20 Cookie Dough Ice Creams Ranked From Average To Amazing

Cookie dough ice cream is a beloved treat, combining the creamy delight of ice cream with the nostalgic joy of cookie dough. In this blog, we rank 20 different cookie dough ice creams from average to amazing. Whether you’re a fan of low-calorie alternatives or indulgent treats, there’s something for everyone. We’ll explore unique flavors, textures, and brands to help you discover the ultimate cookie dough ice cream experience.

1. Halo Top Cookie Dough

Halo Top tries to cater to the health-conscious crowd with its Cookie Dough flavor, but it falls short in delivering bold tastes. The ice cream is notably low in calories, which unfortunately translates to a lack of rich flavor. The texture leans icy rather than creamy, and the dough chunks are sparse and small. It’s like a whispered promise of cookie dough rather than a full conversation. Unless you’re on a strict calorie count, you might find more satisfaction elsewhere. Still, its sleek packaging and guilt-free promise might appeal to some.

2. Breyers Delights Cookie Dough

Breyers Delights aims for a “better for you” angle but misses the mark in flavor impact. The ice cream feels more like a cloud of vanilla, with only a faint whisper of cookie dough. Its lightness might be refreshing on a hot day, but it leaves a lot to be desired in terms of indulgence. The texture is airy, bordering on insubstantial, which might leave traditional ice cream lovers unsatisfied. Still, its promise of lower calories might attract those watching their intake. A pleasant companion for a diet-friendly dessert, but not a standout.

3. So Delicious Dairy-Free Cookie Dough

So Delicious offers a plant-based alternative with its Dairy-Free Cookie Dough, but the experience can be hit or miss. While it scores points for catering to dairy-free diets, the texture is slightly off, lacking the creaminess many crave. The cookie dough pieces are sparse, and the chewiness you might expect is somewhat missing. For those avoiding dairy, it’s a decent choice, but it might not fully satisfy those nostalgic for the classic combination. Its subtle flavors and unique base could appeal to the adventurous, though. A niche delight rather than a mainstream hit.

4. Oatly Cookie Dough (Non-Dairy)

Oatly’s Cookie Dough ice cream presents a creamy oat base, offering something different for non-dairy enthusiasts. While it delivers a pleasant texture and a distinct oat flavor, the cookie dough pieces are few and far between. For those who enjoy the natural taste of oats, this ice cream might hit the spot, but it may not meet the expectations of those craving a rich cookie dough experience. It’s a decent offering in the non-dairy market, providing an alternative for those exploring new taste horizons. Some might find it surprisingly delightful, others merely adequate.

5. Great Value Cookie Dough (Walmart)

Great Value, Walmart’s in-house brand, delivers a surprisingly decent cookie dough ice cream for its price point. You get what you pay for: a basic yet enjoyable treat that doesn’t break the bank. The ice cream is sweet and pleasant, though not particularly rich, and the cookie dough pieces are small and infrequent. It’s a choice that satisfies when budget constraints are a priority. For an affordable indulgence, it offers a satisfying sweet treat that could be a staple in any frugal shopper’s freezer. A frugal choice for casual indulgence.

6. Edy’s / Dreyer’s Cookie Dough

Edy’s, also known as Dreyer’s in some regions, offers a middle-of-the-road cookie dough ice cream. The flavor profile is sweet and mild, making it accessible to a wide audience. Its texture is soft, lacking the rich creaminess of some premium options, but it remains a reliable choice for general enjoyment. The dough pieces blend well into the ice cream, though they don’t particularly stand out. It’s a crowd-pleaser, suitable for family gatherings or casual desserts, but it might not leave a lasting impression. Consistent and comforting, it plays it safe.

7. Kroger Deluxe Cookie Dough

Kroger’s Deluxe Cookie Dough ice cream is an affordable and pleasant option for those seeking a straightforward treat. It doesn’t claim to break new ground, but it delivers the basics well. The ice cream is creamy enough, with a decent amount of cookie dough mix-ins that provide the expected chewy bits. It’s the kind of ice cream you might find at a weekend family gathering, offering a good balance of taste and texture without any surprises. A solid choice for those who appreciate quality without the premium price tag. Understated but enjoyable.

8. Baskin-Robbins Cookie Dough

Baskin-Robbins brings a classic take on cookie dough ice cream, with solid chunks and a creamy texture. While it might not stand out amongst the more adventurous flavors, it remains a reliable favorite. Its nostalgic taste and satisfying texture make it a go-to for those who appreciate tradition over trend. The dough pieces are generous, providing a pleasant contrast to the smooth ice cream. It’s a taste of childhood, served in vibrant scoops that evoke memories of simpler times. Ideal for those who cherish the classics without needing a gourmet twist.

9. Tillamook Cookie Dough

Tillamook offers a rich and creamy cookie dough ice cream that leans on its milky roots. Known for its high-quality dairy, Tillamook doesn’t disappoint with a smooth texture and subtle, sweet flavor. The cookie dough chunks are well-dispersed, though a bit lighter than some might hope. It’s a reliable choice, blending its farm-fresh reputation with a comforting taste. This ice cream is for those who value quality ingredients and consistency, ideal for a quiet evening treat. It’s not extravagant, but it satisfies those who appreciate simple pleasures.

10. Haagen-Dazs Cookie Dough

Haagen-Dazs brings its signature velvety texture to its Cookie Dough flavor, offering a refined ice cream experience. The base is smooth and indulgent, with an elegant flavor profile that sets it apart. While some might wish for larger, bolder cookie dough chunks, the existing pieces are delicately balanced within the creamy base. It caters to those who prefer a sophisticated approach to a classic flavor, making it a delightful choice for special occasions. Its premium quality is reflected in every bite, appealing to those with a taste for the finer things.

