15 BBQ Orders You Might Regret And 11 Best BBQ Dishes to Try

Exploring the world of barbecue reveals a landscape dotted with both delightful surprises and regrettable choices. While some dishes promise an unforgettable gustatory experience, others might leave your palate wanting. In this article, we’ll navigate through 15 BBQ orders you might regret and 11 best BBQ dishes you should definitely consider trying. From the cautionary tales of overcooked meats and soggy sides to the savory success stories of expertly smoked briskets and tantalizing ribs, this guide aims to inform your next barbecue adventure.

1. Overcooked Pulled Pork

Overcooked Pulled Pork
© Tasting Table

Pulled pork is meant to be a tender, succulent delight, but when overcooked, it turns into something else entirely. Imagine taking a bite only to find the meat dry, stringy, and drowned in sauce to cover up its shortcomings. It’s like watching a beloved movie star deliver a disappointing performance – you just know it could have been so much better. The allure of pulled pork lies in its melt-in-your-mouth texture and rich flavor, a far cry from this culinary faux pas.

2. Pre-Sauced Ribs

Pre-Sauced Ribs
© Amazing Ribs

There’s a saying in BBQ circles: good ribs don’t need to be drenched. Imagine being served a rack of ribs already slathered in sauce, hiding what lies beneath. It’s like receiving a gift wrapped in too many layers – it arouses suspicion. The beauty of ribs is in their smoky, tender flesh, complemented by a balanced glaze. When the sauce overpowers, it suggests the ribs might be more show than substance, leaving you wondering what they’re hiding.

3. Boiled Brisket Masquerading as BBQ

Boiled Brisket Masquerading as BBQ
© House of Nash Eats

True brisket is a labor of love, requiring smoke and patience to transform into a masterpiece. Picture a brisket that’s been boiled, lacking the telltale signs of a proper BBQ. It’s like a blockbuster movie with no plot – all hype, no heart. Smoke kisses the meat with flavor, while boiling leaves it bland and unworthy of the BBQ title. A real brisket seduces with its smoky aroma and meltworthy tenderness, a far cry from this impostor.

4. BBQ Chicken Breast

BBQ Chicken Breast
© Budget Bytes

Chicken breast at a BBQ can often be like the wallflower at a party – present but unremarkable. When grilled without finesse, it leans towards dryness and lacks the excitement found in other BBQ offerings. It’s the least thrilling choice on the menu, akin to choosing vanilla in a world full of vibrant flavors. A well-cooked chicken breast should be juicy and flavorful, a blank canvas for smoky and spicy notes, not a lackluster afterthought.

5. Turkey Legs

Turkey Legs
© The Happier Homemaker

Turkey legs evoke visions of medieval feasts, yet often fail to deliver on that promise. Imagine biting into one only to find it tough and flavorless, more suitable as a prop than a meal. It’s like expecting a fairy tale, only to end up with a dry history lesson. When cooked properly, turkey legs can be a juicy, flavorful choice, but too often, they’re an exercise in chewing and patience. Done right, they can transport you to another time.

6. Store-Bought Coleslaw

Store-Bought Coleslaw
© Mashed

Coleslaw should be a refreshing counterpoint to the richness of BBQ, but store-bought versions often miss the mark. Picture a bowl of watery, overly sweet slaw, serving more as a filler than a flavorful addition. It’s like expecting a sharp, witty exchange and receiving small talk instead. Fresh slaw, with its crisp texture and tangy dressing, can elevate a BBQ meal, but this version falls flat, leaving you longing for homemade freshness.

7. Soggy Cornbread

Soggy Cornbread
© Tara Teaspoon

Cornbread should be a comforting, golden delight, but when it turns soggy, it loses its charm. Imagine biting into what should be a moist, crumbly treat, only to find it mushy and unappetizing. It’s like stepping into a puddle when expecting solid ground. The perfect cornbread offers a balance of sweetness and texture, a welcome companion to smoky meats. Soggy cornbread, however, is a misstep in an otherwise delicious journey.

8. Dry Sausage Links

Dry Sausage Links
© Goldbelly

Good BBQ sausage should snap and ooze flavor, a burst of joy in every bite. However, dry sausage links are a sad affair, akin to a joke that falls flat. Imagine a sausage that lacks juiciness, leaving you longing for the vibrant taste of spices and smoke. It’s like anticipating a fireworks show and only getting a sparkler. Quality sausage links are a celebration of bold flavors, while dry ones are a party you might regret attending.

