10 Worst BBQ Sauces To Avoid At The Store And 10 That Are Totally Worth It

Navigating the aisle of BBQ sauces can be daunting, with options ranging from overly sweet to perfectly tangy. Whether you’re a backyard griller or a barbecue enthusiast, choosing the right sauce can make or break your meal. Here, we explore ten BBQ sauces that might not meet your grilling expectations and ten others that truly hit the mark.

1. Kraft Original Barbecue Sauce

When it comes to Kraft Original Barbecue Sauce, affordability may be its only asset. The sauce’s lack of depth stems from its base of corn syrup and liquid smoke, leaving a sugary aftertaste that fails to complement any grilled dish. Unlike the rich, smoky flavor one expects from a barbecue sauce, this version leaves much to be desired.

Without real spices to balance its sweetness, Kraft’s offering is more akin to candy than a proper meat enhancer. It’s a reminder that sometimes, you get what you pay for. For those seeking authenticity, look elsewhere.

2. Heinz Carolina Vinegar Style

Heinz attempts to capture the essence of Carolina barbecue with their Vinegar Style sauce but misses the mark. This sauce, unfortunately, presents a watery consistency that doesn’t hold onto meat well, leaving behind a trail of disappointment. The overpowering tartness overshadows any subtle heat or spice, which are crucial for a balanced taste.

For those hoping for a punchy vinegar-based sauce, Heinz leaves you wanting. The potential is there, but without the right blend of spices, it falls short. Seek a true Carolina masterpiece from local artisans instead.

3. Bull’s-Eye Everyday Original

Bull’s-Eye Everyday Original BBQ Sauce might appeal to those with a sweet tooth but disappoints those looking for complexity. The hefty sugar content combined with an intense salty taste overwhelms the palate rather than enhancing the dish. It crafts a syrupy glaze that masks rather than complements the meat’s natural flavors.

If ribs are on the menu, consider alternatives that offer a more nuanced profile. Bull’s-Eye lacks the spice and tang that characterize a quality barbecue sauce. Its candy-like profile isn’t for everyone, and BBQ aficionados may want to skip.

4. KC Masterpiece Original

Once heralded as a must-have in BBQ circles, KC Masterpiece Original now struggles to live up to its name. The sauce’s overly thick, syrupy consistency fails to deliver the smoky, spicy notes expected from a classic barbecue sauce. Instead, it overpowers the meat, drowning out its natural flavors.

While it might have been a favorite in the past, changing tastes demand more than just thickness and sweetness. For those seeking a subtle, smokey tang, KC Masterpiece might not satisfy. Consider exploring newer, more balanced options that enhance rather than overshadow.

5. Famous Dave’s Sweet & Zesty

Famous Dave’s Sweet & Zesty promises a dynamic flavor experience but falters with an overpowering sweetness. The sauce’s cloying nature makes it difficult to enjoy, as the artificial smokiness lingers uncomfortably on the palate. Rather than a harmonious blend, it offers a disjointed taste.

While the intention might be to create a memorable BBQ flavor, the execution leaves room for improvement. BBQ enthusiasts longing for a genuine smokey kick should look elsewhere. Famous Dave’s doesn’t quite capture the zesty essence it advertises, making it less than stellar for serious grillers.

6. Sweet Baby Ray’s Honey BBQ

Sweet Baby Ray’s Honey BBQ sauce is a staple on many tables, yet its sweetness often overshadows the barbecue experience. Over-reliant on sugary notes, it resembles a glaze more than a sauce meant to highlight savory flavors. For those hunting for an authentic BBQ kick, this sauce might fall flat.

Despite its popularity, the sauce lacks the depth of spices expected from a true barbecue companion. It caters to those preferring sweet over spicy, but for others, the quest for the perfect sauce continues. Consider pairing with something more balanced for proper BBQ indulgence.

