18 Frozen Pepperoni Pizzas, Ranked From Worst To Best

Here’s a ranked list of 18 popular frozen pepperoni pizzas, from worst to best, based on taste, crust texture, cheese quality, pepperoni flavor, and overall satisfaction. While everyone’s preferences vary, this list offers a general guide to which brands deliver the most satisfying frozen slice—and which might be better left in the freezer aisle.

1. Tony’s Pepperoni Pizza

Tony’s Pepperoni Pizza is easy on the wallet but doesn’t quite deliver on flavor. You’ll notice the crust is overly doughy, reminiscent of bread, rather than the crisp bite that pizza lovers might expect. Pepperoni slices are sparse, lacking the spicy punch many seek in a slice. Despite its affordability, the overall taste might leave you wanting.

For those who prioritize cost over quality, it serves as a quick fix but doesn’t promise a memorable meal. Its simplicity might appeal to those with unadventurous taste buds, preferring gentle flavors over bold zest.

2. Totino’s Party Pizza: Pepperoni

Totino’s Party Pizza brings back childhood memories, but it’s more of a nostalgic snack than a culinary delight. The crust is super thin, similar to a cracker, and the overall texture is quite greasy. Pepperoni pieces are mini and scattered, delivering a taste that’s unmistakably artificial.

If you’re looking for a quick, crispy bite that won’t break the bank, this pizza might do the trick. It’s a fun, retro choice for those who want to reminisce about simpler times, despite not being a gourmet option by any means.

3. Mama Cozzi’s (ALDI brand)

Mama Cozzi’s offers affordability but falls short on consistency. The crust can often seem cardboard-like, leaving a dry taste with every bite. Pepperoni slices taste overly processed, missing the spicy, savory richness many expect.

Although it’s a budget-friendly option, the lack of flavor depth might not satisfy those seeking genuine pizzeria quality at home. This pizza is better suited for days when convenience trumps culinary adventure, appealing to those who value simplicity and cost-effectiveness.

4. Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni Pizza

Red Baron has been a household name for years, but the Classic Crust Pepperoni Pizza might divide opinions. The crust has a welcoming crispness that contrasts with the overly sweet tomato sauce, causing a flavor clash. Pepperoni slices are plentiful but tend to be chewy, lacking a spicy kick.

For those who enjoy a sweeter sauce, this can be a comforting classic. Yet, if spice and balanced flavors are what you’re after, it might not be your go-to choice. It’s a nostalgic bite with a twist that not everyone appreciates.

5. Great Value Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza (Walmart)

Great Value’s Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza offers a hearty crust with impressive rise, but it falls short in delivering a pepperoni-filled experience. The crust is pillowy, offering a nice chew, yet the sparse pepperoni and subdued flavor profile might leave you wanting more zest.

Perfect for those who enjoy a bread-heavy slice, this pizza caters to individuals who prioritize crust over toppings. It’s a reliable option for a filling meal, although it could benefit from a more generous hand with the pepperoni.

6. California Pizza Kitchen Thin Crust Pepperoni

California Pizza Kitchen’s Thin Crust Pepperoni aims for elegance with its crispy thin crust. The cheese quality is commendable, but the toppings are somewhat scant, leaving a faint impression on your taste buds. It’s an underwhelming choice in size and value, especially for those craving a hearty slice.

Best suited for those who prefer a light pizza experience, this option stands out for its refined simplicity. It’s ideal for enjoying a delicate balance of textures, without the guilt of overindulgence. A sophisticated choice for a moderate appetite.

7. DiGiorno Crispy Pan Pepperoni Pizza

DiGiorno’s Crispy Pan Pepperoni Pizza delights with its golden crust that delivers a satisfying crunch. Although some might find the pan crust heavy, its texture is appealing. The sauce, however, veers toward the sweeter side, which may not be everyone’s cup of tea.

This pizza is perfect for those who enjoy a substantial, textured bite. While the sweetness of the sauce might not suit all palates, it offers an interesting contrast that some find intriguing. It’s a hearty choice for a filling and crunchy meal.

8. Amy’s Uncured Pepperoni Pizza

Amy’s Uncured Pepperoni Pizza is a nod to organic ingredients and real flavor, but its size and price might deter some. The crust is thin and crispy, while the pepperoni delivers an authentic, savory taste that stands apart from more processed competitors.

This pizza is ideal for those who prioritize quality over quantity. Despite its smaller size, the flavors are bold and satisfying. A great choice for a thoughtful meal when you want to treat yourself to something genuine and delicious.

9. Freschetta Naturally Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza

Freschetta’s Naturally Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza wins points for its pillowy, soft crust that complements the melted cheese perfectly. However, some may find it a tad greasy, and the pepperoni distribution could be more generous.

