20 Iconic Old-School Steakhouses Across America

Here are 20 iconic old-school steakhouses across America that have stood the test of time, earning loyal followings for their prime cuts, classic ambiance, and timeless charm. Whether you’re after a dry-aged porterhouse or tableside Caesar salad, these restaurants deliver the kind of steakhouse experience that never goes out of style.

1. Peter Luger Steak House – Brooklyn, NY

Peter Luger Steak House, established in 1887, is a Brooklyn legend. Known for its no-frills approach, this steakhouse serves dry-aged porterhouse steaks that draw crowds from all over. The cash-only policy adds to its old-school charm. Inside, the wood-paneled walls and vintage photographs create a nostalgic atmosphere, making it a beloved New York City institution. The waiters, in their crisp uniforms, swift and efficient, add to the seamless experience. A visit here feels like stepping back in time, where the focus is solely on delivering the perfect steak. Many cherish it as a must-visit landmark for any steak enthusiast.

2. Bern’s Steak House – Tampa, FL

Bern’s Steak House, a Tampa treasure since 1956, captivates with its encyclopedic wine list and massive portions. The vintage dessert room is a unique feature, allowing diners to indulge in an array of sweet delights. Known for its meticulous attention to detail, Bern’s offers a memorable dining experience. The ambiance, with its rich wooden decor and elegant lighting, exudes sophistication. The staff’s expertise in guiding guests through the wine selection is unparalleled. Whether you’re a steak lover or a dessert aficionado, Bern’s promises a feast for the senses, making it a must-experience destination.

3. St. Elmo Steak House – Indianapolis, IN

St. Elmo Steak House, since 1902, stands as an Indianapolis icon. Renowned for its famously fiery shrimp cocktail, this steakhouse offers hearty Midwestern steaks that satisfy the soul. The historic facade, with its iconic signage, draws diners into an atmosphere where tradition reigns. Inside, the bustling dining room is alive with chatter and the clinking of silverware. The service is warm and welcoming, embracing guests like family. It’s the kind of place where memories are made, with each meal becoming a part of its storied legacy. A true staple in the heart of Indiana.

4. Keens Steakhouse – New York, NY

Keens Steakhouse, operating since 1885, is a New York classic with a twist. Famous for its mutton chop, it offers a unique dining experience amidst ceilings adorned with clay pipes once owned by historical figures like Teddy Roosevelt. The vintage decor, with its dim lighting and classic dining setup, creates an inviting ambiance. The staff, well-versed in the steakhouse’s rich history, add depth to your visit. A blend of the past and present, Keens delivers not just a meal, but a journey through time. It’s an experience every steak lover should savor.

5. Jess & Jim’s Steak House – Kansas City, MO

Jess & Jim’s Steak House, a Kansas City staple since 1938, continues to wow patrons with its sizzling sirloins. Praised by Playboy, this steakhouse embodies Midwestern charm. The classic facade welcomes diners into a setting where tradition and quality meet. Inside, the atmosphere is warm, filled with laughter and the aroma of perfectly cooked steaks. The staff, friendly and attentive, ensure a delightful dining experience for all. Jess & Jim’s is not just about steak; it’s about preserving a legacy of culinary excellence that resonates with each visitor.

6. Gibson’s Bar & Steakhouse – Chicago, IL

Gibson’s Bar & Steakhouse, since 1989, brings a touch of old-school flair to Chicago’s dining scene. Known for its big steaks and bold sides, it has become a go-to for meat lovers. The bustling interior, filled with a vibrant crowd, exudes energy and excitement. Each table is elegantly set, promising an upscale dining experience. The staff, professional and knowledgeable, guide you through a menu brimming with classic steakhouse favorites. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a night out, Gibson’s delivers with style and substance.

7. House of Prime Rib – San Francisco, CA

The House of Prime Rib, established in 1949, is a San Francisco classic focused on one thing: serving the perfect prime rib. Carved tableside with traditional accompaniments, this meal is an experience. The dining room, with its cozy ambiance and attentive service, feels like a step back in time. Each visit is a celebration of culinary tradition, highlighted by the rich flavors of perfectly cooked beef. The staff, courteous and efficient, enhance the experience, ensuring that guests leave satisfied. It’s a must-visit for anyone seeking the timeless joy of a great steak dinner.

8. Murray’s – Minneapolis, MN

Murray’s, the “Home of the Silver Butter Knife Steak,” has been a Minneapolis favorite since 1946. Known for its old-school service, this steakhouse offers generous cuts that delight the senses. The Art Deco dining room, with its elegant setting, creates an ambiance of sophistication. Each steak is a testament to Murray’s commitment to quality and tradition. The staff, polished and attentive, ensure a seamless dining experience. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, a meal at Murray’s is a chance to indulge in a piece of Minnesota’s culinary history.

9. Gene & Georgetti – Chicago, IL

Gene & Georgetti, Chicago’s oldest steakhouse, has been serving serious steaks since 1941. The classic interior, with white tablecloths and Sinatra tunes, sets the stage for a memorable meal. Known for its warm service and hearty portions, this steakhouse remains a beloved institution. The staff, with their personal touch, make you feel like part of the family. Each visit is a journey into the past, where the focus is on quality and hospitality. Gene & Georgetti is not just a restaurant; it’s a piece of Chicago’s vibrant history.

10. Taylor’s Steakhouse – Los Angeles, CA

Taylor’s Steakhouse, a hidden gem in Koreatown, Los Angeles, has been delighting diners since 1953. Known for its classic steaks and cocktails, this vintage spot offers a unique dining experience. The decor, with its retro charm, transports guests to a bygone era. The intimate atmosphere, paired with the attentive service, makes each meal special. Whether you’re enjoying a perfectly cooked steak or a classic cocktail at the bar, Taylor’s provides a taste of nostalgia. It’s a place where the past and present coexist, inviting you to savor the moment.