7. Stubb’s Sticky Sweet

The name Stubb’s Sticky Sweet is all too fitting, as this sauce sticks in more ways than one. Lacking the robust spices and tang of its original counterpart, it leaves a sugary film rather than enhancing your meal. It’s a far cry from what many expect when reaching for a bottle of Stubb’s.

While sweetness can complement a BBQ sauce, it shouldn’t dominate. For those loyal to the original Stubb’s flavor, this version might be disappointing. Seek out sauces that offer a fusion of sweet and spicy for a truly satisfying taste experience.

8. Open Pit Original

Open Pit Original might evoke nostalgia, but not always in the best way. Its thin consistency and overly vinegary taste create an unexpected sourness that doesn’t pair well with most meats. For those familiar with robust and balanced sauces, this one may seem like a step back in time.

A lack of depth characterizes this sauce, leaving it struggling to compete with modern favorites. While some may appreciate its vintage appeal, others might find it out of touch with contemporary BBQ expectations. Those seeking bold flavors should explore other brands.

9. Great Value Hickory & Brown Sugar

As a generic store-brand sauce, Great Value Hickory & Brown Sugar lives up to its name in the most predictable way possible. Its thin, overly sweet profile doesn’t deliver the smokiness or complexity often desired in a barbecue sauce. Forgettable and lacking in character, it leaves little impression.

While accessible for budget-conscious buyers, the sauce’s ordinary flavor profile doesn’t satisfy those with a passion for BBQ. For serious grillers looking for a signature taste, this option might disappoint. It’s a reminder that not all budget-friendly picks can offer premium flavor.

10. Trader Joe’s Organic Kansas City Style BBQ Sauce

Trader Joe’s Organic Kansas City Style sauce sounds promising but falls short in flavor execution. Its overwhelming molasses base overpowers the palette, overshadowing any smokiness or tang a BBQ sauce should have. This heaviness leaves the taste unbalanced, lacking the finesse of a top-tier sauce.

Although organic, the sauce doesn’t capture the essence of Kansas City barbecue that many expect. Those seeking a true representation of this style might be better off with more authentic options. It’s a reminder that organic doesn’t always equate to superior taste.

11. Stubb’s Original Bar-B-Q Sauce

Stubb’s Original Bar-B-Q Sauce stands out with its bold, peppery essence and the perfect blend of tang and spice. What sets it apart is the absence of high fructose corn syrup, making it a rare gem in the BBQ aisle. Its rich flavor profile enhances rather than masks the meat’s natural taste.

This sauce is a reminder of what authentic barbecue should be. Whether slathered on ribs or brushed over chicken, its robust character elevates any dish. BBQ lovers seeking depth and authenticity will find a trusted companion in Stubb’s Original.

12. Lillie’s Q Smoky BBQ Sauce

Lillie’s Q Smoky BBQ Sauce brings the heart of Memphis BBQ right to your kitchen. Its deep, smoky flavor is complemented by just the right amount of heat, making it a versatile choice for various meats. Whether your preference is pulled pork or grilled chicken, this sauce adds an authentic touch.

Crafted with care, Lillie’s Q captures the essence of Southern barbecue traditions. Each bottle reflects a commitment to quality, ensuring that the flavors resonate with every bite. For those who appreciate depth and a touch of tradition, this sauce is a worthy addition.

13. Rufus Teague Made Some Sauce – Whiskey Maple

Rufus Teague’s Whiskey Maple sauce is an indulgence for the senses. Its rich, smoky character paired with a touch of maple sweetness creates a unique profile perfect for slathering on ribs. This sauce doesn’t just coat the meat; it elevates it.

The whiskey infusion adds a sophisticated note, making each meal feel like an event. For those who love a hint of sweetness without the overpowering sugar, this sauce strikes a perfect balance. It’s a flavorful journey that enhances barbecue to new heights, making it a must-have for enthusiasts.

14. Blues Hog Original BBQ Sauce

Blues Hog Original BBQ Sauce is a fixture in competition circles, renowned for its thick, intense flavor. Each bite offers a complex blend of sweetness and tang, making it ideal for those who appreciate depth in their BBQ. Whether you’re a pro griller or backyard enthusiast, this sauce adds a professional touch.

