18 Forgotten Grocery Items Boomers Wish Were Still Around

Not all nostalgia lives in photo albums—some of it was wrapped in plastic, boxed with bold fonts, or popped open with a satisfying “thwack.” If you grew up in the mid-20th century, chances are you remember a few of these discontinued grocery staples. From oddball snacks to beloved pantry must-haves, here are 18 forgotten grocery items Boomers still miss—and wish they could toss in the cart one more time.

1. Jell-O 1-2-3

Remember the magic of Jell-O 1-2-3? This unique dessert separated into three layers as it chilled. The bottom was classic gelatin, the middle a fluffy mousse, and the top a creamy delight. It was a staple in many households during the ’60s and ’70s. A simple box and some water turned into a culinary marvel. It wasn’t just a treat; it was an experience, a science experiment in your fridge. Sadly, it disappeared in the ’90s, leaving behind fond memories.

2. Morton’s Pot Pies (Original Recipe)

The original Morton’s Pot Pies were something special. With a flaky crust and rich filling, they were the ultimate comfort food. Unlike today’s versions, these pies were packed with flavor, making them a dinner favorite. Perfectly balanced between crust and filling, each bite was a taste of nostalgia. Generations grew up with these pies, a quick meal that felt homemade. While modern versions exist, nothing quite matches the original recipe, cherished by many for its unique taste.

3. Nabisco Swiss Cheese Crackers

Crunchy, salty, and distinctly cheesy, Nabisco Swiss Cheese Crackers were a sensation. Their unique hole-punched design made them stand out. These crackers were a lunchbox staple, a perfect pairing for soups and salads or just as a snack. Cheese lovers adored them for their bold flavor, reminiscent of a real Swiss cheese experience. Although they vanished from shelves, their memory lingers on, a testament to the simple pleasures of snacking from another era.

4. Libby’s Fruit Float

Libby’s Fruit Float was a dessert that defied categorization. It combined gelatin and fruit with a creamy top layer, creating a delightful treat. This whipped, jiggly hybrid seemed almost magical in its construction. A favorite for those who enjoyed a little culinary adventure, it was both refreshing and rich. Its unique texture and flavors were odd yet satisfying, making it a beloved choice at gatherings. A sweet memory for those who dared to indulge.

5. Betty Crocker Shake-a-Pudding

Imagine a pudding you could shake into existence! Betty Crocker Shake-a-Pudding offered just that. With a simple box and some milk, you created a thick, creamy dessert without cooking. It was fun, engaging, and a bit of an arm workout. Children especially loved the novelty of shaking their own dessert. Its playful nature made it a hit, turning a simple treat into an event. While it’s no longer available, the joy it brought remains unforgettable.

6. Burry’s Fudgetown Cookies

Fudgy-filled and fabulous, Burry’s Fudgetown Cookies were a true delight. These shortbread sandwich cookies, with their rich chocolate center, were a staple in cookie jars. Their unique texture and chocolatey goodness made them irresistible. Loved by children and adults alike, they were perfect for any occasion. Though they’ve long been discontinued, their legacy lives on in the memories of those lucky enough to have tasted their chocolaty charm.

7. Franco-American Macaroni and Cheese

Before Kraft’s reign, Franco-American Macaroni and Cheese held a special place in many homes. This canned delight had a unique, tangy flavor that set it apart. It was quick, delicious, and a go-to meal for busy families. Its creamy texture and cheesy goodness made it a favorite among mac and cheese aficionados. Though it disappeared from shelves, its distinctive taste still garners fond memories from those who enjoyed its comforting embrace.

8. Hostess Chocodiles (Original Recipe)

The original Hostess Chocodiles were legendary. A chocolate-covered delight with a creamy center, they were a cousin to the famous Twinkie. Their rich taste and indulgent texture made them a much-loved snack. Though they’ve made a comeback, many say the original recipe was unmatched. The blend of chocolate and cream created a treat that was pure joy, a sweet escape that still lingers in the hearts of many snack lovers.

