10 Best And 5 Worst Sandwiches To Order At Jimmy John’s

Jimmy John’s is known for its “freaky fast” sandwiches, but not all subs are created equal. With a menu full of options ranging from light and fresh to salty and gut-busting, it’s worth knowing which sandwiches are worth your order—and which ones might leave you underwhelmed, overloaded, or just plain disappointed. Here’s a rundown of the 10 best and 5 worst sandwiches at Jimmy John’s, based on flavor, value, and nutrition.

1. The Vito (Italian Sub)

Bursting with Italian flair, The Vito is a cold-cut classic done right. Salami, capicola, and provolone unite under a drizzle of zesty Italian vinaigrette. The combination of meats provides a bold flavor, yet doesn’t overwhelm. Its savory delight is balanced by just the right amount of crunch from fresh veggies. Whether you’re a fan of Italian cuisine or just craving something hearty yet fulfilling, The Vito is a reliable choice. Every bite takes you through the taste of Italy, making it a standout favorite in the sub world.

2. J.J.B.L.T.

For those who seek simple, salty, and crispy perfection, the J.J.B.L.T. delivers. The bacon is plentiful and cooked to a perfect crisp, while the lettuce and tomato add a refreshing balance. This sandwich is a no-frills favorite, embodying everything you love about a classic BLT. It’s crafted with care, each layer contributing to a symphony of taste. The J.J.B.L.T. is a testament to how simplicity can triumph in the culinary world, making it an irresistible choice for bacon lovers everywhere.

3. Turkey Tom

A go-to for the health-conscious, the Turkey Tom is lean, tasty, and easily customizable. Its simplicity shines through with sliced turkey breast, fresh lettuce, and tomatoes. To elevate this classic, adding avocado spread offers a creamy upgrade. Perfect for those mindful of their waistline yet unwilling to compromise on flavor, this sandwich strikes the right balance between taste and nutrition. Turkey Tom is more than just a healthy choice; it’s a delightful experience in every bite.

4. Pepe (Ham & Cheese)

In the world of sandwiches, sometimes basic is best, and Pepe’s ham and cheese creation is a testament to that. Featuring a great balance of ham and provolone, this sandwich shines, especially when served on wheat bread or as an Unwich. Its flavors are straightforward yet full of warmth, providing a wholesome experience with each bite. It’s perfect for those days when you seek something simple yet satisfying. Pepe wraps comfort and taste in a neat package, making it a solid choice for sandwich lovers.

5. Club Lulu

Combining the best of two worlds, turkey and bacon, Club Lulu is a leaner alternative to the Hunter’s Club, with just as much flavor and crunch. The turkey’s mild taste contrasts beautifully with the crispy bacon, while lettuce and tomato add freshness. Club Lulu offers a satisfying bite that doesn’t skimp on taste. It’s a delightful surprise that provides richness without the heaviness, ensuring it remains a top pick among sandwich enthusiasts.

6. Beach Club

The Beach Club transports you to a sunny getaway with its fresh and balanced ingredients. Turkey and provolone create a creamy base, complemented by avocado spread and crisp cucumbers. This choice is perfect for those who seek a refreshing and light meal. Its satisfying taste captures the essence of a beach picnic, where every bite is a breath of fresh air. The Beach Club is a testament to how delightful fresh ingredients can be when artfully combined.

7. Jimmy Cubano

For a sandwich that packs a flavorful punch, Jimmy Cubano is a bold pick. Ham, bacon, Dijon mustard, and pickles create a symphony of taste that dances on your palate. While it can be enjoyed as is, toasting it at home elevates the flavors to new heights. It’s a sandwich that doesn’t shy away from strong flavors, offering a robust experience for those in search of something distinctive and satisfying.

8. Bootlegger Club

A meat-lover’s dream, the Bootlegger Club combines roast beef and turkey in a light yet satisfying manner. Despite its hearty ingredients, it maintains a clean and delightful taste. The marriage of roast beef and turkey creates a unique flavor profile, while fresh veggies add a burst of freshness. It’s perfect for those who enjoy a protein-packed meal without feeling weighed down, making it a favorite among sandwich aficionados.

9. Tuna Salad

In-house crafted and surprisingly tasty, the Tuna Salad sandwich offers creamy and flavorful goodness. The richness of tuna is perfectly complemented by fresh veggies like cucumber or pickles, adding a satisfying crunch. It’s a delightful surprise for seafood lovers looking for a unique sandwich experience. Despite its simplicity, it stands out on the menu, ensuring every bite is both refreshing and full of flavor.

10. Slim 5 (Salami, Capicola, and Cheese)

For those who appreciate simplicity, Slim 5 offers a straightforward yet delightful experience. Italian salami, capicola, and provolone cheese come together to create a clean, flavorful bite without the veggie overload. It’s a great base to build on with your own add-ons, allowing customization to suit personal tastes. This sandwich embodies a minimalist approach while still delivering on taste, making it a beloved choice for Italian meat lovers.

11. The Gargantuan

The Gargantuan is aptly named, presenting a monster challenge with its five meats and cheese. While it might excite those with hearty appetites, the overwhelming size, salt, and fat content can be daunting. It’s more of a challenge meal than a sensible lunch option. For those daring enough, it offers a whirlwind of flavors, but it may leave you feeling more exhausted than satisfied. It’s a spectacle on a plate, best approached with caution.

12. Hunter’s Club

With double roast beef and cheese, the Hunter’s Club sounds appealing but may fall short of expectations. Its dryness and heaviness overshadow the experience, lacking standout flavors unless you add extras. While it may attract meat lovers, it doesn’t quite hit the mark in delivering a balanced taste. It serves as a reminder that sometimes, less is more, and the right combination is key to a fulfilling sandwich experience.

13. Big John (Roast Beef Only)

Big John offers a straightforward experience with its lean roast beef, but it might seem bland. Without additional textures or flavors, this sandwich is a blank canvas. Unless you’re a roast beef enthusiast, it misses the mark, lacking the intrigue found in more elaborate creations. It’s a reminder that even simplicity needs a touch of creativity. Adding sauces or toppings can transform it, but on its own, it doesn’t quite satisfy.

14. Slim 1 (Ham Only)

Slim 1 is a prime example of how simplicity can sometimes fall flat. With its basic ham on bread, it offers little excitement or value. Priced high for its simplicity, it doesn’t bring much to the table. Unless you’re in the mood for minimalism, it’s easy to be left wanting more. While it’s a quick option, it lacks the creativity and flavor that make a sandwich memorable, leaving it among the less favorable choices.

15. Slim 4 (Turkey Only)

Slim 4 follows a similar path as its ham counterpart, offering turkey without additional flair. It’s hardly a sandwich, lacking cheese, veggies, or sauce. This simplicity may appeal to those seeking an ultra-basic meal, but for most, it feels incomplete. It serves as a reminder of how crucial complementary ingredients are in creating a satisfying sandwich. Without them, it remains an unfulfilled promise, leaving you searching for something more.