The sauce’s reputation among competitors speaks volumes about its quality. It’s not just about flavor—it’s about creating experiences. For those aiming for competition-level grilling without leaving home, Blues Hog offers an unmatched experience. This sauce transforms ordinary grilling into a gastronomic event.

15. Bone Suckin’ Sauce Original

Bone Suckin’ Sauce Original epitomizes North Carolina BBQ with its delightful blend of tang, light sweetness, and just a hint of kick. Made with clean ingredients, this sauce is a testament to quality and flavor purity. It’s perfect for basting or dipping, accentuating the natural taste of the meat.

Whether you’re grilling or slow-cooking, Bone Suckin’ Sauce enhances without overpowering. It’s a nod to traditional Carolina flavors, crafted for modern palates. For BBQ enthusiasts who appreciate subtlety and quality, this sauce is a flavorful find, adding authenticity to any dish.

16. G Hughes Smokehouse Sugar-Free BBQ Sauce

G Hughes Smokehouse Sugar-Free BBQ Sauce offers a guilt-free indulgence for those monitoring their sugar intake. Surprisingly rich and smoky, it manages to deliver depth without the cloying sweetness of traditional sauces. This makes it a perfect choice for keto enthusiasts and low-carb dieters.

The sauce’s ability to maintain flavor integrity without added sugars is commendable. It’s a reminder that dietary restrictions shouldn’t mean sacrificing taste. With G Hughes, enjoying a delicious BBQ meal is not just possible—it’s deliciously attainable. It’s proof that healthy can still mean flavorful.

17. Dinosaur Bar-B-Que Sensuous Slathering Sauce

Dinosaur Bar-B-Que Sensuous Slathering Sauce hails from upstate New York and has achieved cult status for a reason. Its spicy, smoky, and slightly sweet profile creates a dynamic flavor that enhances any BBQ dish. It’s a sauce that invites exploration, with every layer offering something new.

The combination of spices ensures a memorable taste experience, perfect for those who crave complexity in their sauces. Whether you’re grilling or roasting, Dinosaur Bar-B-Que adds a sensuous touch to your meal. It’s a must-try for anyone looking to elevate their barbecue game.

18. Bachan’s Japanese Barbecue Sauce

Bachan’s Japanese Barbecue Sauce offers a distinctive take on traditional barbecue. This soy-based, umami-packed gem is perfect for those seeking a savory alternative to the usual fare. It pairs beautifully with grilled meats, rice bowls, or even wings, offering versatility beyond expectation.

Its unique flavor profile reflects a fusion of Japanese culinary traditions with modern BBQ tastes. For those eager to explore global flavors, Bachan’s provides a gateway to culinary creativity. It’s a note-worthy addition to any kitchen, promising a flavor-packed journey with every dish.

19. Sweet Baby Ray’s No Sugar Added Hickory

Sweet Baby Ray’s No Sugar Added Hickory is a rare find where a lighter version genuinely satisfies. By removing the excess sugar, this sauce delivers a balanced, smoky flavor that many original versions fail to achieve. It’s a testament to how less can truly be more.

For those wary of overly sweet sauces, this version offers a refreshing alternative. The hickory notes stand out, making it ideal for those who crave a more authentic BBQ flavor. It’s a lighter choice that doesn’t compromise on taste, perfect for health-conscious grillers.

20. Williamson Bros. Bar-B-Q Sauce

Williamson Bros. Bar-B-Q Sauce delivers a thinner, vinegar-forward flavor reminiscent of beloved Southern BBQ traditions. Its tangy profile makes it perfect for basting or dipping, accentuating the meat’s natural flavors without overpowering them. This sauce is a reminder of the charm found in simplicity.

For those who appreciate a vinegar-based sauce, Williamson Bros. offers an authentic experience that stands out among the sweeter options. It’s a taste of the South in every bottle, capturing the essence of regional BBQ with integrity and passion.