9. Cold Baked Beans

Cold Baked Beans
© The Comfort of Cooking

Baked beans should be a warm, comforting side dish at any BBQ, but when served cold, they become an insult to the meal. Imagine taking a bite, only to be met with syrupy sweetness and a chill that doesn’t belong. It’s like expecting a warm embrace and receiving a cold shoulder. Properly warmed, baked beans offer a sweet-savory harmony that complements grilled meats, while cold beans feel like a culinary oversight.

10. Fatty Burnt Ends

Fatty Burnt Ends
© Reddit

Burnt ends are supposed to be the crown jewels of BBQ, but when they’re all fat and no meat, they’re a greasy letdown. Picture eagerly anticipating rich, smoky morsels, only to find them overwhelmed by fat. It’s like buying a mystery novel only to discover the pages are blank. True burnt ends tantalize with a perfect balance of fat and meat, crispy edges, and tender insides. These, however, fall short of their legendary status.

11. Sauceless BBQ Tofu

Sauceless BBQ Tofu
© Eat With Clarity

BBQ tofu should be a flavorful, smoky delight, but when served without sauce or seasoning, it’s simply uninspired. Imagine placing a plain block of tofu on the grill, expecting it to transform into something impressive, only to find it as bland as before. It’s like attending a concert where the band forgot to play. Properly seasoned, tofu can absorb the essence of BBQ, but without it, the dish falls flat and forgettable.

12. Overly Smoky Anything

Overly Smoky Anything
© Tastyble

Smoke is an art in BBQ, but when overdone, it turns what could be a masterpiece into an overwhelming mess. Picture meats that are more smoke than substance, with flavors masked by bitterness. It’s like wearing too much perfume – overpowering and unpleasant. The beauty of BBQ lies in the balance of smoke, heat, and seasoning, where each element enhances the other. Too much smoke, however, obscures the true taste of the dish.

13. Pulled Chicken

Pulled Chicken
© Legends of the Grill

Pulled chicken can struggle to hold its own at a BBQ, often ending up dry and uninspiring. Imagine a dish that lacks the rich, fatty content needed for slow cooking, leaving it dull and unmemorable. It’s like reading a story without a climax. While pulled pork excites with its tender juiciness, pulled chicken often leaves you wanting more. Properly prepared, it can shine, but too often, it falls short of expectations.

14. Undercooked Corn on the Cob

Undercooked Corn on the Cob
© Nutritious Deliciousness

Grilled corn on the cob should be a smoky, sweet delight, but when undercooked, it’s a crunchy disappointment. Imagine biting into kernels that lack the charred, caramelized notes essential to great BBQ corn. It’s akin to watching a movie that ends before the climax. Well-cooked corn pops with flavor and texture, a satisfying side that enhances the meal. Undercooked, it feels unfinished and unworthy of the BBQ spotlight.

15. Mac and Cheese With No Soul

Mac and Cheese With No Soul
© Oh Sweet Basil

Mac and cheese at a BBQ should be a creamy, indulgent treat, yet when runny and flavorless, it’s a culinary letdown. Imagine expecting a rich, cheesy comfort only to find something straight from a box, devoid of love and creativity. It’s like looking at a painting that lacks depth and emotion. A good mac and cheese is a soul-warming addition to BBQ, but without the right touch, it’s just a missed opportunity.

16. Smoked Brisket (Fatty End)

Smoked Brisket (Fatty End)
© Fatty Butts BBQ

The fatty end of smoked brisket is where the magic happens, turning a simple cut of meat into an unforgettable experience. Imagine slicing into brisket so tender and juicy it practically falls apart, releasing aromas rich with smoke and anticipation. It’s like listening to a symphony of flavors, each note perfectly harmonized. This isn’t just brisket; it’s a masterpiece of patience and precision, showcasing BBQ at its finest.

17. Dry-Rubbed Ribs

Dry-Rubbed Ribs
© The Speckled Palate

Dry-rubbed ribs are a testament to the power of simplicity, where a blend of spices creates a crispy bark without the need for sauce. Picture ribs so tender that each bite is a revelation, a perfect marriage of spice and smoke. It’s like enjoying a song that needs no words to move you. These ribs stand proudly on their own, proving that when done right, less can indeed be more. A true BBQ triumph.