11. Blue Bell Cookie Dough

Blue Bell offers its Cookie Dough ice cream with a creamy southern-style base, providing a satisfying treat for the sweet-toothed. Renowned for its rich and flavorful ice creams, Blue Bell doesn’t hold back on the generosity of its dough-to-ice cream ratio. Each bite is a delightful combination of smooth cream and chewy dough, appealing to those who love a sweeter touch. It’s a comforting choice, ideal for those who appreciate a classic yet indulgent flavor. Perfect for a sunny day or a cozy evening at home, it satisfies deeply.

12. Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough (Non-Dairy)

Ben & Jerry’s Non-Dairy Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough is a surprisingly excellent choice for those seeking dairy-free indulgence. Using a creamy almond base, it captures the essence of Ben & Jerry’s beloved doughy goodness. The plant-based approach doesn’t compromise on taste, making it a standout in the non-dairy segment. Dough pieces are plentiful and satisfying, delivering what fans expect from the iconic brand. It’s a treat for those who are dairy-adverse but unwilling to sacrifice flavor. An inclusive option that resonates with both plant-based and traditional ice cream lovers.

13. Jeni’s Splendid Cookie Dough

Jeni’s Splendid Cookie Dough ice cream exudes an upscale feel, with buttery dough pieces and high-quality ingredients. Known for its artisanal approach, Jeni’s delivers a premium experience at a slightly higher price point. The texture is creamy, and the flavors are carefully crafted, appealing to gourmet palates. While it may be too pricey for everyday indulgence, it’s a delightful choice for special moments. It stands out for those who appreciate the finer details and are willing to pay for quality. Each scoop is a testament to thoughtful craftsmanship.

14. Alden’s Organic Cookie Dough

Alden’s Organic Cookie Dough ice cream caters to those who prioritize organic ingredients without sacrificing flavor. It offers a clean-tasting base, with big, satisfying dough bites. The organic label appeals to those conscious of their consumption, blending quality with peace of mind. The ice cream is creamy and fulfilling, providing a good balance of taste and ethics. It’s a reliable pick for those seeking a natural option, offering both indulgence and integrity. A choice that aligns with eco-friendly values while delivering on taste expectations.

15. Trader Joe’s Cookie Dough Ice Cream

Trader Joe’s Cookie Dough Ice cream might be underrated, but it delivers an impressive treat. Known for its bold flavors and thick, rich texture, it doesn’t skimp on the cookie dough chunks. The combination of creamy ice cream and daring dough pieces creates a satisfying experience. It’s a hidden gem within the Trader Joe’s lineup, offering a flavor that stands out in the store’s diverse selection. Ideal for those who enjoy a surprise hit, it turns a simple dessert into something memorable. A top pick for adventurous dessert seekers.

16. Ben & Jerry’s Half Baked

Ben & Jerry’s Half Baked is a flavor bomb, combining half brownie, half cookie dough — all indulgence. Known for its over-the-top approach, it offers a gooey, rich experience that satisfies deeply. The mix of brownie and cookie dough chunks provides a dual delight, appealing to fans of both treats. It’s indulgent, pushing the boundaries of traditional flavor combinations in the best way possible. Perfect for those with a sweet tooth and a love for creative concoctions, it’s a standout in the Ben & Jerry’s lineup. A treat worth savoring.

17. Häagen-Dazs Cookie Dough Core

Häagen-Dazs Cookie Dough Core is built around a gooey core of cookie dough, catering to true dough lovers. This innovation transforms the classic flavor into a more immersive experience, offering rich and satisfying bites. The core is surrounded by Häagen-Dazs’ signature creamy ice cream, blending elegance with indulgence. It’s a must-try for those who appreciate both taste and texture, providing a delightful adventure in every scoop. Designed for those unafraid to embrace decadence, it’s an irresistible option for special occasions. A masterful creation in the ice cream realm.

18. Van Leeuwen Cookie Dough Chunk

Van Leeuwen’s Cookie Dough Chunk ice cream is a purist’s delight, featuring a French-style base with massive dough pieces. Known for its deep vanilla flavor and premium approach, it stands out as a luxurious choice. Each scoop is crafted with care, offering a rich and satisfying experience that’s worth the price. It appeals to those who value quality over quantity, providing a refined indulgence. Ideal for special occasions or a personal treat, it’s a testament to thoughtful ice cream making. A gourmet choice for discerning palates seeking something extraordinary.

19. Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough (Original)

Ben & Jerry’s Original Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough stands strong as a beloved classic. With a smooth base and abundant dough pieces, it captures the nostalgic flavor fans have adored for years. It’s a crowd favorite, appealing to both the young and the young at heart, offering a comforting taste of familiarity. Each scoop is packed with chewy dough, providing a delightful contrast to the creamy ice cream. It’s a staple in the Ben & Jerry’s lineup, known for its consistent goodness and happy memories. Timeless and always satisfying.

20. Milk Bar Cookie Dough Ice Cream

Milk Bar’s Cookie Dough Ice Cream is an experience of richness, featuring gobs of brown sugary, salty-sweet cookie dough. It takes the concept of indulgence to new heights, turning the familiar into something extraordinary. Each bite is packed with flavor, offering a delightful blend of textures and tastes that excite the palate. It’s a definitive favorite for those who crave boldness, providing a sweet adventure with every scoop. The ice cream is as playful as it is decadent, making it a must-try for true cookie dough enthusiasts. A top-tier treat.