15 Most Perfect Pizza Places Across America And 5 That Deserve A Special Slice Of Praise

Explore the finest pizza establishments across the United States, showcasing 15 standout pizzerias and 5 noteworthy places that deserve unique recognition. From classic thin crusts to innovative deep-dish creations, these are the must-visit spots for every pizza enthusiast. Dive into this journey of savory delights, charming local favorites, and culinary legends that define the diverse landscape of American pizza making.

1. Lucali (Brooklyn, NY)

Lucali, a Brooklyn jewel, has garnered fame with its thin, blistered crusts and minimalist toppings. Regular patrons include celebrities like Drake and Beyoncé, who are drawn to its unpretentious charm and authentic taste. This pizzeria’s atmosphere is as inviting as its menu, allowing guests to bring their own beverages. The experience is both familiar and unique, making it a staple in the New York pizza scene. Immersed in tradition, each bite of Lucali’s pizza resonates with simplicity and flavor, setting it apart as a beloved culinary haven. Its reputation continues to grow, fueled by word of mouth.

2. Pequod’s (Chicago, IL)

Pequod’s in Chicago redefines what locals consider pizza heaven. Their signature offering, a caramelized crust pan pizza, stands out amidst a sea of deep-dish competitors. The rich, gooey texture and unique flavor profile make each slice an indulgence. With a cozy interior that invites relaxation, it’s a favorite among both residents and visitors. The pizzeria’s special crust, achieved through a meticulous baking process, is a testament to its commitment to quality. Pequod’s isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an experience that leaves a lasting impression on every patron. Discover why it’s a must-visit.

3. Pizzeria Bianco (Phoenix, AZ)

In the heart of Phoenix, Pizzeria Bianco’s wood-fired pies have achieved legendary status. Each pizza, especially the Margherita, showcases Chris Bianco’s dedication to craft. Patrons willingly endure long waits, knowing the reward is an unparalleled dining experience. The rustic charm of the establishment complements the authenticity of its offerings. With a focus on quality and tradition, Pizzeria Bianco has become a beacon for pizza aficionados seeking excellence. Every bite is a testament to Bianco’s skill, leaving guests yearning for more. It’s not just a meal; it’s a celebration of culinary artistry.

4. Di Fara Pizza (Brooklyn, NY)

Di Fara Pizza stands as an emblem of traditional pizza-making in Brooklyn. Each slice is a labor of love, crafted by the legendary pizzaiolo who finishes with a drizzle of olive oil and fresh basil. The old-school charm resonates with both locals and tourists, making it a pilgrimage for pizza lovers. The unassuming setting belies the extraordinary flavors that have been perfected over decades. This pizzeria isn’t just about eating; it’s about experiencing a slice of history. Every visit reaffirms why Di Fara is a timeless treasure in the pizza world.

5. Tony’s Pizza Napoletana (San Francisco, CA)

Tony’s Pizza Napoletana in San Francisco offers a unique array of pizza styles, thanks to its 12 different ovens. Helmed by world champion Tony Gemignani, each creation is a masterpiece, reflecting his expertise and passion. The pizzeria buzzes with energy as patrons explore the extensive menu. From Neapolitan to Sicilian, the diversity caters to every palate. This dynamic atmosphere makes Tony’s a cornerstone of the city’s culinary scene. Visitors leave with not just a meal, but a memorable experience of pizza innovation. It’s a must-visit destination for any pizza enthusiast.

6. Lou Malnati’s (Chicago, IL)

Lou Malnati’s is synonymous with Chicago’s deep-dish tradition, offering a rich, buttery crust that supports a hearty topping of sausage and bright tomato sauce. This iconic pizzeria has become a symbol of the city’s culinary pride. The bustling atmosphere enhances the rich sensory experience, making each bite a celebration. It’s a place where tradition meets taste, and every slice tells a story of Chicago’s vibrant culture. Lou Malnati’s offers more than just pizza; it provides a taste of the city’s heart and soul, making it a must-visit for locals and tourists alike.

7. Sally’s Apizza (New Haven, CT)

Sally’s Apizza in New Haven is revered for its coal-fired, thin-crust pizzas. With a chewy texture and charred edges, it embodies the essence of New Haven-style pizza. The pizzeria’s storied history adds to its allure, drawing in pizza enthusiasts from all over. Each bite offers a symphony of flavors, from the smoky crust to the savory toppings. The intimate setting and rich tradition make Sally’s a cornerstone in the local dining scene. It’s not just a meal, but a rite of passage for those seeking authentic, bold pizza experiences.

8. Prince Street Pizza (NYC, NY)

Prince Street Pizza in NYC has gained fame for its thick, square slices topped with spicy pepperoni that curl into crispy cups. This iconic offering is both greasy and glorious, making it a favorite among locals and tourists. Set in the heart of the city, the pizzeria buzzes with energy as patrons queue for a taste of this beloved creation. Each slice is a flavorful explosion, perfectly marrying spice and texture. A visit to Prince Street Pizza is a quintessential New York experience, offering a slice of the city’s dynamic culinary landscape.

9. Joe’s Pizza (New York, NY)

Joe’s Pizza offers the quintessential NYC slice—foldable, saucy, and cheesy. It’s a staple for those seeking a true taste of New York. The simplicity of its ingredients belies the depth of flavor found in every bite. Whether it’s a quick lunch or a late-night craving, Joe’s delivers with consistency and charm. Its unassuming presence on the streets of New York makes it a beloved institution. For locals and visitors alike, Joe’s Pizza provides a comforting, classic experience that captures the essence of the city’s pizza culture.

