15 Lunchables PB&J Sandwiches Ranked: Who Tops Uncrustables?

Peanut butter and jelly sandwiches have long been the go-to comfort snack, but Lunchables and Uncrustables have turned them into full-on packaged powerhouses. But which ones are actually worth tossing in your lunch bag? We rounded up 15 PB&J-style snacks—including every variety of Lunchables, a few honorable mentions, and of course, Uncrustables—to see who really delivers.

1. Uncrustables Grape Jelly (Smucker’s)

The classic that started it all, Uncrustables Grape Jelly is the epitome of a perfect PB&J sandwich. With a delicate crustless edge, it provides an ideal balance of sweet grape jelly and creamy peanut butter. This convenient snack is not only easy to pack but also ensures a mess-free experience. Its popularity stems from its effortless transition from freezer to lunchbox, maintaining freshness and flavor. Many consider it the gold standard among PB&J sandwiches, offering nostalgia and satisfaction with every bite. It’s no wonder this remains a top choice for kids and adults alike.

2. Uncrustables Strawberry Jelly (Smucker’s)

For those with a penchant for strawberry over grape, the Uncrustables Strawberry Jelly sandwich is a delightful alternative. It features the same soft, crustless bread filled with a sweet, fruity strawberry jelly and smooth peanut butter. This sandwich offers a lighter, more refreshing taste while still providing the convenience of a no-fuss meal option. Whether it’s enjoyed at home or on-the-go, it delivers consistent flavor and a satisfying experience. Fans of strawberry flavors will appreciate its authentic fruitiness and the simplicity it brings to lunchtime.

3. Lunchables PB&J Grape with Crusts

Lunchables PB&J Grape with Crusts brings a surprising twist to traditional PB&J sandwiches. Unlike its crustless counterparts, this option retains the crust, offering a slightly heartier texture. The grape jelly inside bursts with flavor, complementing the rich peanut butter. It holds up well in a lunchbox, making it a reliable choice. This version adds a touch of nostalgia for those who prefer their sandwiches with a classic look. It’s a perfect balance of taste and texture, sure to please both young and old snackers who crave a bit of tradition in their meals.

4. Uncrustables Reduced Sugar Grape

The Uncrustables Reduced Sugar Grape offers a healthier twist without sacrificing flavor. It maintains the classic PB&J combo with less sugar, appealing to health-conscious consumers. The grape jelly remains sweet and smooth, pairing perfectly with the creamy peanut butter enveloped in soft, crustless bread. This option is ideal for those who want to enjoy the nostalgic taste without feeling guilty about sugar intake. It offers the same convenience and deliciousness, making it a favorite for lunchboxes or snacks. A smart choice for today’s mindful eaters.

5. Lunchables PB&J Strawberry with Crusts

Lunchables PB&J Strawberry with Crusts stands out with its fresh and fruity strawberry filling. Unlike some artificial alternatives, this version captures the authentic taste of strawberries. The inclusion of crusts offers a satisfying bite, giving the sandwich a more substantial feel. It’s a delightful choice for strawberry enthusiasts seeking a portable snack. Its balanced flavor profile ensures a pleasurable eating experience, whether in a lunchbox or as an afternoon treat. This sandwich combines tradition with fruity fun, making it a popular pick among various age groups.

6. Lunchables PB&J Grape Crustless Sandwich

Lunchables PB&J Grape Crustless Sandwich offers a convenient, kid-friendly option for the PB&J lover. Its soft, crustless bread encases a deliciously sticky grape jelly paired with smooth peanut butter. Although smaller in size, this sandwich packs enough flavor to satisfy sweet cravings. However, some might find the bread slightly dry, especially if not consumed immediately. Despite this minor setback, it remains a favorite among children for its easy-to-hold shape and familiar taste. A go-to for parents seeking a quick, no-mess snack option.

7. Uncrustables Chocolate Flavored Hazelnut

Uncrustables Chocolate Flavored Hazelnut brings a dessert-like twist to the classic PB&J lineup. While not a traditional peanut butter and jelly sandwich, its chocolate-hazelnut filling tantalizes taste buds with every bite. The smooth filling is enclosed in the characteristic crustless bread, offering a sweet treat more suited for dessert than lunch. Despite its deviation from the classic, it remains a beloved choice for those craving a chocolaty indulgence. Perfect for satisfying afternoon sweet tooth cravings, this flavor promises a delightful departure from the ordinary.