18. Pork Belly Burnt Ends

Pork Belly Burnt Ends
© Kevin Is Cooking

Pork belly burnt ends are the dream of any BBQ aficionado, combining crispy edges with a melt-in-your-mouth center. Picture them glazed with a sweet-heat sauce, the perfect blend of indulgence and balance. It’s like savoring a piece of art, where every detail is in harmony. These burnt ends aren’t merely a dish; they’re an experience, a testament to the creativity and passion that defines great BBQ.

19. Texas Hot Links

Texas Hot Links
© PS Seasoning

Texas hot links bring boldness to the BBQ table, with flavors that are both spicy and juicy. Imagine biting into a sausage that challenges and excites your taste buds, a celebration of heat and smoke. It’s like a dance party for your palate, where every step is a new sensation. These sausages are not for the faint-hearted, but for those who seek adventure in every bite, making them a must-try for spice lovers.

20. Smoked Turkey Breast

Smoked Turkey Breast
© Epicurious

Smoked turkey breast can be a revelation, offering surprising depth of flavor for a lean cut. Imagine savoring turkey that’s moist, kissed by smoke, and rich with subtle complexity. It’s like finding a hidden gem in a familiar landscape, unexpected yet delightful. This isn’t just turkey; it’s a celebration of what BBQ can do, transforming the ordinary into the extraordinary. A perfect choice for those seeking a lighter, yet satisfying option.

21. Pit-Smoked Wings

Pit-Smoked Wings
© Braised & Deglazed

Pit-smoked wings offer a delightful contrast, with a crispy exterior and juicy interior that’s hard to resist. Imagine wings so flavorful and tender they practically beg to be devoured, a true testament to the art of smoking. It’s like discovering a new favorite song that you can’t stop playing. These wings capture the essence of what makes BBQ special, where each bite is a harmonious blend of smoke, spice, and satisfaction.

22. Grilled Corn With Chili-Lime Butter

Grilled Corn With Chili-Lime Butter
© Zena’s Kitchen

Grilled corn with chili-lime butter is a side that sings with flavor, transforming a humble cob into a star. Picture corn that’s perfectly charred, with a hint of smoke, adorned with a spicy, tangy butter that dances on your tongue. It’s like a burst of sunshine on your plate, a side that elevates the entire BBQ experience. This isn’t just corn; it’s a flavorful adventure that complements the richness of smoked meats beautifully.

23. Homemade Coleslaw With Vinegar Dressing

Homemade Coleslaw With Vinegar Dressing
© Love and Lemons

Homemade coleslaw with vinegar dressing is the unsung hero of BBQ sides, offering a crunchy, tangy counterpoint to rich, smoky meats. Imagine a slaw so fresh and crisp, it cuts through the heaviness, waking up your palate. It’s like a refreshing breeze on a hot summer day, bringing balance and brightness to your meal. This isn’t just coleslaw; it’s a culinary sidekick that enhances and elevates every bite of BBQ.

24. Loaded BBQ Baked Potato

Loaded BBQ Baked Potato
© Smells Like Home

A loaded BBQ baked potato is more than just a side; it’s a meal in itself. Imagine a fluffy potato, bursting with pulled pork, cheddar, and sour cream, each component adding to the indulgence. It’s like a cozy blanket on a chilly night, wrapping you in comfort and satisfaction. This isn’t just a potato; it’s a testament to BBQ’s ability to transform simple ingredients into something extraordinary, filling and fulfilling.

25. Beef Ribs

Beef Ribs
© Jess Pryles

Beef ribs are the giants of the BBQ world, offering a primal, satisfying experience that’s hard to beat. Imagine ribs so large and tender they practically melt in your mouth, with a smoky crust that adds depth and character. It’s like witnessing a grand performance, each bite a powerful note in a symphony of flavors. These ribs aren’t just about size; they’re about delivering an unforgettable taste experience that captures the essence of BBQ.

26. Smoked Mushrooms or Portobellos

Smoked Mushrooms or Portobellos
© Plays Well With Butter

Smoked mushrooms or portobellos are a vegetarian delight that holds its own against any meat. Imagine mushrooms so juicy and flavorful, they soak up smoke like a sponge, delivering a rich, umami-packed bite. It’s like discovering a new dimension in a familiar world, surprising yet satisfying. These mushrooms aren’t just a substitute; they’re a celebration of BBQ’s versatility, proving that great flavor belongs to everyone, regardless of dietary preference.