its towering layers of cheese and rich tomato sauce, each slice is a meal in itself. The buttery crust cradles a luxurious filling, making it not just a pizza, but an event. A single slice can be over 600 calories, which speaks volumes about its indulgence level. It’s a pizza that embraces the spirit of Chicago: bold, hearty, and unapologetically satisfying. Perfect for those who see pizza as more than just a quick bite.

9. L&B Spumoni Gardens Sicilian Pie (Brooklyn, NY)

L&B Spumoni Gardens’ Sicilian Pie is a Brooklyn legend. Known for its thick, square slices, each piece is a delightful combination of dense crust, sweet tomato sauce, and gooey cheese. It’s pizza that plays by its own rules, offering a thicker, heartier bite. The sweetness of the sauce is a signature, setting it apart from typical pizzas. At over 450 calories per slice, it’s a heavy hitter in the calorie department but offers a slice of New York’s rich pizza heritage. A must-try for any pizza lover visiting Brooklyn.

10. Prince Street Pizza’s Pepperoni Square (NYC)

Prince Street Pizza’s Pepperoni Square is a New York City icon, celebrated for its thick crust and characteristic crispy pepperoni cups. Each bite is a perfect balance of rich cheese and savory pepperoni, all resting atop a robust, flavorful crust. The edges are delightfully crispy, offering a textural contrast that’s deeply satisfying. It’s a pizza with character, capturing the essence of NYC’s vibrant food scene. Overindulgence is easy with this calorie-rich delight, as its flavors invite you back slice after slice. Truly a slice of New York’s finest.

11. Detroit-Style Pizza at Jet’s (Nationwide)

Jet’s Detroit-Style Pizza brings a regional favorite to a wider audience. Known for its rectangular shape and thick, airy crust, it’s topped with a generous layer of cheese that caramelizes to perfection. Each bite is a mouthful of rich, cheesy goodness, complemented by a robust tomato sauce that adds tang and depth. It’s a pizza that feels like home, offering comfort in every slice. However, with over 400 calories per slice, it’s a pleasure that’s as substantial as it is satisfying. Perfect for sharing, but hard to resist keeping to oneself.

12. Pizzeria Bianco’s Wiseguy (Phoenix, AZ)

Pizzeria Bianco’s Wiseguy is a masterpiece of artisan pizza making. Featuring savory sausage, roasted onions, and their signature cheese blend, it’s a pizza that offers complexity in every bite. The thin, crispy crust serves as the perfect canvas for these robust flavors, with each ingredient complementing the other harmoniously. It’s a pizza that invites exploration, offering new taste experiences with each slice. Despite its gourmet appeal, the calorie count adds up quickly, making it a decadent choice that’s worth every bite. A must-try for those in Phoenix seeking authentic taste.

13. Frank Pepe’s White Clam Pizza (New Haven, CT)

Frank Pepe’s White Clam Pizza is a New Haven treasure. Known for its unique topping of fresh clams, garlic, and white cheese, it’s a pizza that challenges the norm. The charred, crisp crust provides a smoky undertone that enhances the overall flavor profile. Each slice is a journey into rich, maritime tastes, offering something both unusual and delightful. While seafood might seem light, this pie is rich and calorie-laden, offering a taste of Connecticut’s pizza history. A daring choice for anyone willing to step outside traditional pizza boundaries.

14. DiGiorno Supreme Rising Crust

DiGiorno Supreme Rising Crust shifts the notion that frozen pizzas can’t be indulgent. With a thick, fluffy crust, each slice is topped with a medley of pepperoni, sausage, and vegetables. It’s a frozen pizza that aims to deliver freshness and flavor rivaling delivery. Perfect for a quiet night in, this pizza provides a hearty, satisfying meal. However, with over 600 calories for just a third of the pie, it’s a caloric indulgence that whispers of comfort and ease. A reliable choice for those seeking quality without leaving home.

15. Tombstone Original Pepperoni

Tombstone Original Pepperoni is a slice of nostalgia with every bite. Known for its simple yet effective combination of cheese and pepperoni, it’s a pizza that speaks to tradition. The classic flavors transport you to a time where pizza night was the highlight of the week. With a crispy crust and a generous topping of pepperoni, it satisfies cravings without pretense. Yet, consuming half the pie equates to nearly 900 calories, making it a guilty pleasure that’s hard to resist. A timeless choice for those who appreciate the classics.

16. Red Baron Classic Crust Meat Trio

Red Baron Classic Crust Meat Trio is a celebration of meat-lovers’ dreams. Topped with sausage, pepperoni, and ham, it’s a pizza that embraces the full spectrum of savory flavors. The classic crust provides a firm foundation, offering a satisfying crunch with each bite. It’s a pizza perfect for family gatherings, where sharing is encouraged, but the taste is unforgettable. Each quarter of the pizza packs over 400 calories, making it an indulgence that beckons with its rich, comforting flavors. A familiar choice that delivers consistent satisfaction.

17. California Pizza Kitchen Frozen BBQ Chicken

California Pizza Kitchen’s Frozen BBQ Chicken pizza brings gourmet flair to the frozen section. Featuring BBQ sauce, chicken, and cheese, it’s a flavor-packed pizza that defies the frozen norm. Perfect for those who crave a little sophistication at home, it offers a balance of sweet and savory in each bite. Despite being frozen, it delivers restaurant-quality taste. With slices ranging from 300 to 350 calories, it’s a more refined indulgence that still respects your calorie limits. An elegant option for those seeking a touch of gourmet at home.