Ideal for family meals, this pizza caters to those who value a soft, bread-like texture in every bite. It’s a satisfying option for a cozy dinner, though it might not top the charts in the pepperoni department. A solid choice for a dependable and flavorful family meal.

10. Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Pepperoni

Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Pepperoni Pizza is appreciated for its solid flavor and light crust. The use of natural ingredients shines through, presenting a less greasy bite. It’s a refreshing change from heavier pizzas.

This option is perfect for those who prefer a clean, straightforward taste without excessive oiliness. It serves as a great choice for health-conscious individuals who still crave a slice of indulgence. A commendable balance of ingredients makes it a delightful, guilt-free treat.

11. Jack’s Pepperoni Pizza

Jack’s Pepperoni Pizza doesn’t boast bells and whistles but surprises with its crispy texture and decent flavor for the price. The pepperoni is adequately distributed, and the cheese melts well, creating a harmonious blend of simplicity.

For those who seek an uncomplicated, reliable option, this pizza fits the bill. It’s a no-nonsense choice that delivers on expectations without breaking the bank. Perfect for any casual gathering or simple night in, it’s a trusted standby that doesn’t disappoint.

12. Tombstone Original Pepperoni

Tombstone’s Original Pepperoni Pizza is a staple in the frozen aisle, offering a balanced combination of sauce, crust, and pepperoni spice. The crust is firm yet forgiving, and the sauce provides a flavorful base, complemented by the well-seasoned pepperoni.

This pizza is great for those who appreciate a classic taste with a nostalgic feel. It’s perfect for a regular pizza night, delivering consistent satisfaction with every bite. A trusted choice for families and pizza lovers alike who enjoy a timeless flavor profile.

13. Screamin’ Sicilian Bessie’s Revenge Pepperoni

Screamin’ Sicilian’s Bessie’s Revenge is a meat lover’s dream, loaded with thick-cut pepperoni and real mozzarella. The generous toppings create a meaty, satisfying experience that stands out in the frozen pizza scene.

For those who crave hearty, bold flavors, this pizza delivers in spades. The combination of savory pepperoni and rich cheese makes it a standout option for indulgent pizza nights. A robust option that promises to satisfy even the most discerning meat enthusiasts.

14. DiGiorno Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza

DiGiorno’s Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza is celebrated for its fluffy, delivery-like crust. The generous cheese and evenly baked texture create a comforting eating experience that imitates a freshly delivered pizza.

Perfect for those who enjoy a pizzeria feel at home, this pizza is satisfying and filling without needing takeout. A go-to choice for those who want a bit of everything in their pizza: taste, texture, and a hint of nostalgia.

15. Trader Joe’s Uncured Pepperoni Pizza

Trader Joe’s Uncured Pepperoni Pizza stands out with its bold pepperoni flavor and thin, crisp crust. It focuses on simple, high-quality ingredients that create a powerful taste experience.

Ideal for those who love a punchy pepperoni taste without unnecessary extras, this pizza shines in its simplicity. A great choice for casual gatherings or solo indulgence, it proves that sometimes less is truly more.

16. Target’s Good & Gather Wood-Fired Pepperoni Pizza

Target’s Good & Gather Wood-Fired Pepperoni Pizza offers an artisan-style experience unexpected from a frozen option. The smoky crust and quality toppings give it an edge that’s a delight to discover.

This pizza is perfect for those seeking a gourmet touch in their frozen food. Its distinctive wood-fired flavor adds a unique twist that elevates any meal. A hidden gem that surprises with its quality and taste, offering an impressive alternative to traditional frozen pizzas.

17. Wild Mike’s Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza

Wild Mike’s Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza is big and bold, packed with flavor. The excellent pepperoni, real cheese, and spicy sauce create a combination that stands out among competitors.

For those who seek a flavor-packed punch in every bite, this pizza is a must-try. Its spicy and savory profile will satisfy those who love a little heat in their meals. An ultimate choice for adventurous eaters who enjoy bold tastes and hearty flavors.

18. Motor City Pizza Co. Double Pepperoni (Detroit-Style)

Motor City Pizza Co.’s Double Pepperoni is the epitome of frozen pizza perfection. The thick, crispy-edged crust with caramelized cheese and zesty sauce creates an unforgettable experience.

Ideal for those who appreciate a hearty, filling meal, this Detroit-style pizza delivers on all fronts. With its abundance of pepperoni and unique crust texture, it’s a top choice for anyone wanting to experience a slice of frozen pizza excellence. A must-have for any pizza enthusiast’s freezer.