11. The Pine Club – Dayton, OH

The Pine Club, a Dayton institution since 1947, is famous for its no-reservations policy and perfectly grilled filets. This classic steakhouse welcomes diners into a bustling dining room, where the focus is on delivering exceptional steak. The facade, with its timeless charm, invites you into a world where quality reigns. Inside, the friendly staff make you feel at home, ensuring a memorable experience. Each steak, cooked to perfection, embodies the Pine Club’s dedication to excellence. It’s a must-visit for anyone seeking a true taste of Ohio’s culinary tradition.

12. Doe’s Eat Place – Greenville, MS

Doe’s Eat Place, a down-home joint in Greenville, Mississippi, has been serving giant steaks since 1941. Known for its unassuming setting, this steakhouse has welcomed presidents and celebrities alike. The rustic interior, with its casual charm, creates a relaxed dining atmosphere. Each steak, cooked to perfection, is a testament to Doe’s commitment to quality. The staff, friendly and laid-back, enhance the dining experience, making you feel like part of the family. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Doe’s offers a taste of Southern hospitality at its best.

13. Ruth’s Chris Steak House – New Orleans, LA

Ruth’s Chris Steak House, now a national chain, started in New Orleans in 1965. The original location remains a must-visit for sizzling butter-topped steaks. The elegant dining room, with its warm lighting, creates an inviting atmosphere. Each steak, cooked to perfection, is enhanced by the signature sizzling butter. The staff, attentive and knowledgeable, guide you through a menu filled with classic steakhouse delights. Whether you’re a steak aficionado or a first-timer, Ruth’s Chris promises a dining experience that captivates the senses.

14. Sparks Steak House – New York, NY

Sparks Steak House, operating in New York since 1966, is notorious for its mob ties and celebrated for its huge sirloins. The elegant setting, with its historic charm, offers a dining experience that’s both sophisticated and intriguing. Each steak, grilled to perfection, is a culinary delight. The staff, with their impeccable service, add to the overall experience, ensuring a memorable visit. Whether you’re drawn by its history or its steaks, Sparks remains a must-visit for anyone exploring New York’s culinary scene.

15. Golden Steer – Las Vegas, NV

Golden Steer, a Las Vegas legend since 1958, was once a favorite of the Rat Pack. Known for its tableside Caesar salad and aged prime beef, it offers a vintage Vegas experience. The decor, reminiscent of old Vegas glamour, creates an ambiance of nostalgia. The staff, with their polished service, ensure a memorable dining experience. Each visit to Golden Steer is a journey into the past, where the spirit of Vegas’s golden era still thrives. It’s a must-stop for anyone seeking a taste of classic Las Vegas.

16. Galatoire’s – New Orleans, LA

Galatoire’s, more than a steakhouse, has been a New Orleans staple since 1905. While known for its French Creole cuisine, its filet mignon earns it a spot here. The elegant dining atmosphere, with its classic charm, offers a unique culinary experience. Each dish, prepared with care, showcases the rich flavors of Creole tradition. The staff, attentive and personable, ensure a dining experience that delights the senses. Whether you’re exploring its Creole dishes or savoring a steak, Galatoire’s promises a meal to remember.

17. Elway’s – Denver, CO

Elway’s, though newer, opened in Denver in 2004 with a throwback vibe. Founded by football legend John Elway, it offers serious steak credibility. The modern decor, infused with old-school flair, creates an inviting atmosphere. Each steak, cooked to perfection, reflects Elway’s commitment to quality. The staff, knowledgeable and friendly, enhance the overall dining experience. Whether you’re a sports fan or a steak lover, Elway’s offers a unique blend of history and contemporary dining. It’s a place where tradition meets modernity, satisfying both the palate and the spirit.

18. Buckhorn Exchange – Denver, CO

Buckhorn Exchange, Colorado’s oldest restaurant since 1893, offers a unique dining experience. Known for steak and wild game, the taxidermy-filled dining room adds a rustic charm. Each visit feels like a journey into the past, where culinary adventure awaits. The staff, friendly and knowledgeable, ensure a memorable experience. Whether you’re indulging in a perfectly grilled steak or exploring exotic game, Buckhorn Exchange promises a taste of Colorado’s wild spirit. It’s more than just a meal; it’s an experience that connects you to the region’s rich history and vibrant culture.

19. Barclay Prime – Philadelphia, PA

Barclay Prime, established in 2004, offers a modern decor with classic sensibility in Philadelphia. Known for its luxe spin on traditional steakhouse fare, it includes a $140 cheesesteak. The ambiance, chic and sophisticated, invites diners to indulge in a unique culinary experience. Each dish, crafted with precision, showcases the restaurant’s commitment to excellence. The staff, polished and professional, guide you through a menu filled with gourmet delights. Whether you’re savoring a steak or the infamous cheesesteak, Barclay Prime delivers a taste of opulence.

20. Cattlemen’s Steakhouse – Oklahoma City, OK

Cattlemen’s Steakhouse, originally opened in 1910 to feed cowboys and cattlemen, continues to grill steaks to perfection. The historic entrance, with its cowboy-themed decor, invites you into a world where tradition and quality meet. Inside, the atmosphere is warm and welcoming, filled with the aroma of perfectly cooked steaks. Each visit is a celebration of Oklahoma’s rich heritage, where culinary excellence shines. The staff, friendly and attentive, ensure a seamless dining experience. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Cattlemen’s promises a taste of timeless charm.