18. Roberta’s Bee Sting (Brooklyn, NY)

Roberta’s Bee Sting is a pizza with personality. Featuring spicy salami, mozzarella, and a drizzle of hot honey, it’s a unique combination that intrigues the palate. The balance of heat and sweetness offers an exciting contrast, making each slice a new adventure. It’s a pizza that stands out in the crowded Brooklyn scene, offering something both trendy and delicious. Despite its playful name, it’s a serious calorie contender, with each bite contributing to a higher count. A must-try for those seeking innovative flavors in the heart of Brooklyn.

19. Emmy Squared’s Colony Pie (Various Locations)

Emmy Squared’s Colony Pie is a bold statement in the pizza world. Known for its thick, Detroit-style crust, it’s topped with spicy pepperoni and a sweet honey drizzle that challenges the traditional. Each bite offers a delightful mix of crunch and chew, with flavors that dance between spicy and sweet. It’s a pizza that feels substantial, both in taste and in calories, where each slice feels like a meal in itself. A culinary delight that appeals to those who enjoy pushing the boundaries of flavor.

20. Pizano’s Cheese Pizza (Chicago, IL)

Pizano’s Cheese Pizza combines simplicity with indulgence. Known for its thin crust, this pizza is deceptively heavy with a rich layer of melted cheese that satisfies any cheese lover’s cravings. Despite its appearance, it’s a caloric powerhouse, where one slice easily leads to another. It’s a pizza that tells a story of Chicago’s love affair with cheese, offering a familiar yet indulgent experience. Perfect for those who appreciate the art of traditional pizza making, it’s a classic that never goes out of style.

21. Patsy’s Famous Pie (Harlem, NY)

Patsy’s Famous Pie is a piece of New York history. Known for its thin, coal-fired crust, it delivers a charred flavor that’s quintessentially Harlem. Each slice offers a rich blend of cheese and sauce, capturing a simplicity that’s deeply satisfying. It’s a pizza that doesn’t rely on gimmicks, only quality ingredients and traditional methods. Despite its unassuming appearance, it packs a caloric punch, offering a taste of history with every bite. A timeless piece of New York’s culinary legacy, cherished by locals and visitors alike.

22. Cheeseburger Pizza (Various Chains)

Cheeseburger Pizza is a quirky twist on two American favorites. Featuring toppings like ground beef, cheddar cheese, and even pickles, it brings the essence of a cheeseburger to a pizza crust. This unconventional combination offers a playful nod to creativity in pizza-making, catering to those who enjoy their flavors bold and unexpected. It’s a calorie-dense choice, as each slice tries to capture the essence of a full meal. Perfect for those looking to break the norm and explore new tastes, it’s a fun and hearty indulgence.

23. Buffalo Chicken Pizza (Bar-style or Fast Casual)

Buffalo Chicken Pizza is a game-day favorite that combines the best of bar food into a single slice. Loaded with buffalo sauce, cheese, and chunks of chicken, it offers a spicy, tangy kick that fans love. Each bite is a bold expression of flavor, perfect for those who enjoy their pizza with a bit of heat. Despite its casual appeal, this pizza is a calorie-rich option, often paired with ranch or blue cheese for extra indulgence. Ideal for sharing among friends, it’s both a social and culinary delight.

24. Mac & Cheese Pizza (Seen at state fairs and college towns)

Mac & Cheese Pizza combines comfort food classics into a single, indulgent experience. Topped generously with creamy macaroni and cheese, it’s a pizza that doesn’t shy away from carbs. Often seen at state fairs and college campuses, its appeal lies in its playful nature and rich, comforting flavors. Each slice is a calorie-packed delight that promises satisfaction and nostalgia in equal measure. While it might not be an everyday choice, it’s a fun treat that celebrates the joy of food experimentation. A must-try for those seeking something different and delightful.

25. Breakfast Pizza with Gravy & Eggs

Breakfast Pizza with Gravy & Eggs transforms morning meals into a pizza party. Featuring white gravy, scrambled eggs, and melted cheese, it’s a breakfast lover’s dream come true. Each slice is a rich, savory delight that brings the comfort of breakfast to any time of day. It’s a pizza that doesn’t just satisfy hunger but also offers a warm, inviting experience. The calorie count is significant, as expected from a meal that combines multiple hearty components. An indulgent option for those who want to start their day with a culinary bang.

26. Taco Pizza (Midwest Favorite)

Taco Pizza is a beloved Midwest innovation that merges Mexican flavors with classic pizza. Topped with seasoned beef, shredded cheese, lettuce, and crispy tortilla chips, it offers a taste of fiesta in every bite. Each slice is a delightful crossover that captures the best of both worlds. It’s a pizza that invites fun and creativity, perfect for those who appreciate bold, layered flavors. With its hearty toppings, it’s a calorie-rich option that delights with its unique approach. A regional favorite, it’s a must-have for those exploring Midwestern culinary creativity.

27. BBQ Pulled Pork Pizza

BBQ Pulled Pork Pizza is a southern delight that brings comfort food to new levels. Featuring tender pulled pork, rich barbecue sauce, and melted cheese, it’s a pizza that celebrates bold, savory flavors. Each slice is a hearty embrace, offering a taste of southern hospitality on a crust. It’s perfect for those who enjoy their pizza with a side of smoky goodness. The calorie content is as rich as its flavors, making it a choice for those who prioritize taste over restraint. A true indulgence that’s worth every bite.

28. Triple Cheese Stuffed Crust Pizzas (Various Chains)

Triple Cheese Stuffed Crust Pizzas are a cheese lover’s fantasy come to life. With cheese in the crust, on top, and even under the sauce, it’s a triple threat that satisfies every cheesy craving. Each bite is a rich, creamy delight, perfect for those who can’t get enough cheese. It’s a pizza that doesn’t just deliver on flavor but also on indulgence, with each slice offering a gooey, satisfying experience. The calorie count is predictably high, making it a guilty pleasure that’s hard to resist. Ideal for sharing, but so tempting to savor alone.