18 Church Cookbook Desserts Nobody’s Making Anymore (But Should Be)
Remember those spiral-bound church cookbooks filled with recipes handwritten in loopy cursive, passed around potlucks, bake sales, and Sunday suppers? Those desserts were pure comfort—simple, sweet, and made to feed a crowd. Somewhere along the way, they got overshadowed by fancy soufflés and TikTok trends. But it’s time to bring them back. Here are 18 old-school church cookbook desserts that no one’s making anymore—but absolutely should be.
1. Watergate Salad
Once a star at every potluck, Watergate Salad remains a quirky but delightful treat. This green fluffy dessert combines pistachio pudding, crushed pineapple, mini marshmallows, and whipped topping to create a sweet, creamy dish that’s both retro and refreshing. With a hint of nuttiness from pistachios, it captures a playful charm that’s hard to resist. Imagine a dessert so simple yet so harmonious, evoking memories of simpler times. It’s a crowd-pleaser for all ages, perfect for those who appreciate nostalgia in a bowl. A taste of the past, just a spoonful away.
2. Wacky Cake
Wacky Cake defies dessert conventions with its unique ingredient list. This chocolatey delight requires no eggs, milk, or butter, yet emerges moist and rich. The secret lies in pantry staples like cocoa powder, vinegar, and vegetable oil. It’s the cake that depression-era bakers embraced, showcasing innovation amidst scarcity. Served with a simple chocolate frosting, its charm lies in its unfussy approach, making it accessible to everyone. This cake invites you to savor the spirit of creativity, perfect for those who love a good story behind their dessert.
3. Texas Sheet Cake
Texas Sheet Cake is a legend in its own right. This thin, fudgy cake topped with glossy chocolate icing is the epitome of indulgence. Made in a large pan, it’s designed to feed a crowd, making it a staple at gatherings. The warm icing, poured directly onto the cake, sets into a delectable chocolate layer that melts in your mouth. The addition of pecans adds a delightful crunch, creating a harmonious blend of textures. A celebration on its own, this cake embodies the spirit of hospitality and togetherness.
4. Cherry Delight
Cherry Delight is a no-bake wonder that layers nostalgia with flavor. With a graham cracker crust, cream cheese filling, and canned cherry pie topping, it requires minimal effort for maximum delight. This dessert is all about layers. The tangy cream cheese provides a luscious contrast to the sweet cherries, while the crumbly crust offers a satisfying base. Perfect for busy days, it’s a reminder of the joys that simple pleasures bring. Serve it chilled for a refreshing treat that speaks to the heart as much as the taste buds.
5. Dump Cake
Dump Cake is the culinary equivalent of a lazy summer afternoon. True to its name, all you need to do is “dump” fruit filling, boxed cake mix, and butter into a pan and bake. The result? A golden, gooey, deliciously messy dessert that feels like a warm hug. It’s the dessert for those who love simplicity without sacrificing taste. Each bite brings the contrasting textures of tender fruit and slightly crisp cake, all melded together in buttery bliss. Ideal for impromptu gatherings or comforting nights in.
6. Icebox Cake
Icebox Cake is a testament to the magic of simplicity. Layers of graham crackers are alternated with whipped cream or pudding, then chilled to perfection. The beauty of this dessert lies in its transformation—what starts as crunchy layers becomes a cake-like masterpiece after a night in the fridge. Refreshingly cool and subtly sweet, Icebox Cake is perfect for hot days or a sweet finish to a meal. It’s a slice of nostalgia that delights both young and old, reminding us of leisurely summers and cherished memories.
7. Buttermilk Pie
Buttermilk Pie is a slice of Southern comfort. This sweet custard pie, with its tangy buttermilk base and hint of nutmeg, offers a silky, smooth texture that melts in your mouth. Traditionally Southern, it’s a pie that’s as humble as it is unforgettable. The balance of sweet and tang with a buttery crust makes each bite a journey through flavors and sensations. It’s a delightful surprise for those unfamiliar, and a beloved classic for those in the know. Perfect for family gatherings or a cozy dessert night.
8. Sock-It-To-Me Cake
Sock-It-To-Me Cake brings the joy of indulgence with every bite. This buttery bundt cake, swirled with brown sugar and pecans, is topped with a simple yet elegant glaze. Each slice reveals a rich, flavorful center that feels like a warm embrace. A Southern classic, it’s the cake for celebrations big and small. The playful name hints at its bold flavors and undeniable charm. It’s the kind of dessert that turns ordinary days into special occasions, infusing sweetness and warmth into any gathering. A true testament to Southern baking.
9. Orange Dreamsicle Salad
Orange Dreamsicle Salad evokes memories of carefree summers and playful afternoons. This chilled dessert combines mandarin oranges, orange Jell-O, and whipped topping into a creamy, dreamy delight. With each spoonful, it brings back the nostalgic taste of a favorite childhood treat. The vibrant orange hue and refreshing flavor make it perfect for sunny days or potluck gatherings. As a dessert, it’s both familiar and unique, delighting those who cherish the sweetness of simpler times. A salad that’s a dessert, it’s a fun twist on classic flavors.