8. Lunchables PB&J Strawberry Crustless Sandwich

Lunchables PB&J Strawberry Crustless Sandwich is a compact and accessible option for strawberry lovers. Its soft, crustless bread contains strawberry jelly that tastes a bit artificial but still enjoyable. The pairing with creamy peanut butter strikes a comforting note, ideal for a quick snack fix. Its size makes it an excellent choice for kids or those in need of a small treat. While not as fresh-tasting as some, it holds its place as a convenient and tasty option. A colorful addition to any lunchbox, bringing a touch of sweetness to the day.

9. Great Value (Walmart) PB&J Crustless Sandwich

The Great Value PB&J Crustless Sandwich from Walmart offers an economical alternative to brand-name options like Uncrustables. Although it may not be as soft or sweet, it still provides a satisfactory experience. The crustless bread houses a generous spread of peanut butter and grape jelly, making it a solid budget-friendly choice. While the texture might not match its pricier counterparts, it fulfills its role as a convenient snack without breaking the bank. Perfect for those looking to save a little while still enjoying the classic flavors of a PB&J sandwich.

10. Trader Joe’s PB&J Bars

Trader Joe’s PB&J Bars diverge from the traditional sandwich, offering a soft-baked bar that satisfies peanut butter and jelly cravings. With chewy, nutty, and fruity layers, these bars capture the essence of PB&J in a new form. They are ideal for those on-the-go, offering a compact and mess-free alternative. Although not a sandwich, they effectively scratch the same itch, providing a convenient snack with all the classic flavors. Fans of Trader Joe’s appreciate the unique texture and taste, making it a favorite among those seeking variety.

11. Lunchables PB&J with Jelly Dipper

Lunchables PB&J with Jelly Dipper offers a fun, interactive twist on the classic sandwich. This DIY-style snack features separate compartments for bread, peanut butter, and a jelly dipper, allowing for a customized experience. While the concept is entertaining for kids, the bread tends to dry out quickly, and the jelly can resemble more of a gelatin texture. Despite these drawbacks, the novelty of dipping and assembling appeals to younger audiences. It’s a playful option for those looking to engage with their food and adds a touch of creativity to snack time.

12. Kroger PB&J Crustless Sandwich

Kroger PB&J Crustless Sandwich tries to capture the essence of the classic PB&J with varying success. While offering an affordable grocery-store alternative, it often falls short with dry bread and a too-thin filling. However, it still manages to deliver the familiar peanut butter and grape jelly taste many desire. Suitable for those on a budget, it provides a decent snack option in a pinch. Though not the most luxurious choice, it serves its purpose for quick, everyday consumption. Its simplicity may appeal to those who prefer a more understated snack experience.

13. Lunchables PB&J “Half Sandwich”

The Lunchables PB&J “Half Sandwich” presents itself as a petite version of the beloved classic. Unfortunately, its size often leaves snackers wanting more, with an uneven filling distribution further detracting from satisfaction. Despite these setbacks, it remains a viable quick snack choice when time is limited. It’s particularly handy for smaller appetites or as an addition to a more substantial meal. While it may not fulfill larger hunger pangs, its convenience and simplicity make it a go-to for those in need of a rapid, fuss-free snack.

14. Aldi’s Friendly Farms PB&J Pouches

Aldi’s Friendly Farms PB&J Pouches offer a unique twist in the PB&J realm. With a pouch-style packaging, they present a convenient, on-the-go option that deviates from the traditional sandwich form. The filling, while somewhat muted in flavor, provides a balanced taste of peanut butter and jelly. These pouches offer an innovative texture, more novel than essential for PB&J enthusiasts. Ideal for those seeking something different, they merge practicality with playfulness. While not a direct sandwich replacement, they make for an interesting snack adventure.

15. Generic Gas Station PB&J

The Generic Gas Station PB&J often carries a reputation for being pre-packaged, sticky, and stale. Despite its shortcomings, it sometimes serves as a last-resort snack when options are limited. Travelers might find themselves reaching for this as a quick hunger fix during long drives. While its texture and flavor are not its strong points, it still delivers the basic peanut butter and jelly taste. For those in a pinch, it offers a sense of comfort and familiarity, albeit with room for improvement. A reminder of simpler, nostalgic times on the road.