10. Apizza Scholls (Portland, OR)

Apizza Scholls in Portland is celebrated for its meticulously crafted pies. The crust achieves the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, while the toppings are thoughtfully curated to enhance each bite. This dedication to quality is evident in every pizza that leaves the oven. The cozy environment adds to the charm, making it a favorite among locals. Apizza Scholls offers more than just pizza; it delivers an experience that resonates with authenticity and innovation. It’s a place where every visit is an exploration of flavors, leaving a lasting impression on all who dine there.

11. Pizano’s (Chicago, IL)

Pizano’s in Chicago offers a delightful twist on the traditional deep-dish experience. With its buttery crust and deep cheese pulls, it provides a lighter alternative to the heavier options. The cozy, welcoming atmosphere invites patrons to relax and savor their meal. Each pizza is crafted with care, ensuring that the balance of flavors and textures is just right. Pizano’s is a testament to Chicago’s diverse pizza landscape, offering something unique while staying true to its roots. It’s a hidden gem that promises satisfaction with every slice.

12. Modern Apizza (New Haven, CT)

Modern Apizza in New Haven challenges the debate among locals about its superiority to other institutions. The Italian Bomb pie, a medley of toppings, stands out as a crowd favorite. The bustling atmosphere is a testament to its popularity and the loyalty of its patrons. Each visit offers a chance to explore the rich flavors and textures that define New Haven-style pizza. Modern Apizza isn’t just about competition; it’s about community, tradition, and the love of good food. It’s a vibrant destination for those seeking a genuine pizza experience.

13. Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana (New Haven, CT)

Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana is a staple in New Haven, offering a unique take on pizza with its famous clam pie. The coal-fired crust provides a smoky, crispy base that perfectly complements the briny clams and savory toppings. This distinctive offering has been a favorite since 1925, drawing pizza lovers from near and far. The historic setting adds to the allure, creating an atmosphere steeped in tradition. Each bite at Frank Pepe’s is a journey into the past, where pizza is not just a meal but a cherished legacy. It’s a must-visit for any aficionado.

14. Roberta’s (Brooklyn, NY)

Roberta’s in Brooklyn combines trendiness with culinary substance. The wood-fired Bee Sting pie, featuring honey and spicy salami, has become a modern classic. This inventive combination of flavors reflects Roberta’s commitment to pushing boundaries while honoring tradition. The pizzeria’s vibrant atmosphere is a magnet for those seeking both innovation and authenticity. Each pizza is a testament to the creative spirit that defines Roberta’s. It’s more than a meal; it’s an exploration of taste and texture that captivates the senses. A visit here promises a unique experience that’s both exciting and satisfying.

15. Regina Pizzeria (Boston, MA)

Regina Pizzeria in Boston has been a staple since 1926, offering thin crusts with bold, vibrant flavors. Located in the North End, it’s a piece of living history that continues to delight pizza lovers. The bustling atmosphere and rich aroma of baking pizzas create an inviting environment. Every slice is a celebration of tradition, with recipes that have stood the test of time. Regina Pizzeria provides a genuine taste of Boston’s culinary heritage, making it a beloved destination for both locals and tourists. It’s a landmark that delivers satisfaction with every bite.

16. Caserta Pizzeria (Providence, RI)

Caserta Pizzeria in Providence has been crafting thick, pillowy pizzas with sweet sauce for over 60 years. This old-school establishment exudes a nostalgic charm that resonates with patrons. The unique dough and flavorful sauce create a harmonious balance that keeps customers returning. Caserta’s is a community favorite, offering a taste of tradition amidst the modern hustle and bustle. Each visit is an opportunity to indulge in comfort and flavor, reminiscent of simpler times. It’s a cherished spot that offers both history and heart in every delicious slice.

17. Via 313 (Austin, TX)

Via 313 in Austin introduces the city to Detroit-style pizza, characterized by its square shape, crispy edges, and layers of cheese. This modern twist on a classic style has captivated the local dining scene. The pizzeria blends tradition with innovation, offering a unique taste that sets it apart. With its welcoming atmosphere and creative offerings, Via 313 has become a favorite destination for pizza lovers. Each bite is a testament to the pizzeria’s commitment to quality and flavor, providing an unforgettable experience. It’s a slice of Detroit in the heart of Texas.

18. Santarpio’s Pizza (Boston, MA)

Santarpio’s Pizza in Boston is a local legend, known for its charred crust and spicy sausage. This unpretentious spot captures the essence of old-school pizza making, resonating with authenticity and flavor. The rustic setting and no-frills approach create a unique dining experience that appeals to purists and enthusiasts alike. Each pizza is a labor of love, crafted with care and precision. Santarpio’s isn’t just about pizza; it’s about community, tradition, and the joy of simple, honest cooking. It’s a Boston landmark that offers a genuine taste of the city’s culinary spirit.

19. Cane Rosso (Dallas, TX)

Cane Rosso in Dallas delivers a Neapolitan-style pizza experience with a Texas twist. The fresh mozzarella and 900-degree oven create a doughy bliss that captures the essence of Naples. The lively atmosphere and commitment to authenticity make it a standout in the local dining scene. Each pizza is a celebration of flavors, reflecting a perfect blend of tradition and innovation. Cane Rosso offers more than just a meal; it delivers a taste of Italy right in the heart of Texas. It’s a vibrant and delicious destination for pizza lovers to explore.

20. Vito & Nick’s (Chicago, IL)

Vito & Nick’s in Chicago offers a departure from the deep-dish norm with its classic tavern-style thin crust, cut into squares. This nostalgic setting provides a glimpse into the past, where simplicity and flavor reign supreme. Each pizza is crafted with a focus on texture and taste, offering a satisfying alternative to heavier options. The pizzeria’s long-standing reputation speaks to its quality and consistency. Vito & Nick’s is more than just a restaurant; it’s a piece of Chicago’s culinary history. It’s a must-visit for those seeking a traditional, unpretentious pizza experience.