10. Hello Dollies (7-Layer Bars)
Hello Dollies—also known as 7-Layer Bars—are a delightful medley of textures and flavors. These bars feature a graham cracker crust layered with chocolate chips, coconut, and sweetened condensed milk, creating a chewy, decadent treat. The magic happens as these layers meld together during baking, forming rich, indulgent bars that are as satisfying as they are easy to make. Perfect for those who appreciate the art of balanced flavors, these bars are a reminder of the creativity in simple recipes. A cherished treat for any occasion.
11. Banana Pudding with Nilla Wafers
Banana Pudding with Nilla Wafers is a pure comfort in a dish. Layers of creamy pudding, ripe bananas, and crunchy Nilla Wafers come together to create a dessert that’s both classic and comforting. The harmony of textures and flavors makes each spoonful a delightful experience. Topped with whipped cream, it’s a dessert that evokes warmth and nostalgia, perfect for family gatherings or church potlucks. Simple yet elegant, it’s a testament to the beauty found in traditional recipes. A staple that never goes out of style.
12. Pineapple Upside-Down Cake
Pineapple Upside-Down Cake is a visual and culinary delight. With caramelized pineapple rings and maraschino cherries atop a fluffy yellow cake, it’s as stunning as it is delicious. The cake absorbs the sweet, caramel flavors from the fruit, creating a moist and flavorful dessert. This classic cake is perfect for those who love a touch of tropical sweetness. It’s the kind of dessert that brings a slice of sunshine to any table, making ordinary moments feel special and bringing smiles to everyone who tries it.
13. Oatmeal Scotchies
Oatmeal Scotchies combine the wholesome goodness of oats with the rich sweetness of butterscotch chips. These chewy bars offer a satisfying texture that’s both nostalgic and comforting. Each bite delivers a perfect balance of flavors, where the earthy oats complement the decadent butterscotch. A staple in church cookbooks, these bars are beloved for their simplicity and deliciousness. They’re perfect for sharing, whether at bake sales or as a homemade treat. A classic that continues to bring joy and warmth to those who savor them.
14. Chocolate Mayonnaise Cake
Chocolate Mayonnaise Cake challenges traditional baking norms with its surprising ingredient list. By replacing oil and eggs with mayonnaise, it achieves an ultra-moist, rich chocolate flavor. Each slice offers a moist, tender crumb, making it a standout dessert. The chocolate frosting enhances its decadence, creating a treat that delights chocoholics. This cake is a testament to innovative baking, proving that unexpected ingredients can lead to delicious results. A quirky yet beloved classic, it’s perfect for those who appreciate culinary surprises and a rich, chocolatey indulgence.
15. Rhubarb Custard Bars
Rhubarb Custard Bars are a taste of country baking at its finest. With a sweet-tart rhubarb filling atop a custardy layer and buttery shortbread crust, they offer a delightful contrast of flavors. These bars capture the essence of homemade goodness, perfect for those who enjoy the balance of sweet and tart. The rhubarb provides a refreshing zing, while the custard adds creamy richness. Ideal for spring gatherings or anytime you crave a touch of rustic charm, these bars bring warmth and satisfaction with every bite.
16. Jell-O Pretzel Salad
Jell-O Pretzel Salad is a masterpiece of salty-sweet perfection. A crunchy pretzel crust provides the foundation, layered with a creamy cheese layer and topped with vibrant strawberry Jell-O. This chilled dessert is a delightful surprise, offering contrasting textures and flavors in each bite. Perfect for picnics or potlucks, it’s both visually appealing and deliciously unique. A fun twist on traditional salads, it captures the joy of creativity in the kitchen. This salad isn’t just dessert; it’s an experience that delights and entertains.
17. Mississippi Mud Cake
Mississippi Mud Cake is a chocolate lover’s paradise. With a fudgy cake base topped with melted marshmallows and rich chocolate frosting, it’s a dessert that’s messy in the best way. Each bite is a symphony of textures, from gooey marshmallows to smooth frosting. This cake captures the playful indulgence of Southern baking, offering a treat that’s both rich and satisfying. Ideal for gatherings or special occasions, it embodies the spirit of celebration and joy. A must-try for anyone who appreciates the magic of chocolate.
18. Peanut Butter Cornflake Bars
Peanut Butter Cornflake Bars are the ultimate no-bake indulgence. Sticky and crunchy, they combine the nutty flavor of peanut butter with the satisfying crunch of cornflakes. Perfect for those who love a quick and easy dessert, these bars are a nostalgic nod to simpler times. They’re ideal for school lunches or as a quick snack, offering a delightful balance of sweetness and texture. A favorite across generations, they continue to bring joy with their uncomplicated deliciousness. Perfect for sharing or savoring solo.