9. Dannon Sprinkl’ins Yogurt

Dannon Sprinkl’ins Yogurt was where fun met flavor. With candy sprinkles included in the lid, it transformed yogurt into an exciting treat. Not the healthiest option, but certainly one of the most entertaining. Kids loved the combination of creamy yogurt and crunchy sprinkles, a sensory delight. It was an innovative twist on a traditional snack, making it a household favorite. Though it’s a thing of the past, its playful allure still charms those who remember.

10. Kellogg’s Danish Go-Rounds

Before Pop-Tarts dominated, Kellogg’s Danish Go-Rounds were the breakfast pastry to beat. Rolled and glazed, these fruit-filled delights were less messy but full of flavor. They provided a sweet start to the day, loved by children and adults alike. Their convenient design and delicious taste made them a morning favorite. Though they’ve disappeared from shelves, their nostalgic appeal remains, a reminder of simpler breakfast times.

11. Space Food Sticks

Space Food Sticks brought a touch of the cosmos into everyday snacking. Marketed as astronaut snacks, these chewy bars came in flavors like chocolate and peanut butter. They were part science, part sugar rush, appealing to the adventurous. Kids imagined themselves as astronauts with each bite. Though they’re no longer a grocery staple, their unique concept and nostalgic charm endure, reminding us of a time when space was the final frontier.

12. Nabisco Ideal Bars

Nabisco Ideal Bars were a peanut butter lover’s dream. Covered in chocolate, these bars offered a perfect blend of sweet and savory. They competed with Reese’s but had their own loyal following. Their rich taste and satisfying texture made them a favorite treat. Though they disappeared in the ’90s, their legacy lives on in the hearts of those who enjoyed their peanut buttery excellence. A snack of pure nostalgia.

13. Quaker Corn Bran Cereal

Quaker Corn Bran Cereal was a breakfast staple for those who loved a crunch. Mildly sweet and strangely addictive, it was a unique choice. Its simple ingredients and satisfying texture made it a favorite. Although quietly discontinued, fans still petition for its return. It remains a beloved memory for those who enjoyed its distinct taste, a cereal that transcended the ordinary breakfast experience.

14. Carnation Breakfast Bars

Carnation Breakfast Bars were more than just a meal; they were an adventure. Chewy and chocolatey, they packed ’80s breakfast energy in every bite. More candy bar than health food, they made mornings exciting. They were quick, convenient, and full of flavor, loved by those who preferred a sweet start. Though they’ve vanished, their charm and energy remain vivid, a testament to a time when breakfast was bold and unapologetically sweet.

15. Campbell’s Pepper Pot Soup

Campbell’s Pepper Pot Soup was a spicy staple. Made with tripe, it was popular among Boomers. Its peppery kick and unique ingredients made it stand out in the soup aisle. Though a hard sell to younger generations, it held a cherished place in many homes. Discontinued after over a century, its bold flavor and distinctive recipe remain a fond memory for those who grew up with its hearty warmth.

16. Kraft Chicken Noodle Dinner

Kraft Chicken Noodle Dinner was a childhood favorite for many. A box meal with dried noodles and chicken bits, it was quick and easy. Though it sounds sketchy now, kids in the ‘70s loved it. It provided a comforting meal with minimal effort, a staple for busy families. While it’s no longer available, its simple taste and convenience are remembered fondly, a nostalgic nod to quick and satisfying dinners.

17. Pudding Roll-Ups

Pudding Roll-Ups were a sweet sensation. Like Fruit Roll-Ups but made of pudding, they were sticky and short-lived. Their unique texture and flavor captivated those who tried them. Though not around for long, they left a lasting impression with their novelty. A fun and quirky treat, they remain a fond memory for those who experienced their brief but memorable presence in the snack world.

18. Tato Skins Chips (Keebler)

Tato Skins Chips by Keebler were a cult favorite. Made with real potato skin flavor, they offered a unique snacking experience. Their crunchy texture and distinct taste made them popular in the chip aisle. Although they vanished in the early 2000s, snack fans still mourn their loss. Their authentic flavor and nostalgic appeal made them a memorable part of snacking history, cherished by those who enjoyed their crispy charm.